Oak Trees Can Starve Caterpillars By Delaying Their Spring Leaves

Trees seem to remember their past and plan accordingly.

Forests don’t always wake up as soon as spring arrives. Sometimes, they hold back.

A new study suggests that oak trees attacked by caterpillars can delay leafing out the following spring. That tiny shift, only about three days, may be enough to throw hungry larvae off schedule and cut future leaf damage by more than half.

These findings show that trees are more resourceful and active than we usually give them credit. 

“This discovery fundamentally changes our previous understanding of the onset of spring in the forest,” Soumen Mallick, first author of the study and a postdoc researcher at the University of Würzburg, said.

Mapping caterpillar attack on oaks

Scientists used to believe that the timing of leaf emergence, known as spring phenology, was driven almost entirely by temperature. Warmer weather meant earlier leaves. 

But that simple explanation doesn’t tell the whole picture. Some forests stay brown longer than expected, even when the weather is warm enough for leaves to appear. The missing factor, the new study suggests, may be caterpillar damage from the previous year.

To uncover this, the study authors combined ecology with satellite technology. Instead of tracking a handful of trees from the ground, which is a slow and limited method, they monitored an enormous forested area of about 2,400 square kilometres in northern Bavaria, Germany.

They relied on data from Sentinel-1, a radar-based satellite system that can see through clouds and capture detailed information about forest canopies. This approach allowed them to continuously observe changes in tree cover across seasons and years.

Over five years (2017–2021), the team collected an astonishing 137,500 observations. Each data point represented a 10×10 metre patch—roughly the size of a single tree crown—across 27,500 such patches in 60 different forest areas. This level of detail gave them a near tree-by-tree view of how forests respond over time.

×

Get smarter every day...

Stay ahead with ZME Science and subscribe.

Daily Newsletter
The science you need to know, every weekday.

Weekly Newsletter
A week in science, all in one place. Sends every Sunday.
No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime. Review our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! One more thing...

Please check your inbox and confirm your subscription.

“The radar sensors recorded exactly which trees were stripped bare and how they reacted in the following year”, Jörg Müller, one of the study authors and a professor at the University of Würzburg, said.

How did the trees outsmart hungry pests?

In 2019, a year marked by a major outbreak of the gypsy moth (Lymantria dispar), caterpillars stripped many oak trees bare. The following spring revealed a clear pattern—previously attacked trees delayed their leaf emergence by about three days.

That short delay had a big impact. Caterpillars hatch at a fixed time, expecting fresh, soft leaves to eat. However, when the leaves weren’t there yet, many larvae couldn’t survive. The result was a sharp drop in insect survival and a 55 percent reduction in leaf damage.

What’s surprising is that this timing strategy appears to be more efficient than traditional defenses like producing bitter chemicals (tannins). This is because chemical defenses require energy and resources, while simply waiting a few extra days costs the tree much less.

“By comparison, achieving a 50 percent reduction in herbivory via the chemical defence of trees would require an approximately six-fold increase in tannin concentration. This highlights that herbivory-induced budburst delay may represent an effective defence strategy that equates or even exceeds the benefits of induced chemical defence,” the study authors note.

A new way to look at forests

This discovery means we have to rethink how we think about ecosystems, and stop considering trees as passive elements. Forest models have long relied on temperature as the main driver of seasonal changes, often ignoring interactions between species. If trees actively respond to threats, this can send ripples across the ecosystem.

RelatedPosts

Climate Change Will Cause More Infectious Diseases
Climate change is bringing new diseases to sea creatures
Trump to withdraw from Paris Agreement, briefed source claims
World’s largest container shipping company pledges carbon neutrality by 2050

There’s also a deeper evolutionary story here. 

“Our study highlights that trees are experiencing opposing selection pressures from climate warming and herbivory, which may place them at risk of being caught in an evolutionary trap,” the study notes.

Climate change is pushing them to leaf earlier each year, while insect pressure is pushing them to delay. However, the fact that trees can adjust their timing only when needed gives them an edge because insects can’t easily adapt to a moving target.

However, scientists don’t yet fully understand how trees remember past attacks or what internal mechanisms trigger the delay. Future research aims to dig into these processes and test whether similar strategies exist in other tree species and regions.

The study is published in the journal Nature Ecology & Evolution.