I tested Google's 3 storage tools; I finally understand why my Pixel kept nagging me

My Google Pixel kept nagging me about storage, which felt ridiculous given I'm paying for 2TB on Google One.

Every few days, another warning that I couldn't save new photos until I cleared something out.

It made no sense at first, since I have more cloud storage sitting unused than most people will ever need in a lifetime. Yet, the phone in my hand kept acting broke on a regular basis.

So I looked for a fix, the same way someone else did after nearly filling a 256GB Pixel despite paying for a cloud plan.

I tested three Google tools to free up valuable space on my phone: Google Photos, Files by Google, and Google One's storage manager.

I assumed all three were fighting for the same job, since they're Google tools and technically about storage. They weren't, and figuring that out mattered more than any of the numbers I ended up with.

Related

I back up data using an open source app, and I may never need Google Drive again

There's a way to save on a Google One subscription

Posts By  Akshay Bhalla

Google Photos cleared phone storage without me lifting a finger

13.6GB gone in a matter of seconds

Google Photos has a Free up space option buried in the app's settings. It deletes photos and videos from your phone after they're safely backed up to the cloud, nothing more complicated than that.

I tapped it, confirmed I trusted the backup, and it cleared 13.6GB almost instantly, with no major waiting times. I didn't have to sort files from a folder or decide whether to keep some and permanently lose the rest. The operation was hands down seamless.

This method only touches your phone's storage. The photos stay where they were in the cloud; they're just no longer duplicated on the device. I can always view them by timeline wherever I want to.

Files by Google picked up what Photos couldn't touch

Good for documents, not much else for me

Photos and videos weren't the only problem.

Years of documents, PDFs, and downloaded files were hogging my phone storage, and Google Photos had no idea they existed.

Files by Google earned its spot right here. I went through the Clean tab category by category, folder by folder, and deleted documents I didn't need.

It only added up to a few hundred MBs, since these files are significantly smaller than photos and videos. But it was space Photos was never going to touch, since it's not built for that kind of stuff.

It also served as a great file organization tool. I decluttered redundant files, which made it easier to find the relevant ones among all the junk. But that's a bonus.

Both tools solved the same underlying problem, only from a different angle.

Google One wasn't fixing my phone at all

It pointed me at a completely different problem

Google One's storage manager felt like it belonged on the space-saving list, and it does, but not for the same reason as the previous two tools.

It didn't free up a single byte on my phone.

What it did was flag large files sitting inside my Google Photos library in the cloud, ones I'd forgotten I had sitting there taking up room. I went in, deleted the ones I didn't need, and freed up almost 20GB of cloud storage.

That's a different kind of storage issue, the one that could make you pay more for cloud storage later on.

My phone wasn't any less crowded afterward. My Google One quota was, and I hadn't even realized that was a separate thing worth checking.

I'd been treating the "storage problem" as one thing this whole time. It's actually two, and nothing I'd tried so far had made that obvious until now.

Two tools fixed my phone; one fixed something I didn't know was broken

Fixing one never fixed the other

Google Photos and Files by Google freed up ample storage on the device I was holding. Google One never touched that number. It went after freeing a major chunk of my cloud space.

Neither kind of full felt urgent on its own. Together, they were why I kept getting nagged no matter which one I fixed first, since fixing one never addressed the other.

I'm turning on Smart Storage, so I can stop doing this by hand

Automating one problem, keeping the other manual

Google Photos' Free up space button is the manual version of a Pixel feature called Smart Storage. It does essentially the same cleanup but automatically, when backed-up media has sat on the device for a specific number of days.

Given how often this keeps happening, I'm setting mine to 30 days instead of doing this by hand every few months and waiting for another warning to remind me.

I'm not the first person here to fix this by flipping a Google Photos setting I'd ignored for years, and I doubt I'll be the last.

Google One, though, stays manual. That's not a problem I want automated without me first looking at what's being deleted, since it touches my cloud backups and not just device clutter.