Amanda Seyfried’s Charlie Kirk Comments Appear in Heated Scene from Nathan Fielder’s Elizabeth Holmes Documentary
· Thought Catalog
Updated 14 seconds ago, October 16, 2026
Amanda Seyfried’s comments about Charlie Kirk appear in You Can See Everything, Nathan Fielder’s Elizabeth Holmes documentary, which includes a heated dinner where Holmes’ partner, Evans, admits he posts from her X account without her approval.
He is an avid Charlie Kirk fan who believes Holmes at face value when she says she has never told a lie in her life.
With Holmes in prison, Evans says he is managing her account. He tells Fielder and Seyfried that he often shares controversial posts and reposts without Holmes knowing; Seyfried appears stunned to hear it.
In the wake of Kirk’s death, Seyfried commented on an Instagram post that compiled some of his past statements and wrote, “He was hateful.” In later interviews, she stood by the original comment, saying she was “not f-cking apologizing,” that it was based on “actual reality and actual footage and actual quotes,” and that she was free to have an opinion. She has also said the intense online reaction led her to hire a bodyguard at one point.
Related Articles
Seyfried, who won an Emmy for playing Holmes in The Dropout, also reenacts Holmes’ words for the documentary, including a prison phone call to Fielder. Seyfried’s sympathy for Holmes does not keep her from questioning Holmes’ decisions and state of mind.
You Can See Everything opens in theaters October 16.
Thank you for reading. You can find Thought Catalog on Facebook, and read more over on our website.