Forget coal, lord mayor - Newcastle is a coffee town now

by · Newcastle Herald

SHARE YOUR OPINION

Email letters@newcastleherald.com.au or send a text to 0427 154 176 (include name and suburb). Letters should be fewer than 200 words. Short Takes should be fewer than 50 words. Disclose political party roles or affiliations. Correspondence may be edited in any form.

Newcastle lord mayor Gavin Morris. File picture

Newcastle has traded coal for coffee, Cr Morris

Dear me. Gavin Morris, new-ish lord mayor of Newcastle, is clutching at his pearls because he used his casting vote with support from the Labor NSW government to go against climate action groups, and other unknown protest groups, to use council-owned land for their democratic right of protest in this land of free speech and action. Yes, lots of people are not happy with you, Cr Morris. Actions do have consequences, and I imagine you will indeed be using taxpayer money to defend your decision in court.

I don't understand how you were not up to speed with the fact that Newcastle is not a coal town anymore. It is a university town. Its demographics in 2026 includes students, well-heeled retirees who are concerned about the impact of climate change on the futures of their grandchildren, and a lot of tourists. There are more coffee shops in Newcastle per person than in Melbourne or Sydney. Novocastrians are well over the film of coal dust that coats their lungs and their homes, and being bled dry by multinational coal companies that do not pay their fair share of tax and send their profits overseas. Cr Morris is on the wrong side of history and I think any of his political ambitions have just hit troubled waters. As a weatherman, he should have seen this one coming.

Wendy Atkins, Cooks Hill

What happens when the tide turns

As expected, the same mob of unruly demonstrators blocked Newcastle Harbour with their silly little canoes.

And as usual the police did nothing because they were outnumbered by a factor that would have required physical force, with injuries from both sides. I tend to believe that the judicial system would be sympathetic. But what are the consequences when they don't expect to be penalised for disobeying police direction?

At the very least, I would have confiscated their canoes instead of a fine that they might never pay, and then auction the canoes off to help pay for the cost of keeping them safe. The police have far better things to do. After all, the protesters were just having a bit of fun, but what happens when a demonstration becomes violent (which seems to be becoming a more regular practice)? Is civil disobedience being taught at schools? Not so much by the teachers, but outside influence, because children are impressionable and not wise to being responsible. As for the adults, settle down and stop carrying on like children. Next time it may be violent, and your children may be held responsible.

Carl Stevenson, Dora Creek

Young see protests as necessary

I hate to break it to the Newcastle Herald but I don't think many young people who are concerned about climate change being an existential threat to human life and this planet read letters criticising Rising Tide's protests in the Herald ("Rising Tide cools off simmering tension", Opinion 17/11").

I asked some much younger people than me at the Rising Tide's Paddle for Planet last Saturday if they read the Newcastle Herald and its letters page and all said no. They are instead prolific users of social media. I think a much larger survey would probably show that most young people don't read, and don't trust, mainstream media to present their views. There is a perception that the fossil fuel industry gets more favourable coverage. Young people, it seems to me, see Rising Tide actions as necessary whether tactical decisions at the protests mean arrests or not. Building a climate mass movement won't stop because of criticism or anti-democratic actions by governments and police.

Kerry Vernon, New Lambton

We can't ignore Sandpapergate

The controversy over the South African cricket test in 2018 has become appalling with players now openly critical of each other. Cricket Australia (CA) had the resources to fully investigate the behaviour of the team and made a report in 2018. It penalised three players very severely, way above the recommendations of the International Cricket Council (ICC).

It has become increasingly clear the matter was not investigated thoroughly enough, allowing the division among players to become embarrassingly obvious in what I see as a lack of leadership. The issue will not go away, allowing the disintegration of the camaraderie of our cricketers in disarray. There is now a very obvious need to investigate the issue independently and thoroughly by CA.

The disgrace is letting our players deal with the issue while CA looks on, hoping it will go away. The lack of integrity will reflect in lower appeal for the cricket, which means lower income with an expanding cost base. That's a potential disaster.

Emus stick their heads in the sand to avoid a problem, but I have never seen that approach work well.

Grahame Danaher, Coal Point

We're missing Sonia Hornery here already

A milestone on Monday, with the ribbon cutting of the Newcastle Inner City Bypass with the local federal and state politicians. I could help but notice that our local hard-working member, Sonia Hornery, was not there. Instead we had a non-elected politician that does not live in the area who says that if elected she may move. What is wrong with our local people that know what the people want in Wallsend, like Sonia did?

Ian Bartrop, Birmingham Gardens

Newcastle MP Sharon Claydon, Maitland MP Jenny Aitchison, Minister for the Hunter Yasmin Catley and Labor Wallsend candidate Emily Suvaal. Picture by Marina Neil

Lord mayor made the right call

A kayaker going under a ship or a tug could well be catastrophic for the kayaker, and spare a thought for the crews on the ships and tugs having to deal with the aftermath. The lord mayor made an honest call regarding safety in the shipping channel. The Newcastle Cruising Yacht Club safety information regarding harbour shipping collision regulations backs him up. How about the protests without the shenanigans? Thanks Debra Forbes, great words ("Peaceful protest not much to ask", Letters, 16/11).

Ian Gilkes, Adamstown

Compassion may be left adrift

Great letter from Niko Leka ("Blockades are bold action", Letters, 17/11). The more we drift politically to the right, the further we move from humanity and compassion.

Mac Maguire, Charlestown

It's only scary if it's more specific

Niko Leka riles about hypocrisy and absurdity ("Blockades are bold action", Letters, 17/11), claiming that 500,000 people will die as a result of El Nino, without advising of where, in what timeline and when. This is the epitome of absurdity.

Shane Tull, Redhead

Book tells a cautionary tale

I have just read the Paul Barry book about Sanjeev Gupta. A great analysis of the failures around the world of regulation authorities and the weakness of politicians. It is amazing that the Australian authorities and governments did not remember Bond and Skase, who were amateurs compared to this.

David Reynolds, Coal Point