Strangled from behind: US expert claims Epstein's death was murder, not suicide
US forensic expert Professor Michael Freeman has challenged the 2019 suicide ruling in Jeffrey Epstein's death, saying medical evidence points to strangulation and homicide. However, the New York medical examiner's office has reiterated its original finding of suicide by hanging. Freeman's research has not undergone peer review.
by India Today World Desk · India TodayIn Short
- Michael Freeman based his assessment on autopsy records and photographs
- Epstein's brother supplied the files but did not pay Freeman
- Shoulder haemorrhage and facial injuries were cited as assault indicators
US forensic expert Professor Michael Freeman has challenged the official finding that convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein died by suicide in prison, saying his review of the medical evidence points to homicide by strangulation, probably from behind, reported the BBC.
Even seven years after his death, questions surrounding Epstein's suicide continue to linger. The controversy, fuelled by a three-minute gap in CCTV footage around midnight at the time of his death and the malfunctioning of two cameras outside his cell, has now resurfaced following fresh revelations by a forensic expert.
The New York City medical examiner who conducted the autopsy concluded in 2019 that Epstein had died by suicide and found no defensive injuries indicating homicide. Epstein was found dead in a New York prison on August 10, 2019 while awaiting trial on sex-trafficking charges.
Dr Barbara Sampson, who was the chief medical examiner when the autopsy was conducted and ruled the death a suicide, has previously said she remained firm in the determination of its cause and manner.
In a statement to CNN, the New York City Office of the Chief Medical Examiner has once again stood by its original assessment, saying it “stands by its determination” that Epstein died by suicide by hanging.
Freeman has worked as a cause-of-death expert for attorneys-general in the United States in cases involving deaths in police custody, including that of George Floyd in Minnesota.
He released his research and the New York City medical examiner's records after presenting his findings in London on Monday evening.
Freeman did not examine Epstein's body. He reached his conclusions after studying records and photographs from the medical examiner's report that were given to him by Epstein's brother, Mark Epstein, who has consistently said his brother was murdered.
Freeman said his assessment was independent and that Mark Epstein had not paid him. His research has not undergone peer review.
Speaking to BBC, Freeman said he had identified signs that he believed pointed to an assault. These included a deep haemorrhage in Epstein's left shoulder and facial injuries that, in his view, appeared consistent with blows to the face.
He said the evidence was most consistent with strangulation using a ligature, which was then probably used to hang Epstein's body from the bunk bed.
Freeman also told BBC that there appeared to be fingernail marks above the ligature mark on Epstein's neck. He said such marks would be consistent with a person being strangled, particularly from behind, and trying to pull the ligature away from the neck.
According to Freeman, the injuries did not correspond with the position in which the body was discovered. He said this left homicide as the only explanation for the death.
However, the medical examiner who conducted the autopsy told the US Department of Justice's Office of the Inspector General that Epstein's injuries were more consistent with suicide by hanging than homicide by strangulation. The examiner also said there were no defensive wounds of the kind generally found on strangulation victims.
Freeman said he would have expected investigators examining a death by hanging in custody to take a photograph of the body before it was brought down.
A Department of Justice investigation into Epstein's imprisonment said the guard who found him immediately called another officer for assistance. They lowered his body to the floor and attempted to resuscitate him.
The department's report said Epstein died one month after he had briefly been placed on suicide watch.
Asked who could have killed Epstein if his reading of the evidence was correct, Freeman said he had no idea. He added that he had formed no view on the identity of any possible assailant and had not examined that question as part of his work.
When challenged over whether his position amounted to a conspiracy theory, Freeman said people did not have to accept his word and should examine the material themselves.
He said that if others regarded him as a conspiracy theorist for interpreting the evidence as strangulation rather than hanging, they should show where his assessment was wrong.
Freeman also said he remained open to informed alternative interpretations, describing that openness as part of his role as an academic.
- Ends