Michael Burry's Netflix warning puts investors in a $39 dilemma
· The Fresno BeeMost of the firms in your investing portfolio are probably less familiar to you than Netflix.
You know its price, whether its programming is worthwhile, and how easy it would be to live without it.
But after losing over half of its value in less than a year, does that make Netflix stock a wise investment?
It appears that two of Wall Street’s most well-known investors have opposing opinions.
Billionaire Bill Ackman’s Pershing Square increased its Netflix (NFLX) stake by nearly 18% in the third quarter, reaching $1.07 billion by September.
Meanwhile, Michael Burry, the investor made famous by The Big Short, indicated that he would be interested in Netflix shares in the high $30s, according to Stocktwits.
Netflix closed Nov. 20 at $56.73. A decline to $39 would cost someone investing $10,000 at that closing price approximately $3,125.
The opposing viewpoints provide a crucial lesson about purchasing beaten-down equities for Americans investing their hard-earned wealth.
Additionally, Netflix users’ monthly entertainment costs are a far more personal aspect of the financial issue.
Related: GTA 6’s $80 price hides a surprise for American families
Michael Burry sees a problem Netflix subscribers understand
Think about the last time you subscribed to Netflix to watch a particular series.
It’s possible that you’ll complete it in a week, spend another evening searching for anything intriguing, and ultimately decide if the membership is worthwhile.
Burry’s investment thesis is somewhat explained by that common experience.
The investor has questioned whether Netflix’s content would continue to be profitable for future generations.
“Disney produces wine. Netflix produces milk,” Burry said, according to 24/7 Wall St.
He contends that while certain Disney titles may retain their financial value for decades, Netflix must continue investing in new content to sustain viewership.
In the past, Burry said that Netflix shares in the low $50s were still a bit outside his price range. Since then, his ideal entry price has decreased.
His most recent remarks, however, do not prove that he is betting against the stock or that Netflix will drop below $39.
Bill Ackman’s $1 billion Netflix bet tells a different story
Ackman believes Netflix’s enormous customer base gives it an enduring competitive advantage.
According to Pershing Square’s most recent regulatory filing, its Netflix holdings grew from around 13.08 million shares at the end of June to 15.41 million shares at the end of September.
More Streaming:
- Disney+ subscribers face a costly mistake hiding in plain sight
- Jim Cramer flags Netflix’s ‘biggest problem,’ and it isn’t price
- Why Netflix reportedly walked away from Xbox licensing deal
Pershing Square’s Form 13F disclosed the $1.07 billion quarter-end position.
The investment company said in its semiannual shareholder report that Netflix can spread programming expenses across more than 325 million users.
Pershing Square estimates that Netflix’s earnings could grow by nearly 20% annually over time, helped by improving profitability and share repurchases.
Pershing Square’s shareholder report outlines that investment thesis.
Ackman reiterated his optimism during a Nov. 12 interview with Yahoo Finance, highlighting Netflix’s considerably lower valuation compared with its historical levels.
However, regular investors should keep in mind that a billionaire’s capacity to tolerate losses can vary significantly from their own.
Furthermore, a fund’s current holdings are not always reflected in regulatory filings.
Netflix’s $240 annual cost explains what’s at stake
In the end, the argument between these investors is about consumers’ willingness to spend.
In the US, a typical Netflix membership with advertising support costs $8.99 per month, or around $108 per year.
The monthly cost of its standard ad-free membership is $19.99, bringing the yearly total to close to $240.
Meanwhile, premium subscribers pay $26.99 monthly, or approximately $324 annually, according to Netflix’s official pricing page.
Switching from ad-free to advertising-supported could save a household $132 per year, before taxes.
The importance of Netflix’s advertising division becomes clear when millions of users make such choices.
Netflix may make more money from non-subscribers by advertising.
However, since certain advertising features took longer to launch than anticipated, Netflix recently lowered its 2026 advertising income projection from around $3 billion to $2.7 billion.
Despite these setbacks, the corporation recorded $12.9 billion in sales for the third quarter, increasing around 12% from the same period last year.
Customer retention improved both domestically and internationally, and its operating margin rose from 28.2% to 34.6%.
Netflix’s Oct. 20 shareholder letter confirmed the results and reduced advertising forecast.
It’s not certain that Netflix will increase subscription costs in response to the advertising setback.
However, it highlights the company’s need to balance increasing income with keeping its service affordable for typical homes.
What Michael Burry’s $39 scenario means for your savings
I’ve covered financial markets for years, and I’ve discovered that a declining share price does not always indicate that a company is cheap.
Consider an American investing $10,000 in Netflix at its Nov. 20 closing price of $56.73.
That investment would be worth around $6,875 if the stock dropped to $39, which is within Burry’s favored purchasing range.
That is a loss of over 31%.
However, the same investment would increase to almost $12,339 if Netflix recovered to $70, yielding a return of more than 23%.
If the price later rose to $70, a person who waits to invest $10,000 at $39 would make around 79.5%.
These are not share-price projections; rather, they are speculative possibilities.
One way to lessen the danger of overpaying is to wait for a cheaper admission price. But Netflix may bounce back before it gets there, keeping investors on the sidelines.
Purchasing now exposes owners to more losses but may catch a possible comeback.
Americans investing through broad-market retirement funds should also check whether they already own Netflix indirectly before purchasing additional shares.
What ordinary Netflix investors should watch next
Netflix anticipates a 13% increase in revenue to $51.1 billion in 2026.
Despite the significant drop in its shares, the company is still expanding.
The key challenges are whether Netflix can boost advertising revenue, retain users, and increase profits without unduly increasing content expenditures.
Regular subscribers can handle the problem more easily.
When consumers decide the service is no longer worth it, they may cancel, downgrade to the less expensive choice, or compare subscription plans.
Whether Ackman’s optimism or Burry’s caution is ultimately warranted will depend on those particular household choices.
For investors, the lesson is equally important.
You don’t need to stop watching Netflix because its stock is struggling.
And you don’t need to buy Netflix stock simply because you enjoy its shows.
The quality of a product and the price of an investment are two different things.
Related: Anthropic’s $2 trillion debut hides a 13% warning
The Arena Media Brands, LLC THESTREET is a registered trademark of TheStreet, Inc.
This story was originally published November 22, 2026 at 10:33 AM.