Minister defends work carried out in a personal capacity as questions persist over the report's whereabouts Photo: Christian Sant Fournier

Caruana received between €80,000 and €90,000 for unpublished population report

Finance minister says he compiled the 300-page report in a personal capacity, denying a conflict of interest

by · Times of Malta

Updated at 5.35pm with PN's reaction

Finance Minister Clyde Caruana said he was paid between €80,000 and €90,000 to compile a report on the impact of rapid population growth on various sectors of the country, which has never been published.

Caruana revealed the amount in parliament on Tuesday after PN MP Michael Piccinino asked how much he had been paid to prepare the report and in what capacity he had carried out the work.

“I have no problem answering this at all. That work was done within a personal capacity; I did it as an economist, and it was not done during work hours. In fact, I said that it took me around a year. “

He continued, “Please appreciate that this was around eight years ago, but I believe it was given or taken, between 80,000 to 90,000 euros”

The existence of the 300-page report, drawn up when Caruana was CEO of the Employment and Training Corporation, was confirmed by the minister in previous comments to Times of Malta.

On Tuesday, Piccinino also questioned Caruana over the potential conflict of interest as the author of the report.

Caruana defended his position, arguing that he was entitled to express professional opinions independently of his official role.

He added that the critical remarks he occasionally makes were further evidence of this.

However, the report in the centre of this ongoing back and forth has yet to be published, with questions mounting over its whereabouts and who is responsible for releasing it.

Last week, PN MP Adrian Delia asked Caruana in parliament to publish the report. Caruana replied that he was its author but not the destination of the report.

On Monday, the Finance Minister confirmed that the report had been passed on to the Office of the Prime Minister during Joseph Muscat's tenure as prime minister.

He said he would publish the report if he obtained written permission to do so.

A day earlier, Prime Minister Robert Abela said he had neither seen the report nor had a copy of it.

The issue also prompted a light-hearted exchange in parliament on Tuesday.

As Piccinino questioned Caruana about the report, Abela entered the chamber.

The prime minister walked towards Caruana, patted him on the back and jokingly asked: “Found it?”

The report remains unpublished.

Caruana continues to avoid publishing the report: PN

In a statement reacting to Caruana's comments, the Nationalist Party said the Finance Minister continues to avoid publishing the report, which the country paid thousands for. 

The PN said less than 48 hours after Abela told journalists to ask Caruana for the report, Caruana himself told Parliament that he could not publish it without the Prime Minister's written permission.

"The public paid for this report out of their own pockets. And today, they continue to pay dearly through their quality of life because the Government buried this report," the statement said.

"The least the Government can do now is publish the report paid for by the public. Unless, of course, it has something to hide."

Sign up to our free newsletters

Get the latest stories and updates from Times of Malta delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscribe