Editorial: Tobacco veto – fair hearing wanted
A small island-economy needs flexibility and tax sovereignty to counter the gravitational pull of Europe’s astronomical powerhouse economies
by Times Of Malta · Times of Malta
The EU tobacco tax reform has stalled after Malta withheld its support at the ECOFIN Council, leaving 26 member states behind a compromise that cannot pass without unanimity.
Raising minimum excise rates on cigarettes and other tobacco products is one of several pillars in the European Commission’s new strategy to raise intra-community revenue.
But duties belong to taxation, and every member state holds a veto – Malta has decided to stall the game. Finance Minister Clyde Caruana said Malta supports the objectives of the reform but objected mainly to raising the minimum tax rate every three years in line with inflation; and adjusting to differences in price levels between member states, which would mean that countries where the cost of living is more expensive have higher floor rates.
When the increase in any tax risks having a disproportionate effect on a small economy like Malta’s, it is right that objections are raised.
At €109 million, tobacco duties are just 1.2% of total tax revenue in Malta; 77% of the price of a pack of cigarettes is tax (the EU average is 81%) – that means Malta has further to climb than most in raising tobacco excise, ultimately raising the average price of a pack of cigarettes in Malta by 60c to 80c, with rolling tobacco prices rising by a steeper €1.27.
It is unclear whether higher tobacco prices could feed Malta’s cost-of-living adjustment through the Retail Price Index; or whether a sin tax punishes a low-income group that the Labour government is not keen to rile.
Clearly, European Commissioner for Tax Wopke Hoekstra’s visit to Malta must be carrying a broader agenda, for Malta has already signalled that the EC’s plan to tax member states’ industries directly, offsetting a part of the contribution the government pays as a percentage of gross national income (GNI), could hurt the island disproportionately to other wealthier member states.
The five new sources proposed for the EU’s budget are the emissions trading scheme; the CBAM duty on imports from countries which do not have strict carbon emissions rules; the TEDOR tobacco duty; and a levy on non-collected electrical and electronic equipment.
The major sticking point for Malta is certainly the corporate resource for Europe (CORE), which would levy companies with annual €100 million in net turnover, anything between €100,000 and €750,000, depending on their turnover bracket – and this targets the island’s profitable industries with a levy on total revenue.
Vetoes are serious matters, and a small member state’s objection should not be dismissed lightly – the Maltese government must always make its case, sometimes loudly, because harmonised taxation from Brussels on micro-economies like ours does not necessarily have identical economic consequences for each member state.
Tobacco duty reform has a clear aim: fixing a European framework that has not kept up to date with new tobacco products, to address EU-wide variations on tax. It is not simply a quick fix to raise cash.
Malta can choose to allow the rest of Europe to forge ahead – not by agreeing, but by abstaining with clear reservations.
But that sensible middle-ground must be a two-way road. Hoekstra should return to Brussels with a clear understanding of the way the Maltese economy functions at the European periphery and its heavy dependence on the service economy: a small island-economy needs flexibility and tax sovereignty to counter the gravitational pull of Europe’s astronomical powerhouse economies.
Yet the suspicion remains that the government’s resistance owes as much to fear of upsetting voters as to defending Malta’s economic interests. Is a tax on tobacco really the battle on which Malta should stake its veto?
Sign up to our free newsletters
Get the latest stories and updates from Times of Malta delivered straight to your inbox.