Judge grants release of redacted transcript from Charlie Kirk case hearing

SALT LAKE CITY, Utah – A Utah judge overseeing the trial of the accused killer of conservative activist Charlie Kirk
on Dec 29 ordered the release of most of the transcript and audio of a closed-door hearing on safety and security measures for the proceedings, but said media outlets that had asked for the records did not need special status to cover the proceedings.

Judge Tony Graf made his two rulings on media requests during a video hearing that suspect Tyler Robinson attended via audio link. Robinson spoke only once, replying “yes, your honour”, when asked by Judge Graf whether he was present.

Robinson is accused of firing a single round from a rooftop that killed Mr Kirk as he debated students during a stop on a US university tour. 

Robinson is charged with seven criminal counts, including aggravated murder, obstruction of justice for disposing of evidence, and witness tampering for asking his roommate to delete incriminating texts. Prosecutors said they would seek the death penalty.

Media outlets covering the case had asked for records of a closed hearing on Oct 24 that dealt with the safety restraints and clothing Robinson would be required to wear in court.

The judge on Dec 29 ordered the redaction of about one page of text of the 80-page transcript and the corresponding audio.

Judge Graf had ruled Robinson may appear in court in regular clothes
but must be physically restrained, and has prohibited media from filming or photographing Robinson’s handcuffs and shackles after his lawyers said such images could prejudice potential jurors.

Media outlets had asked for status that would have ensured they received notice of attempts to close hearings or otherwise limit access to the proceedings to give them time to challenge restrictions.

Judge Graf denied that request, citing a prior order that lawyers for both sides must notify the media before attempting to have future hearings held behind closed doors.

At a February hearing, the judge will consider a defence request to ban cameras from the courtroom.

Mr Kirk’s death sparked denunciations of political violence across the ideological spectrum. REUTERS