Scientists Revisit 3-Million-Year-Old Taung Child and Turn Our Evolution Story Completely Upside Down

The story of human evolution is now more tangled than ever.

by · ZME Science
The skull of the Taung child. Credit: Wikimedia Commons.

When the Taung Child was first discovered in South Africa in 1924, it helped establish Africa as an important place to investigate the cradle of humanity. However, a century later, scientists are still debating where this fossilised skull belonging to a young Australopithecus africanus fits among our ancient relatives.

A new study puts the ancestral child again at the centre of this debate, estimating its age at 2.96 million to 3.03 million years and challenging the long-standing practice of lumping dozens of other early South African fossils into the same species, Australopithecus africanus. By re-examining the child’s developing teeth and braincase, an international team of researchers found that many adult fossils traditionally grouped alongside it simply do not fit its growth pattern.

“For over 100 years, we assumed the Taung Child was just one of many similar fossils from the era. Our findings turn that on its head. The human family tree wasn’t a neat, straight trunk—it was a chaotic, tangled bush driven by climate shifts,” said Gabriele Macho, one of the study authors and a professor of archaeology at Vrije Universiteit Brussel (VUB).

The new research describes Australopithecus africanus as “a poorly defined taxon,” with the Taung Child remaining its only unequivocal representative. Instead of a single, clearly defined ancestral species marching steadily toward modern humans, southern Africa appears to have been a dynamic evolutionary crossroads—one where shifting climates repeatedly isolated and reunited distinct groups of early human relatives.

Unlocking the Clock on a Defining Fossil

A. africanus is an extinct hominin species that lived in southern Africa around three million years ago. It provides important evidence of how our ancestors evolved on the African continent. The Taung Child is the type specimen, or holotype, of A. africanus. This means it serves as the reference fossil for defining the species, including what it must have looked like or how large its brain was.  

Interestingly, many other South African fossils have been assigned to the same species despite considerable differences in their anatomy. Some were originally given separate species names, but researchers grouped them under A. africanus in the 1950s to simplify classification.

The problem is that researchers have often relied on broad descriptions of features rather than clear anatomical traits that consistently distinguish one species from another. As the study authors point out, there is still no consensus on what actually defines A. africanus.

Establishing the child’s age was a crucial step in addressing this. Mining destroyed much of the original geological context, and South African fossil sites generally lack the volcanic ash layers that help researchers date East African fossils.

Image credits: ZME Science

Instead, the study authors used uranium-lead dating on a flowstone layer above the fossil-bearing deposit. This method produced an age of 2.962 million years, with an uncertainty of 59,000 years. As the flowstone formed after the fossil-bearing material, this provides a minimum age rather than a direct date for the skull, which could be even older than this figure.

×

Get smarter every day...

Stay ahead with ZME Science and subscribe.

Daily Newsletter
The science you need to know, every weekday.

Weekly Newsletter
A week in science, all in one place. Sends every Sunday.
No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime. Review our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! One more thing...

Please check your inbox and confirm your subscription.

When the Anatomy Refuses to Fit

Reconstruction of the Taung child’s face. Image credits: Cicero Moraes/Wikimedia Commons

Taung died young, while most other South African specimens assigned to A. africanus are adults. To see if they truly belonged to the same species, the researchers had to figure out what the child might have looked like had it grown up.

With the timeline established, the researchers examined dental development and braincase growth. They also studied the dentino-enamel junction, the boundary between a tooth’s dentine and enamel that forms early and is relatively resistant to wear.

RelatedPosts

Neanderthals Had a Hidden World of Wooden Tools. Scientists Just Found Rare Evidence of It
Scientists Say Kissing Is Over 20 Million Years Old and It’s Not Just a Human Thing
An Ancient Virus Left Its Mark on Chimpanzee DNA Even After Millions of Years and May Have Helped Shape Human Brain Evolution
The hands of great apes tell a story about our own evolution

Using brain growth patterns in chimpanzees and gorillas as a guide, the team simulated how Taung’s skull would have matured. While Taung could plausibly have grown into an adult resembling a few classic A. africanus fossils—such as the famous “Mrs. Ples” skull—its projected head shape did not match several other adults long placed in the exact same species.

The tooth analysis made matters all the more confusing. Taung’s first-molar dentino-enamel junction had a shape that placed it at the edge of the group of teeth attributed to A. africanus. In some measurements, it also fell within the range seen in Paranthropus robustus, another early hominin species from southern Africa. 

In other words, multiple distinct species were likely living in the region and mistakenly lumped together.

“No clear picture emerges regarding the relationship of the Taung child with other hominins,” the reserachers concluded.

A changing landscape may have mixed populations

Could environmental change help explain the anatomical diversity among southern Africa’s early hominins? 

Climate records indicate greater rainfall variability across southeastern Africa between 4 million and 2.5 million years ago than in the following period. To understand how these changes may have affected the environment around Taung, the researchers analysed pollen recovered near the fossil site.

The samples indicated that Taung must have lived around freshwater wetlands, open savanna and substantial local woody vegetation. One of the key samples was pollen from Podocarpus trees. Today, these trees are largely associated with wetter areas around South Africa’s eastern escarpment, about 400 kilometres from Taung.

“The presence of Podocarpus is surprising and implies a much more wooded environment during the late Pliocene–early Pleistocene overall. Its presence at Taung provides the first evidential support for the hypothesis of a more widespread distribution of Podocarpus forests across Africa,” the study authors note.

Changing rainfall patterns may have repeatedly shifted suitable habitats, causing hominin populations to spread, shrink or become isolated. Then, isolation could have led to genetic drift, while renewed contact may have allowed populations to interbreed, potentially accounting for the anatomical differences seen in the fossil record.

The family tree is still unresolved

The new study doesn’t name a new species or redraw the human family tree just yet. But the habit of tossing dozens of varied South African fossils into a single catch-all species requires a lot of reconsidering. Back to the drawing board, it seems.

To untangle how these ancient relatives actually fit together, the authors say scientists need sharper fossil dating, larger specimen collections, and a better grasp of how bones and teeth transform as a child grows up. Just as importantly, researchers must look at how shifting climates physically reshaped isolated populations over time, rather than relying on broad, outdated species labels.

This is because even as the human family tree looks more tangled than ever, the skull that started it all a century ago remains our most vital guide.

As the researchers put it, “the Taung Child must stay at the heart of future investigations.”

The study is published in the journal npj Palaeoecosystems.