Wind Forecast for L.A. Fires Was Weaker Than Expected, but Could Pick Up Wednesday

L.A. Wildfires 

Skip to content

Tuesday’s Winds Didn’t Reach Their Predicted Speeds, but Wednesday’s Might

On Tuesday afternoon, forecasters at the National Weather Service dropped their most severe warnings for the rest of the day. But the alerts will be back in place early Wednesday.

• Share full article

By Judson Jones and Amy Graff

Judson Jones is a meteorologist and reporter for The Times. Amy Graff reported from Los Angeles.

Meteorologists get it wrong sometimes.

Thankfully, when they got a Los Angeles weather forecast wrong this week, it was because the winds were weaker than predicted on Tuesday and no longer met the National Weather Service’s criteria for a “particularly dangerous situation.” The phrase describes a rare, high-level warning that is meant to be used only every few years for the worst possible wildfire conditions of dried vegetation, low humidity and strong winds.

Just a week ago, at the start of a cycle of four Santa Ana wind events that have overtaken the region since then, the forecast warned of a “particularly dangerous” wildfire outlook, with a windstorm of a strength not seen in over a decade. That forecast was realized when the Palisades fire, the Eaton fire and other blazes sent Los Angeles residents fleeing from their homes as a torrent of winds pushed fires raging through their neighborhoods.

Weather Service meteorologists make their forecasts based on a combination of current conditions, historical events and computer weather models. They take all this information in and then forecast what they think is the most likely outcome. There are always outliers, conditions that could occur but are less likely.

Sometimes, a storm will overperform the forecast, and sometimes it will under perform. In meteorology, both eventualities are considered “busted forecasts.” While forecasters who predict an especially extreme event might be happy if the conditions aren’t as bad as they had predicted, they know that if the forecast is off by too much, people will trust future warnings a little less.

James Brotherton, a meteorologist with the Weather Service in Los Angeles, said he would much rather have a forecast be wrong if it meant there was “less pain and suffering.”

Ahead of this cycle of winds, forecasters put another “particularly dangerous situation” warning in place from 4 a.m. Tuesday through noon on Wednesday, as they feared more strong winds would help fuel existing fires and possibly spark new ones. But by early Tuesday afternoon, the winds were proving to be less strong than expected, and the Weather Service dropped the warning for the rest of the day. The move was temporary, and another “particularly dangerous situation” warning will be in place from 3 a.m. to 3 p.m. Wednesday.

Ryan Kittell, another forecaster in the Los Angeles office, compared it to someone filling out an N.C.A.A. bracket every March. “Even if you’re the best, at some point you won’t have a forecast verify as you would like,” he said.

The “particularly dangerous situation” designation is still a relatively new tool, Mr. Kittell said. Tuesday’s forecast was always right at the line between high level and not, and the office opted to use the stronger warning because of the ongoing fires across the region, he said.

Robert Clark, a fire behavior analyst for Cal Fire who is working on the Palisades fire, was relieved Tuesday’s winds weren’t as powerful. The fire didn’t grow overnight, and quieter weather was allowing crews to extinguish fire in pockets of smoldering landscape and vegetation.

While conditions have improved, Mr. Clark said he was most concerned about the forecast for the Santa Ana winds to pick up again Tuesday night into Wednesday.

“And then we’re looking out to the future to see what happens with the weather forecast with an additional round of Santa Ana winds possible next week,” he said.

More on the Los Angeles Wildfires

• At the Ignition Point: In the hills above Pacific Palisades, there is crime scene tape and scattered debris, clues to what may have caused the initial fire.
• Hunting for Housing: Tens of thousands of evacuees in Los Angeles are scrambling to find temporary shelter, exacerbating the housing shortage in one of America’s least affordable cities.
• A Call for Help: A father and his son, who both used wheelchairs, called for help in evacuating from the Eaton fire. None came, and now their family is asking what happened.
• The Mayor’s Broken Pledge: Before taking office, Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass had said she would not go abroad. She was overseas when wildfires erupted.
• Private Firefighters in Demand: While the fires overwhelmed emergency responders, some property owners turned to private firefighters, who have become a coveted resource in wealthy communities.