Mia Wurgaft and Jake Horowitz in The Charioteer, at the Cell.Photo: Austin Ruffer

The Charioteer Contains Some of the Most Haunting Images I Saw This Year

by · VULTURE

If you like your theater intimate and your anticapitalism extreme, you still have four more chances to catch Dan Giles’s remarkable new two-hander The Charioteer at the Cell. This compact theater, hiding out in a converted living room in Chelsea, has been producing a steady stream of ambitious and fascinating new works. Giles’s is, by far, the most assured, exciting, and heartbreaking thing I’ve seen there yet.

ad-position slots="mobile_article_body"

The Charioteer is only 75 minutes long, yet still the play takes its time when it needs to, and every one of those minutes feels meticulously crafted and deployed. Under Matt Dickson’s precise, illuminating direction, the excellent Jake Horowitz and Mia Wurgaft play a pair of siblings facing each other through the flames of a burning world. At the start, it’s 2013 and Wurgaft’s Charly is 17, visiting her older brother, Owen (Horowitz), at UMass Amherst, where he has landed after, to their parents’ loud dismay, dropping out of Harvard. In a dude-chic dorm room — messy bed, empty Natty Light cans, Baywatch poster that takes up a full wall — the pair maneuver around each other at once carefully and with deep affection, two animals who were raised in the same nest renegotiating language and territory as their budding adult selves. Charly longs to tell Owen that she’s gay; Owen wants to tell Charly all about the “Occupy House”, the revelations he’s had while reading the Bhagavad Gita, and the fact that he’s moving toward a life even farther from their parents’ ideal than Charly has imagined. “There’s this group in West Virginia,” he says. “More or less off the grid … They’re serious about degrowth and de-industrialization. Climate stuff … We need to break the machine. We have to do it fast. And at a global scale. The only answer is spiritual warfare. These people, they’re serious, they’re disciplined, they’re doing the work. [I] want to be a part of that.”

ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic desktop_article_body mobile_leaderboard"

The Charioteer is split down the middle, and as the play crosses that fissure, Cat Raynor’s set smartly shifts to show us Charly’s apartment in Brooklyn in 2023. Owen’s cruddy dorm room is still visible, though, suspended in a moat of shadow, just as that first encounter still occupies a significant internal space for both brother and sister. Charly has been trying to grapple with the world by living in it: She’s a public defender. Owen went to West Virginia and now he has come limping back into Charly’s life, unbathed and spiritually unmoored, a nasty wound festering on his foot. (He’s “done his homework on antibiotics” he tells Charly, to which she seethes, “How are you so smart and so fucking stupid?”) The gaps in Giles’s play are as pregnant and wrenching as its dialogue. (What happened to Owen’s foot? What about ten years ago, when Charly blacked out at the college party full of young radicals she went to with her brother?) Charly and Owen can say much to each other, but not everything. Especially in the show’s latter half, playwright, director, and actors expertly evoke the feeling of two people speaking across an abyss. Does it matter if one reaches out? The chasm is too wide, too deep. The exigencies of a ravaged planet and a corroded social contract have swept up these two souls like the chaos of a great storm, tearing them apart, flinging them to separate shores.

ad-position slots="desktop_article_body mobile_leaderboard"

Giles’s title comes from — as Owen calls it with bro-ish familiarity when he’s still an aspiring revolutionary — “the Gita.” (“It’s one of those books that finds you at the right time,” he adds, in a perfect blend of youthful pontification and core-level earnestness.) The charioteer is in fact the god Krishna in disguise. He reveals himself to a prince, the hero whose chariot he’s piloting, to show him that “he and his enemies are part of a greater design.” Owen’s voice thrills as he tells Charly the story — he’s letting his sister in on his new scripture. “The destinies of everyone in the universe,” he tells her, are “all woven together.” The prince has been hesitant to attack his foes, but, says the god, “I have already killed these men — you are merely my instrument. You can’t kill someone who’s already dead.”

ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"

Owen’s glittering eyes as he inhales the fumes of righteous certainty, Charly’s rapt face and stone-still form as she watches her brother, reaching for the light, walking toward the dark — both are some of the most haunting images I’ve seen onstage this year. Surely The Charioteer will ride again. It has too much to say, and too great a resonance in all that it leaves unsaid, to go quietly to stable.

ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"

The Charioteer is at the Cell through November 22.

ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"