Aubrey Plaza Sold the Los Feliz Home Where Jeff Baena Died for $4.375 Million, More Than $2 Million Under Her Asking Price

10 Sep 2026, 07:00 · Thought Catalog

Backgrid

Updated 3 minutes ago, September 10, 2026

The property spent almost 1 year on the market. When a buyer finally signed, she was weeks into motherhood with her first child, a daughter she welcomed with Christopher Abbott.

The deal closed around September 4, 2026, after two relistings and a string of price cuts. The home first hit the market at $6.5 million in September 2025, was pulled on December 23, then returned in early January 2026 at $5.75 million. It came off again after a March deal fell through, relisted in May at $5.299 million, and later dropped to $4.85 million.

An aerial view of the Los Feliz property — showing its red-tile roof, swimming pool, and dense surrounding palm and oak trees — that sold for $4.375 million, well below its original list price. Photo by Backgrid.

They’d purchased it for $4.7 million in October 2022, putting the final price $325,000 below what they’d paid. The 1928 Spanish-style compound runs about 4,064 square feet, with 4 bedrooms and a double lot near Griffith Park.

The street-facing garage wing of the Los Feliz house, a Spanish Colonial Revival structure featuring white stucco walls, an arched window, and a clay-tile roofline, photographed in September 2026. Photo by Backgrid.

Her husband was 47 when he died on January 3, 2025; the Los Angeles County Medical Examiner ruled his death a suicide. In August 2025, she told Amy Poehler on Good Hang, “At all times there’s like a giant ocean of awfulness that’s right there and I can see it.”

At the GREY GOOSE Blue Door “Life After Beth” party in Park City, Utah, Aubrey Plaza and Jeff Baena stand together during the Sundance Film Festival on January 19, 2014. Photo by Jamie McCarthy / Getty Images.

Like what you read? Follow Thought Catalog on Facebook, and check out more on our website.