Texas Sues Allstate Over Its Collection of Driver Data

The lawsuit accuses Arity, an Allstate subsidiary, of collecting data about people’s driving behavior through mobile phone apps, leading to increases in drivers’ insurance rates.

The State of Texas sued Allstate on Monday, accusing the insurer of illegally tracking drivers by way of their phones through a subsidiary called Arity that claimed to have the “world’s largest driving behavior database.”

“Allstate and Arity paid mobile apps millions of dollars to install Allstate’s tracking software,” Ken Paxton, the state’s attorney general, said in a statement. “The personal data of millions of Americans was sold to insurance companies without their knowledge or consent in violation of the law. Texans deserve better and we will hold all these companies accountable.”

In a statement, Allstate denied that the company had done anything illegal. “Arity helps consumers get the most accurate auto insurance price after they consent in a simple and transparent way that fully complies with all laws and regulations,” the company said.

The New York Times reported last year that information about people’s driving behavior was being collected via smartphone apps, such as Life360 and GasBuddy, and sold to Arity, an analytics company founded by Allstate. Arity was able to analyze the data collected from people’s smartphones to determine how often they sped, braked suddenly or were distracted by their phones while driving. It used that analysis to give them driving risk scores.

“Insurers then used that consumer’s data to justify increasing their car insurance premiums, denying them coverage, or dropping them from coverage,” according to the attorney general’s lawsuit, which accuses the companies of violating the state’s privacy laws.

According to the state lawsuit, filed in District Court of Montgomery County, Arity has the location, movement and driving data of more than 45 million Americans who “were never informed about, nor consented to,” the continuous collection and sale of their data.

Texas also sued General Motors last year over the collection of consumers’ driving data, following a report by The Times that G.M. and other automakers were selling information about people’s driving to the insurance industry.

Explore Our Business and Tech Coverage

Dive deeper into the people, issues and trends shaping the worlds of business and technology.

• The Church Fixer: Thousands of churches across the United States close every year. In Brooklyn, one pastor is trying to help struggling parishes keep their doors open.
• The King of Network TV’s Next Act: For decades, Dick Wolf has dominated prime-time programming. Now, at 78, he has plans to conquer the world of streaming.
• A.I.’s Boom Towns: A rural region in central Washington is changing fast as electricians from around the country plug the tech industry’s new, giant data centers into its ample power supply.
• Risky Loans, Fast Profits: Blue Owl Capital has become one of Wall Street’s biggest operators in the shadowy world of private credit. But at what cost?
• Arizona’s Tiny Taipei: Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company brought thousands of workers from Asia to the Phoenix suburbs for jobs at a chip plant that the Biden administration helped fund.