Days before SJSU decided to sue the federal government to challenge a federal Title IX investigation over its volleyball scandal, trans activists held a meeting where they berated administrators and demanded the school defy the Trump admin.
SJSU volleyball finishes near bottom of conference as Trump admin battle, coach allegations loom over program
by Jackson Thompson · Fox NewsThe San José State University's women's volleyball program continued a steep decline after its infamous trans athlete scandal, as the fallout of the scandal continues to linger for the university in multiple legal battles.
The program's 2026 season ended on Thursday with this year's team finishing near the bottom of the Mountain West Conference.
The Spartans finished ninth out of 10 teams in the conference, with a 9-20 overall record and just four conference victories. The team closed its season Thursday with a five-set loss to UNLV, missing the conference tournament for the second consecutive year.
The disappointing finish marks a sharp contrast to 2024, when SJSU reached the Mountain West championship match amid a national controversy over transgender athlete Blaire Fleming's participation on its women's team, and public resistance by female teammate Brooke Slusser.
That season triggered multiple lawsuits, federal investigations and a political conflict that has continued well beyond the departure of the athletes at the center of the original dispute. At least seven of the team's players entered the transfer portal right after the 2024 season ended, as the program has declined for two straight seasons since that controversial season.
INSIDE THE FALLOUT OF THE SJSU VOLLEYBALL SCANDAL: ‘THIS IS AN OBVIOUS PROBLEM’
In 2026, the controversy expanded. SJSU sued the Trump administration over federal Title IX findings against the university.
New allegations of misconduct surfaced against head coach Todd Kress, including an alleged physical assault involving a former player at another university nearly three decades ago. And a former assistant coach filed a new lawsuit alleging retaliation, religious discrimination and intimidation.
Despite the legal disputes and allegations, Kress remains the program's head coach and appears to still be the public face of its future. On Tuesday, Nov. 17, SJSU's athletic department announced the signing of six recruits for the 2027 season, featuring individual evaluations from Kress praising the incoming athletes and discussing their expected roles in the program.
In July, Fox News Digital first reported that a former Fairfield University volleyball player had accused Kress of physically assaulting her during a team trip in 1998.
The woman, who has remained anonymous publicly, alleged that Kress physically restrained and humiliated her in a hotel room and pressured her to consume alcohol.
She said she notified SJSU athletic director Jeff Konya in October 2024 because she was concerned about the safety of women playing under Kress, as documents show that former SJSU legal counsel Peter Lim thanked her and her attorney for meeting with him to discuss the allegations in November of that year.
On Tuesday, OutKick reported new correspondence in which SJSU Vice President for People and Culture Harly Neumann confirmed the university reviewed the woman's complaint but said it lacked authority to pursue allegations involving conduct at another institution before Kress's employment.
"The University takes all reports seriously. The University has established processes for reviewing and addressing such reports and followed those here," Neumann wrote.
"However, SJSU’s authority to investigate allegations is limited to matters that occurred within its educational programs and activities."
Neumann also acknowledged the university's responsibility to consider information relevant to the safety of current student-athletes.
The former player disputed the university's explanation, questioning whether officials evaluated her allegations alongside complaints involving Kress's conduct at SJSU.
Fairfield University also addressed the matter in a statement to Fox News Digital.
"Fairfield University unequivocally condemns sexual assault, sexual violence, harassment, and all forms of sexual misconduct. Such behavior has no place at Fairfield or in any community. As a Jesuit Catholic University, we are committed to the dignity and inherent worth of every person and to fostering a community grounded in respect, care, and responsibility for one another," Fairfield said.
The university did not disclose whether it investigated the alleged 1998 incident.
The season unfolded while the university fought a separate battle over the federal government's interpretation of Title IX.
In January, the U.S. Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights concluded that SJSU violated Title IX during the 2022-2024 volleyball seasons by allowing a transgender athlete to compete on its women's team and by failing to adequately address complaints from female athletes.
The investigation began in February 2025, after President Donald Trump returned to office and issued an executive order directing federal agencies to restrict transgender participation in women's sports.
The Education Department's findings alleged that SJSU denied women equal athletic opportunities and mishandled discrimination complaints. Federal officials proposed a resolution agreement requiring changes to university policies and remedial measures for affected athletes.
SJSU and the California State University system rejected the findings, maintaining that the university followed the applicable NCAA rules and state and federal law during the seasons in question.
In March, the Education Department escalated the dispute by issuing a letter warning of potential enforcement action after SJSU declined to enter the proposed agreement.
The California State University system responded with a federal lawsuit challenging the investigation and the administration's attempt to impose sanctions over past conduct.
A subsequent court arrangement established protections against immediate disruption of federal funding while providing a process for expedited litigation if the administration moves to withhold funds.
That dispute remains a separate legal issue from the allegations against Kress.
Meanwhile, former associate head coach Melissa Batie-Smoose escalated her legal fight against SJSU in October.
THE CRAIG CARTON SHOW–UNFILTERED, UNAPOLOGETIC AND UNMISSABLE. DOWNLOAD HIS DAILY PODCAST NOW!
Batie-Smoose filed a new federal complaint on Oct. 13, alleging that university officials retaliated against her after she raised concerns about transgender participation on the women's volleyball team.
ZERO BS. JUST DAKICH. TAKE THE DON'T @ ME PODCAST ON THE ROAD. DOWNLOAD NOW!
Her lawsuit includes claims of political and religious discrimination and accuses Kress of intimidating behavior.
STAY "FEARLESS" ON THE GO! TAKE TOMI LAHREN WITH YOU. DOWNLOAD THE TLIF PODCAST NOW!
The complaint alleges that Kress mocked her support for Trump, reduced her responsibilities and subjected her to confrontations that made her feel physically unsafe.
SIGN UP FOR THE DAILY OUTKICK NEWSLETTER
It also includes allegations concerning Kress's treatment of female athletes.
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP
Batie-Smoose was suspended during the 2024 season, and her contract was subsequently not renewed.
Jackson Thompson is a sports reporter for Fox News Digital covering critical political and cultural issues in sports, with an investigative lens. Jackson's reporting has been cited in federal government actions related to the enforcement of Title IX, and in legacy media outlets including The New York Times, The Los Angeles Times, The Philadelphia Inquirer, The Associated Press and ESPN.com.