Plenty of parents pay for college, and plenty of them believe that buys them a say in every grade, every class and every choice. One student decided that price was too high. Then, at a Fourth of July get-together, his uncle asked one simple question about tuition, and the answer came from the person nobody expected to speak. Based on a story shared by this student on Reddit, here’s what happened, and why so many readers still can’t agree on who was right.