Another Death Knell for the American Musical
by Zach Schiffman · VULTUREIf you weren’t already concerned about the state of the American musical, you should be now. The 100th annual Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade has just announced it will be forgoing its traditional freezing-cold performances from the current slate of Broadway shows. Instead, we’re getting a single ten-minute medley that “takes us on a musical journey through Broadway past and present, filled with beloved songs and Easter eggs for theater fans to discover along the way.” But this isn’t the damn Eras Tour, NBC — we don’t need Easter eggs, we need performances from actual new musical-theater productions.
ad-position slots="mobile_article_body"
Unfortunately, we won’t be getting them. Instead, the medley will feature a number of very long-running shows — Book of Mormon, Chicago, Aladdin, Hamilton, and Wicked — in addition to shows that opened this year and would be looking for the boost (The Lost Boys, The Rocky Horror Show, Schmigadoon!, none of which are from this current season). Rent will also inexplicably be making an appearance in the medley, ostensibly to celebrate its 30th anniversary and promote to the current revival across the pond. In return, we’ll be getting a Paddington float, but no performance from the upcoming Broadway musical.
ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic desktop_article_body mobile_leaderboard"
Despite all that, the lack of individual performances is particularly devastating. So many Broadway productions rely on these nationally televised numbers to get attention of incoming tourists during the lucrative holidays, and gay guys rely on these to watch over and over again in living rooms across the country. We have now been robbed of Solea Pfeifer screaming her face off in 30-degree weather to promote Wanted! Even during COVID, when Broadway was closed, the parade still managed to put to fulfill its implicit promise: Mean Girls, Jagged Little Pill, and Ain’t Too Proud were all given their own performances. If there was ever a time to do a tribute to Broadway with “Easter eggs,” it was when the entire industry was shut down — but even then, the show went on.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body mobile_leaderboard"
All of this, coupled with the loss of The Late Show, means musicals have even fewer televised opportunities to promote themselves to the network-TV-watching out-of-towners who help keep the lights on for so many shows. The annual Tony Awards, thankfully, will still be on CBS for years to come.) Granted, this decision may partly stem from the musicals themselves — the shows typically have to account for some or all of the cost of their parade performances, which is no cheap thing in today’s Broadway economy. Of course, that’s no consolation. It makes the outlook for Broadway even grimmer. It’s one of the most significant death knells to the original American musical I can think of.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
If you are also spending today in mourning like I am, there is only one surefire way to cheer up. Soothe your soul by rewatching the 2002 Seussical performance at the parade.
ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"