Every Testament album ranked from worst to best
· louderBy Adam Brennan
( Metal Hammer )
published 1 November 2024
Ranking the discography of one of the greatest thrash metal bands in the world
Long considered to be the first off the subs’ bench should one of thrash’s Big 4 fall by the wayside, Testament have overcome more than their fair share of adversity – from time in the post-thrash wilderness, unstable line-ups, and life threatening illnesses. Anchored by the colossal frame and lungs of Chuck Billy, the oft-copied but never bettered riffing style of Eric Peterson and in Alex Skolnick (one of the finest guitarists in thrash), Testament have gained respect and admiration for their prestigious output. But which album is the best?
12. The Ritual (1992)
The last album to feature the classic line-up includes some stone cold classics in the form of iron-plated anthems Electric Crown and the moody Return To Serenity. However, this tentative rather than tenacious foray into more classic metal territory paled in comparison to what had elevated Testament to thrash’s upper echelons.
11. Low (1994)
A change in personnel brought a huge departure from the style the band had cultivated for a decade. Billy’s noticeably lower vocals came to the fore over a rush of different elements, from bouncy mid-tempo groove to bursts of death metal. A mixed but necessary step for what was to come.
10. Dark Roots Of Earth (2012)
With Billy paying homage to his Pomo heritage in the awesome Native Blood and spewing fire on Rise Up and True American Hate, Dark Roots Of Earth possessed plenty of vintage Testament power. Unfortunately the band’s tenth album suffered from the weight of expectation and a few middling moments, not least the misguided Cold Embrace.
9. Souls Of Black (1990)
Their fourth album – and their third in as many years – may feel slightly rushed, but it has been unfairly maligned due to the inclusion of divisive ballad The Legacy, which more than holds its own 26 years later. Peterson’s trademark guitars are hook-laden throughout, propelling the likes of Falling Fast with its ridiculous Skolnick lead and the title track’s imperious stomp.
8. Demonic (1997)
Taking the death metal influences that crept in on Low to a whole new level, Demonic slowed the pace and upped the ante. Billy’s guttural growls sounded imposing over the eerie peaks of The Burning Times and hammer blow riffs of the hideous Murky Waters, sewing the seeds of growth in the supposed thrash wasteland of the mid ‘90s.
7. Titans Of Creation (2020)
Celebrating a rare line-up consistency, Testament belied their veteran status with an authoritative, devastating display across Titans Of Creation's twelve tracks. In what would be Gene Hoglan’s final outing, the virtuosity of each musician hit that much harder across expertly crafted modern metal anthems Children Of The Next Level, Ishtar’s Gate and the enormous Dream Deceiver that stood tall alongside the band’s best ever work. One listen to the riffs, leads and vicious co-vocals on Night Of The Witch revealed that Testament were capping off their fourth decade of existence in untouchable form.
Metal Hammer Newsletter
Sign up below to get the latest from Metal Hammer, plus exclusive special offers, direct to your inbox!
Contact me with news and offers from other Future brandsReceive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsors
TESTAMENT - Night of the Witch (OFFICIAL LYRIC VIDEO) - YouTube
6. Brotherhood Of The Snake (2016)
Though marred by a financial spat with bassist Greg Christian, the band’s latest album delivered full-blooded thrash with a renewed vigour. Influenced by ancient extra-terrestrial conspiracies, the notable inclusion of former Death rhythm section Steve DiGiorgio and Gene Hoglan kept the clinical riffs rolling along at a ferocious pace.
TESTAMENT - "Brotherhood of the Snake" (OFFICIAL LYRIC VIDEO) - YouTube
5. Practice What You Preach (1989)
Rounding off a scintillating three-album salvo, there’s very little to separate Practice What You Preach from its predecessors in terms of sheer quality. Greenhouse Effect and Sins Of Omission crackle with propulsive vitality while Time Is Coming and misleadingly titled The Ballad sound absolutely massive, benefiting from a beefed up production.
4. The Legacy (1986)
Easily going to toe-to-toe with thrash’s biggest and best debuts in the genre’s most celebrated year, The Legacy thrummed with razor sharp musicality, menacing riffs and a youthful bluster that continued throughout the rest of the decade. The enduring anthem Over The Wall coupled with the unhinged assaults of C.O.T.L.O.D. and First Strike Is Deadly cemented the band’s position in the vanguard of the Bay Area scene.
Testament - Over The Wall - YouTube
3. The Gathering (1999)
So the ‘90s was a thrash wasteland, was it? Two years before Slayer came back all guns blazing with God Hates Us All, Testament refined their death/thrash fusion. Featuring death metal luminaries Steve DiGiorgio and James Murphy on bass and lead guitar, and none other than Dave Lombardo behind the kit, The Gathering was a precision strike to the senses.
2. The Formation Of Damnation (2008)
As comeback albums go, few are as riveting as this. The first since Chuck Billy had kicked the shit out of cancer saw the returns of Skolnick and original bassist Greg Christian with sticksman Paul Bostpah laying down drums for one of 21st-century metal’s finest moments. Billy sounded monstrous throughout while Skolnick and Peterson’s twin riffage hit a career high on The Henchmen Ride and More Than Meets The Eye.
1. The New Order (1988)
Arriving almost two years to the day after their debut, the band’s second album took The Legacy’s blueprint and upped the stakes to produce their finest collection of songs to date. Into The Pit, Disciples Of The Watch and the title track are indispensable thrash hallmarks while even the rushed Aerosmith cover – added to fulfil the contractually obliged 40-minute length – adds to The New Order’s formidable status.
Rugby, Sean Bean and power ballad superfan Adam has been writing for Hammer since 2007, and has a bad habit of constructing sentences longer than most Dream Theater songs. Can usually be found cowering at the back of gigs in Bristol and Cardiff. Bruce Dickinson once called him a 'sad bastard'.
More about metal hammer
Every The Offspring album ranked from worst to best
"She's made the jump from bizarre YouTube content creator to one of the brightest stars in metal." A guide to every Poppy album
See more latest ►
Most Popular
10 movies that prove 2024 has been a brilliant year for horror