Closing down?: the move to scrap Colombia’s science, technology and innovation ministry – dubbed MinCiencias - is preliminary and has not yet been officially submitted (courtesy: MinCiencias)

Colombia’s science ministry faces an uncertain future

by · Physics World

Nicolás Bustamante Hernández reports how scientists in Colombia are responding to government reforms that would scrap the country’s science ministry

A planned reform to science in Colombia has reopened a debate how the country views science. According to Colombian TV news outlet Noticias RCN, the government, led by president Abelardo de la Espriella, proposing to merge the science, technology and innovation ministry – dubbed MinCiencias – with the education ministry.

The move – framed within the government’s austerity measures – is preliminary and has not yet been officially submitted. If it goes ahead, however, it would see the science ministry scrapped just seven years after it was created. Science would then be without its own seat in the presidential cabinet.

When MinCiencias was set up in 2019, it replaced Colciencias, the state agency that had for decades coordinated science policy and administered much of Colombia’s public research funding. But MinCiencias inherited many of its predecessor’s limitations, with Carlos Vargas, president of the Colombian Academy of Exact, Physical and Natural Sciences, recalling it was given no extra cash for personnel or operating expenses.

“We created an institution with the responsibility of leading the country’s scientific and technological transformation, but without simultaneously establishing a stable funding system,” Vargas told Physics World.

According to biochemist Moisés Wasserman, former rector of the National University of Colombia, there were two major fears when MinCiencias was created. The first was that it would become subject to political interests and the second being it would never receive an adequate budget. “Both fears came true,” he says.

Funding issues

Funding has remained one of Colombia’s persistent weaknesses with the country investing around 0.2% of gross domestic product (GDP) in science and technology. Problems with budget spending have added to those concerns. In February, Colombia’s watchdog that oversees the conduct of public officials, identified possible irregularities in a US$200m fund for science and artificial-intelligence projects.

Then in May, the Colombian senate noted that only 7% of the US$1.7bn allocated for science between 2025 and 2026 had been spent, with dozens of projects stalled. Scientists and academics have also accused successive administrations of politicising parts of the system and allowing cronyism to influence how resources are distributed.

While the countries that are leading in artificial intelligence and the space economy are strengthening their scientific institutions, Colombia barely reaches 0.2% [of GDP spending on science]Santiago Vargas

For Colombian scientists, however, abolishing the science ministry would not necessarily solve those problems. Astrophysicist Santiago Vargas, director of the National Astronomical Observatory of Colombia in Bogotá, says the ministry’s deeper problem is the lack of long-term stability required to build scientific capacity in the country.

“While the countries that are leading in artificial intelligence and the space economy are strengthening their scientific institutions, Colombia barely reaches 0.2% [of GDP spending on science],” he told Physics World. “That’s unacceptable”.

Carlos Vargas suggests that the government should retain a ministry responsible for defining science policy while creating an autonomous technical agency to manage funding calls, infrastructure and separate policy-making from implementation. For him, the question should not simply be whether the ministry failed, but whether Colombia ever gave it the tools it needed to succeed.

“What we cannot do,” he says, “is confuse an institution that was insufficiently strengthened with one that is unnecessary.”