Make sure pupils don't ever use phones at school, Phillipson tells teachers
All schools in England should follow new government guidance and be phone-free for the entire school day, Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson has said.
In a letter to schools seen exclusively by the BBC, she said it was "not appropriate for phones to be used as calculators, or for research during lessons", as well as during break times and lunchtime.
Ofsted will be inspecting schools on the implementation of their mobile phone policies going forward, she confirmed, with teachers also being advised not to use their phones in front of pupils.
One head teachers' union said using Ofsted to "police" schools' mobile phone policies was "deeply unhelpful and misguided".
Schools were first given guidance on phones by the previous Conservative government in February 2024, but Phillipson said in her letter that it "did not deliver the clarity or consistency that schools need".
She said the government had therefore "strengthened" the guidance issued last week, to make it "explicit" that pupils should not be using their phones at school.
Shadow policing minister Matt Vickers told BBC Breakfast he was "entirely supportive of us empowering headteachers to make sure that classrooms are places of learning".
But Laura Trott, the shadow education secretary, said the letter was "yet more guidance", which she said "doesn't represent action, it's just more delay".
Phillipson's letter to schools comes just under a week after the announcement that the government would be launching a three-month consultation on banning social media for all under-16s in the UK.
The education secretary has encouraged teachers to "contribute your professional insight".
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has already said her party would introduce such a ban if it was in power.
Ofsted has issued its own advice on how it will inspect schools based on the government's guidance.
Part of that guidance includes telling staff not to use their devices for personal reasons in front of pupils.
Recent research by the survey tool Teacher Tapp suggested 86% of primary school teachers said they were able to use their phones at school for personal use, but only during breaks, while 44% of secondary school teachers said they were allowed to use their phones freely.
Only 2% of both primary and secondary teachers surveyed said their schools banned staff from using phones entirely during the school day.
Tony McCabe, head teacher at St Joseph's High School in Horwich, Greater Manchester, said he welcomed the guidance because phones can be "very destructive for young people during the school day".
He told BBC Breakfast that screen time for children was "incredibly excessive", with some looking at devices for as long as five hours before the school day had even begun.
Mobile phones are banned from being used at his school, except for in emergency situations with adult supervision.
But he said that it was important to strike a balance, adding: "We've got to prepare them for the world of work out there. That involves emerging technology. We can't ignore that it exists and I believe that schools have a role and a duty to educate young people to use that technology wisely and effectively."
Esther Ghey, whose daughter Brianna was killed by two teenagers who had viewed violent content online, said the guidance was "a step in the right direction", but argued it did not go far enough.
She told BBC Breakfast there was a risk of the rules on phones becoming a "postcode lottery" if there was no legal ban, where some schools could enforce policies more effectively than others.
Teaching unions have generally welcomed the social media consultation, but pushed back on the suggestion of Ofsted monitoring schools' mobile phone policies.
Paul Whiteman, general secretary of the National Association of Head Teachers, said school leaders "need support from government, not the threat of heavy-handed inspection".
Pepe Di'Iasio, general secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders, said the letter would provide clarity for schools and parents, and said he hoped it would be the first step towards the overall ban on social media for under-16s.
Although the government consultation on social media concerns the whole of the UK, its guidance for schools on phones only includes England, as education is a devolved policy area.
The Senedd said last year that phones should not be banned "outright" from schools in Wales, but that schools themselves should be supported to set and implement their own policies.
In Northern Ireland, Education Minister Paul Givan previously advised schools to restrict pupils in their use of mobile phones, and has recently supported a campaign encouraging parents not to buy their children smartphones until they reach 14 years old.
And in Scotland, schools have been given government guidance on setting their own rules, such as pupils having to hand in phones before lessons, or not being allowed to use them on school trips.
Sign up for our Politics Essential newsletter to keep up with the inner workings of Westminster and beyond.