A letter of apology after five years
Five years after cannabis reform, Malta must confront its past injustices and make restorative justice more than an unfulfilled promise, writes Andrew Bonello
by Contributors · Times of MaltaDear Daniel Holmes, five years have passed since Malta began building a legal, regulated framework for the recreational use of cannabis.
You are no longer behind bars but the injustice done to you – and to many others – has not disappeared with the passage of time. You were arrested in 2006 for cultivating cannabis at your home in Gozo. You insisted the plants were for your personal use. In 2011, you were sentenced to 10 years’ imprisonment and fined €23,000. You served more than a decade before your release in 2024.
For that, on behalf of the Maltese state and its institutions, an apology is owed: not a polite expression of regret but a public acknowledgment that a person should never have been subjected to such a punitive response for a non-violent cannabis-related offence.
Where is social justice, what happened to restorative justice?
Adults may now possess limited amounts of cannabis, cultivate a small number of plants at home and obtain cannabis through licensed, non-profit cannabis harm reduction associations. This has brought no small change for various people, including the state-run Authority for the Responsible Use of Cannabis (ARUC).
In fact, between 2023 and 2026, the ARUC generated around €700,000 in profit from the sales and licensing of cannabis. This is a significant amount and one which should make us all wonder. How is this money being reinvested in the cannabis community? How could this money be used for restorative justice, such as in the cases of Holmes, Marie-Claire Camilleri, Christopher Bartolo and many more?
Reform cannot be measured only by what is now permitted. It must also be measured by what the state does to repair past harms. Social justice means more than opening a semi-legal market. It means recognising that the people most harmed by prohibition were often ordinary people, consumers, small-scale growers, parents, workers and young adults. Are these people fully protected today?
The legal changes criminalising drivers for detecting cannabis in saliva instead of measuring impairment and the breach of privacy for home growers accused of “public nuisance due to cannabis odours” are clear examples of how the legislator seems to have forgotten his initial promises of respecting human rights and dignity.
ReLeaf has long argued that all cannabis possession charges and other non-violent cannabis convictions should be automatically expunged from the fedina penali and that people still imprisoned for such offences should be released, with practical support to re-enter society. That principle remains central.
A modern cannabis policy that ignores yesterday’s legal harms, such as the disproportionate sentencing for cannabis related charges, is cruel and dangerous. A similar environment is a poor attempt to cover up the ‘negative consequences of the war on drugs’, including the documented human rights abuses experienced in prison.
Five years, five changes
ReLeaf marks this fifth anniversary not with complacency but with five commitments for the next stage of reform.
Put social and restorative justice first. Introduce a full, transparent record-expungement process for past non-violent cannabis offences. Establish a dedicated support programme for people formerly imprisoned or prosecuted, including legal aid, employment support, counselling and, where appropriate, compensation.
Guarantee meaningful representation. People who use cannabis, former prisoners, harm-reduction specialists and community organisations must have a permanent seat in policy-making bodies such as the National Addictions Board and the Authority for the Responsible Use of Cannabis. Regulation should not be designed only by enforcement bodies and officials; it must include the voices of those most affected.
Demand corporate responsibility. Associations must remain genuinely non-profit and community-driven, including how the authority for the responsible use of cannabis uses money generated from the reform. Transparency and accountability for the regulatory body must be non-negotiable.
Protect environmental sustainability. Ensure associations are provided with government grants to ensure sustainability during the cultivation, packaging and waste process. The availability of ‘no-plastic’ options for packaging and the use of renewable energy are already being adopted across other markets... why leave recreational cannabis out?
Protect home growers and the right to privacy. Ensuring home growers are afforded with equal legal rights to expand cultivation expertise and operations according to personal needs, including the right to privacy and autonomy. No to invasive practices such as the need to register in a cannabis registry as proposed by Caritas in 2025.
An apology must become action. A country that admits its mistakes, repairs the damage and builds a system grounded in dignity, evidence, sustainability and fairness is possible... we just need the right mind set and people to implement change.
Andrew Bonello is the president of ReLeaf Malta.
Sign up to our free newsletters
Get the latest stories and updates from Times of Malta delivered straight to your inbox.