Kelp Have a Bizarre Backup Plan for When They Can’t Find a Mate: Reproduce By Themselves
This striking adaptation comes at a cost.
by Tudor Tarita · ZME ScienceDesperate times call for desperate measures.
When some kelp can’t find a mate, they can produce offspring by themselves. The results, however, are a bit off: stunted seaweeds with misshapen blades and poorly formed anchors.
Even more strangely, males can do it too.
“Our findings highlight that kelps are even more flexible in their reproduction than previously appreciated,” Daniel Liesner, the study’s lead author, told ZME Science.
The High Cost of Going Solo
Liesner, now at the GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research Kiel in Germany, and his colleagues studied Laminaria pallida, a kelp species from the coasts of South Africa and Namibia.
Most people probably don’t think of kelp as having sexes. But these giant seaweeds have a surprisingly complicated sex life. The towering underwater forests we recognize are just one stage of their life cycle. Kelp also spend part of their lives as microscopic organisms that are either male or female.
These spores produce sperm and eggs, which normally join to begin a new large seaweed. But sometimes an unfertilized reproductive cell starts developing anyway, a process called parthenogenesis.
The researchers grew male and female cultures separately. They wanted to see how offspring produced sexually compared their offspring with those produced when males and females grew together.
×
Get smarter every day...
Stay ahead with ZME Science and subscribe.
Daily Newsletter
The science you need to know, every weekday.
Weekly Newsletter
A week in science, all in one place. Sends every Sunday.
No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime. Review our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! One more thing...
Please check your inbox and confirm your subscription.
Sex won decisively: mixed cultures produced more than twice as many young kelp. Furthermore, offspring produced without fertilization were smaller and often had deformed blades or poorly developed anchoring structures. None of them seemed to develop reproductive structures.
The researchers also discovered something unusual about their DNA. Asexually produced kelp underwent endoreduplication, a process in which cells copy their DNA without dividing. In other words, the cells increased their DNA content without combining genetic material from two parents. Genetic tests confirmed that these offspring carried only one type of sex chromosome, consistent with their origin from an unfertilized reproductive cell.
Then came an even more revealing test. The researchers placed male and female cultures on opposite sides of a fine mesh that allowed them to share seawater without coming into direct contact. They then compared these cultures with ones kept entirely apart. In both sexes, asexual reproduction increased when potential mates were absent.
This suggests that kelp knows when there’s a potential partner nearby. But how could they?
Chemicals carried by water are one possibility.
“We already know that males can sense a pheromone released by the female eggs, which triggers sperm release and their attraction,” Liesner said.
RelatedPosts
The Opioid Crisis Has Reached the Gulf of Mexico’s Dolphins
This sea worm’s butt swims away to reproduce, and we finally know how
Generosity is probably somewhat genetic
Researchers Tracked Salmon Numbers in a River Using Only Air Samples
Even Males Can Do It
Researchers weren’t expecting to find that sperm could also develop into new kelp without ever fertilizing an egg.
That’s remarkable because sperm are normally specialized for one job: finding and fertilizing an egg. They aren’t supposed to develop into entire organisms on their own.
A 2024 study of L. pallida had described male cultures producing egg-like structures and abnormal offspring. The new study followed the transformation in greater detail, analyzing patterns of gene activity as the cells developed.
Male reproductive cells grew larger, while their gene activity shifted away from a male pattern toward one resembling female cells and embryos.
Liesner explained that both sexes seem to carry the machinery for making larger reproductive cells capable of developing alone, but in males this capacity is “usually overridden by a dominant male sex locus.”
“The reduced expression of genes on the male sex locus then coincides with the up-regulation of female-biased genes (“feminisation”) and the down-regulation of male-biased genes (“de-masculinisation”), which we also see in our study,” Liesner noted.
His team’s earlier research on giant kelp likewise found that male development overrides a more female-like starting program.
A Backup Plan
Another striking result came from the wild.
Among 523 kelp sampled in South Africa and Namibia, the team found no clear genetic evidence of asexual reproduction. Yet 92% of mature laboratory cultures established from wild kelp produced offspring without fertilization.
The ability was widespread, but there was little evidence of it being used successfully in nature.
“This paradox was what puzzled us most—why maintain a trait if there is seemingly no benefit?” Liesner said.
“Our experiments show that asexual reproduction is reduced when potential mates are nearby,” he explained. “In addition, the higher fitness of sexually produced offspring indicates that asexually produced offspring are likely outcompeted in healthy, dense populations such as those we sampled.”
A 2021 giant-kelp study had already shown that females change their reproductive investment depending on male presence and relatedness.
But going solo doesn’t always mean you produce inferior offspring. A 2007 study of Chilean kelp found that asexually produced individuals could develop normally. And research published in 2024 documented populations of another brown alga, Scytosiphon, that had lost sex entirely and become better at reproducing without it.
As Liesner put it, “the costs or benefits of parthenogenesis definitely depend on the organism”.
For L. pallida, the backup may prove useful in sparsely populated habitats where mates are scarce. However, researchers haven’t established whether asexual offspring can survive long enough to reproduce in nature.
Still, the strategy might make evolutionary sense. In the experiments, asexual development mostly began after opportunities for sex had passed.
“Simply put, it may be better to develop poorly than not at all,” Liesner said.
The study was published in the journal PLOS Biology