from the only-option-when-it's-clear-you-can't-reform-this dept

NYC Mayor Mamdani Disbands NYPD Unit That Treated Protesters Like Terrorists

by · Techdirt

It’s taken pretty much forever, but finally one of the NYPD’s worst specialist units is being disbanded. The catalyst here was the election of a mayor who was finally serious about holding the NYPD in check. For years, the city’s mayors have done whatever they can to keep the cop shop happy, including the last mayor, who went deep down a corruption hole to make sure both he and NYPD remained happy, even if his constituents weren’t.

Here’s what’s happening to the NYPD’s “Strategic Response Group” now that the city is run by a mayor that’s not going to allow a decade-plus of constant civil rights abuses to continue.

A controversial New York Police Department unit accused of using excessive force against protesters has been disbanded, Mayor Zohran Mamdani and NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced Monday, fulfilling a key campaign promise from the mayor to separate protest policing from counterterrorism.

Along with the elimination of the Strategic Response Group, certain aggressive crowd-management tactics are now banned and new dialogue-focused units will be established in the NYPD and the Mayor’s Office of Community Safety to ensure a coordinated response to protests, the mayor and commissioner said in a statement.

If you’re wondering about the controversy of this particular unit, you have to take a trip in the wayback machine to 2015, which was when NYPD Commissioner and the mayor who never was the reformer he pretended to be (Bill de Blasio) decided a single unit could handle three very different aspects of policing, somehow without causing collateral damage to Constitutional rights. (Or maybe they didn’t actually belive this and chose to do it anyway.)

The SRG got folded in with an existing counterterrorism unit, apparently because the mayor and police commissioner decided fighting terrorism and policing protests was roughly the same thing. A few years later, documents obtained by journalists made it clear SRG officers were routinely brutalizing peaceful protesters. This wasn’t much of a surprise, considering its counterterrorism unit was known for routinely violating rights while engaging in extremely biased policing/surveillance. That this infection would spread to the SRG is completely unsurprising. Bad apples, etc.

This unit should have been disbanded once this information was made public. But it wasn’t. Given that regular NYPD patrol officers are just as capable of violating people’s rights, it hardly made sense to provide specialist pay for rote thuggery. But the SRG kept on keeping on… right up until NYC residents made it explicitly clear they were sick of the same old bullshit from their mayors.

The disbanding of this unit has the support of the current police commissioner. And it goes further than just rearranging some deck chairs so SRG officers can get back to the rights-violation business elsewhere. It also establishes a “First Amendment Support Team” in the NYPD that will help train and support officers who are asked to police protests.

In addition, “kettling” protesters is no longer an option. The popular — and extremely abusive — tactic is used by plenty of PDs around the nation. Under the guise of breaking up a demonstration, officers surround protesters, physically force them into a confined area, and then rain down pepper balls and tear gas on protesters whose only other option is to physically force their way out of the “kettle.” This, of course, leads to even more police violence, as well as trumped-up “assaulting an officer” charges as people try to escape this form of mass imprisonment.

The dissolution order also says this, which is pretty fucking wild:

[T]he use of bicycles as weapons will be allowed only when preventing death or physical injury to an officer or another person.

That’s the sort of thing I would normally only expect from CIA operatives who moonlight as folk singers (watch all the way to the end):

[If you haven’t watched the Prime series “Patriot,” you’re only hurting yourself.]

You can’t reform a unit that has been given the greenlight to be as awful as it can be for nearly a decade. The only fix is shutting it down and starting over with an emphasis on making officers realize that people’s rights are just as important as their safety. If this leads to more officers resigning or retiring because they don’t want to work for an employer that expects them to respect the law… GOOD. New York City residents are better off without them.