An elm tree during fall.- Credit: elenathewise / DepositPhotos - License: DepositPhotos

Amsterdam removes 180 elms after 8-year study into best soil for largest trees

Amsterdam officials and Wageningen University researchers pulled 180 identical elms from the ground on Friday, NOS reports. The removals mark the end of an eight-year experiment designed to identify which soil mixes grow large, shade-producing trees quickly in tight urban conditions.

The trees were planted in 15 different soil mixtures in Amsterdam’s port area so scientists could compare growth under identical urban conditions. Root scans taken this week will now be combined with eight years of trunk and crown measurements to determine the most effective growing medium.

The trial reflects a shift in how the city approaches street trees. Extreme summer heat has increased the need for broad crowns that provide more shade. Officials say the results will help address limited underground space.

“There is little space underground in our city,” said Lian Heinhuis, the alderman responsible for green spaces. “It is quite difficult for trees to grow in the city.”

The municipality plans to use the findings to plant more trees, particularly in neighborhoods that need the most cooling. “This information is actually interesting for the whole world,” Heinhuis said. “Other cities face similar challenges.”

The project involved researchers from Wageningen University and other tree specialists. Mixtures tested included tree sand, stony blends, and materials the city has used for about 25 years.

Early visual checks already showed clear differences. One mixture produced a smaller root ball with fewer fine roots, the thin strands that take up water and nutrients.

It is still too early to name a single best mixture. Finer soils appear to support better root growth, and the city has already decided it will no longer use granulate that contains clay.

The 180 elms will be replanted elsewhere in Amsterdam. Most are expected to go into parks, though some may be placed alone on streets in a mixture that already looks promising from initial results.