Austin Wells did more than reward the Yankees’ belief in him with huge Game 1

If Brian Cashman had acted as most expected him to act at the trade deadline, Austin Wells would not have taken his second-inning at-bat. 

Facing lefty Payton Tolle, this was a game reserved for a righty-hitting catcher. Maybe Ryan Jeffers, who might as well have been looking for a New York apartment considering the months of speculation.

Access the Yankees beat like never before

Join Post Sports+ for exciting subscriber-only features, including real-time texting with Greg Joyce about the inside buzz on the Yankees.

Try it free

Or maybe the switch-hitting Adley Rutschman, another potential Yankees target who was behind the plate Tuesday because he was redirected instead to the Red Sox, who overwhelmed the Orioles with their trade package. 

But Cashman did not pull the trigger on finding another catcher, even a complement, and so Wells — who had been among the worst hitters in baseball at that point — only saw his stranglehold on the starting job strengthen. 

That move — or rather lack of move — sure looked smart when Wells took that second-inning at-bat and drove in the only run the Yankees would need. 

The Yankees’ starting catcher (and with all due respect to Ali Sánchez, their only catcher) breathed even more life into his revitalized season in the Yankees’ 9-0 statement of a victory over Boston in The Bronx to move one win from an ALDS date with the Rays. 

Before the Yankees ran away late in the game, their offense had started with promise but only promise: Prior to Wells stepping up for his first at-bat, the club had gone 0-for-3 with runners in scoring position and was threatening to waste another opportunity. In the frame, George Lombard Jr. opened with a single, moved to second on a one-out knock from Anthony Volpe and then watched as Spencer Jones fouled out for the second out. 

But the lefty-hitting Wells — who batted .122 with a .436 OPS against southpaws this season — ripped a single through the right side of the infield and was fired up upon reaching first base after giving the Yankees a lead they only padded from there. 

Wells added a second single off a lefty — Alec Gamboa in the seventh inning, plus a sacrifice fly in the eighth against Brayan Bello — to make it two hits off southpaws in the postseason, which is remarkable for a player who had 11 hits (in 99 plate appearances) against such pitching all season. 

His inability against pitching of all types through the middle of July ensured the Yankees tested the trade market. Wells was hitting .152 with a .501 OPS on July 19. As much as they valued his rapport with pitchers and his defense, he had nearly become unplayable. 

Shop Yankees Merch

New Era 2026 Postseason 59Fifty Fitted Hat

Celebrate the Yankees’ playoff run with the official New Era 2026 Postseason fitted hat. Features a classic navy design and side patch.

$52.99
Fanatics
Buy Now

Nike Aaron Judge Alternate Limited Jersey

Rep Aaron Judge in this premium Nike jersey. Breathable mesh and Dri-Fit technology keep you cool while cheering on the Yankees.

$174.99
Fanatics
Buy Now

’47 Brand Branson Adjustable Cap

Show your Yankees pride every day with this classic ’47 Brand Branson adjustable cap. Available in multiple colors for a comfortable, custom fit.

$34.00
Amazon
Buy Now

New York Yankees 2026 MLB Postseason Hoodie

Gear up for October baseball with this midweight Yankees Postseason hoodie. The perfect layer for staying warm during every nail-biting inning.

$85.00
Fanatics
Buy Now

Nike Aaron Judge Nike Graphic T-Shirt

Back the captain in comfort with this standard-fit Nike Aaron Judge tee. Features a high-density name and number design on the back.

$67.39
Amazon
Buy Now
New York Post may be compensated and/or receive an affiliate commission if you buy something through our links.

And yet Wells kept playing and showed enough in late July and early August to dissuade Cashman from overpaying in prospects. At a time when catchers typically are wearing down, in August and September, Wells posted his two best months of the year. 

And even though the date read Sept. 29, he showed Tuesday why October may further his revival.