"There are no reasons why brothers should not be able to resolve any trauma that they've been through": John Petrucci on the return of Mike Portnoy to Dream Theater

11 Oct 2024, 05:18 · louder

By Dave Ling
( Classic Rock )
published 11 October 2024

With friends (and bandmates) reunited for Dream Theater’s 40th anniversary, it’ll be a special night for fans at Wembley Arena later this month

(Image credit: Francesco Prandoni/Getty Images)

The return of Mike Portnoy, co-founder, drummer, songwriter, producer and all-around creative dynamo of Dream Theater, the world’s biggest and arguably best progressive metal band, has been a long time coming – 14 years, to be precise.

Guitarist John Petrucci, a fellow original member, previews the Grammy-winning US/Canadian group’s 40th-anniversary tour, which includes a date at London’s O2 Arena, and looks further ahead to a brand-new studio album.

In a parallel life where you work as a bookmaker, what odds would you have given on Mike Portnoy returning to Dream Theater in their 40th-anniversary year?

Ha ha. That’s a great question. Not too long ago I would have given very long odds on that. But life is funny that way. Time passes, things change and events unfold. Mike played on my solo record and he toured with me, and I could sense the fans suspecting something might happen. But I must stress that we really were not in that head-space yet. It just happened so quickly and felt right.

For long-term fans invested in the band’s history, it was great to see Mike and singer James LaBrie finally bury the hatchet.

Absolutely, and for me too. There are no reasons why brothers should not be able to resolve any trauma that they’ve been through. At that point [when they reconnected] Mike’s coming back still was not being discussed, and in the ethos of the universe it felt really, really positive to no longer have that sort of negativity in our lives any more.

Given that Mike was a co-producer and co-writer – co- just about everything, in fact – his return must make life a little easier for you personally?

Classic Rock Newsletter

Contact me with news and offers from other Future brandsReceive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsors

Mike was that person, and when he left a lot of extra responsibility shifted onto me, but I embraced that. Mike has been very understanding that this is not the same band he left. The two of us have a very special relationship, we think so alike. It’s such fun having him back, like having an extra person in your life that’s completely on your wavelength.

Could this signal a reintegration of some very unique features from Mike’s original tenure, such as doing albums in their entirety when the band play a second night at the same venue? Or are you too long in the tooth for that now?

Not at all. Certain things did stop [after he left], but now Mike is back anything is possible. By all means let’s bring back those fun things that were missing and that Mike was a pioneer of – classic albums, differing setlists. All that stuff’s back on the table. As a band we should embrace Mike’s strengths. So let’s see how things unfold.

Without getting carried away by nostalgia, it’s important to remember Dream Theater’s successes of the past 14 years, including the three Grammy nominations, and finally a win in 2022.

As painful as it was to have Mike leave, I pride myself on that period. All of our hard work yielded some incredible milestones. I’m superproud of all the releases and the shows that we put on with those crazy productions. Those things are testament to the individual band members and also to our organisation.

To be clear: this was something that you wanted to do, not that you had to do?

Absolutely. I’m a creative person, I love playing guitar and making music. Mike leaving was a massive blow, but I wasn’t going to let anything stop the continuation of Dream Theater.

How is work going on the band’s next studio record – their sixteenth? Did the sparks fly again from the very first moment?

Well, I’m talking to you from the studio, and yes they did. As soon as all five of us got in the room together. No beat was missed. It was really great.

Dream Theater - Night Terror (Official Video) - YouTube

Watch On

How long will it be before it’s released?

We’re at a point in the campaign where all of those details will be revealed in the future. Right now I cannot say any more than that [On October 10 the band released a new single, Night Terror, and announced that the album, Parasomnia, will be released in February].

Is it possible that you might play a song or two from it on this European tour?

It really is a matter of timing. If it’s possible for us to release a single before the tour, then obviously we would be very happy to allow people a sneaky peek [laughs].

Have you even considered the setlist yet?

Mike was always the set-list guy, and that was one of the things I was happy to relinquish. He was always so particular about it. Not long after he rejoined, we were out at dinner and I officially handed back that responsibility – “Just take it already!” Mike already has the set-list, so we are ahead of the game on that.

Presumably the upcoming tour is just a taster for a far bigger one that will take place after the album comes out?

I think so. It’s a celebration of forty years of Dream Theater, and not so much on the new record until it’s released and we can properly give that its due in a live sense. Timing-wise it’s cool, we have Mike back in the band, and then with a brand-new album out we get a part two of the whole thing.

Dream Theater play London’s O2 Arena on October 20 before heading to Europe. For dates and tickets, check the Dream Theater website.

Dave Ling

Dave Ling was a co-founder of Classic Rock magazine. His words have appeared in a variety of music publications, including RAW, Kerrang!, Metal Hammer, Prog, Rock Candy, Fireworks and Sounds. Dave’s life was shaped in 1974 through the purchase of a copy of Sweet’s album ‘Sweet Fanny Adams’, along with early gig experiences from Status Quo, Rush, Iron Maiden, AC/DC, Yes and Queen. As a lifelong season ticket holder of Crystal Palace FC, he is completely incapable of uttering the word ‘Br***ton’.

More about classic rock

"All of a sudden, things went mad!": Motörhead's Overkill, the album that changed everything - only in the new issue of Classic Rock

"This blistering set of old and new material deserves to be heard": Def Leppard's homecoming captured on the slick One Night Only Live at The Leadmill
Latest

"I'm able to retire because of that song becoming such a ginormous hit everywhere": Maria McKee on the new Lone Justice album and the reunion that isn't
See more latest ►

“This was more than just music… It’s part of your DNA if you were that age at the time. It defines the times”: Yes, Genesis and Pink Floyd alumni on what The Beatles’ Sgt Pepper did for prog

From classicly-styled hard rock to the slickest of AOR: The Foreigner albums you definitely need to listen to

"If someone tries to start a fight with you, put them down as fast and nastily as you possibly can": The wild life of The Who's combustion engine, John Entwistle

"I went from sleeping on a mattress to playing arenas inside two years": Creed's rise and fall was fast, but now, thanks to the TikTok generation, they're selling more tickets than ever

“When somebody first called me a rock star it was like a dream come true. And my ego reflected that.” An audience with Nine Inch Nails' Trent Reznor after “self-destruction” forced him to confront some ugly, painful home truths

"The intensity and that whole, 'playing a bit faster than we are able to' type of approach, makes this such a gem." Dark Tranqullity/Halo Effect vocalist Mikael Stanne picks the greatest death metal album of all time

“Every time we arrived back in the early hours in our van, we’d be stopped by the police…In those days, anyone with long hair was a drug addict”: Hawkwind’s bid to spread the counterculture with In Search Of Space (if that’s the album’s actual name)

“In interviews they’d talk about Phil and Mike then say, ‘What have you been doing while these guys have been in the charts?’ It takes as long to make a record that’s not a success as it does to make one that is”: Tony Banks on his career outside Genesis