Joseph Farrugia (left) posted a drawing of a clown (inset) on Facebook, in reference to Nigel Vella (right). Photos: Social media, File photos

No breach of privilege in Labour MP's spat with Joseph Farrugia

Speaker rules no breach of privilege after social media insult between Vella and Farrugia

by · Times of Malta

The Speaker of the House has ruled that there was no breach of parliamentary privilege when Joseph Farrugia, former president of the Malta Employers, called Labour MP Nigel Vella a “clown” on Facebook.

Vella requested the ruling on Monday, arguing that the insult towards him amounted to a breach of parliamentary privilege.

Speaker Carmelo Abela said Vella was within his rights to request the ruling, but ruled that, in this context, there was no breach of privilege.

However, he appealed for more responsible use of social media and careful word choice.

“Freedom of expression must always be guaranteed, but it should not be abused. This applies particularly to people who had or have a public role and hold more responsibility,” the Speaker said.

A bitter row between Farrugia and Vella erupted on Facebook in recent days, sparked by Farrugia’s decision to return his Ġieħ ir-Republika honour after Yorgen Fenech was acquitted of masterminding Daphne Caruana Galizia’s murder.

Vella criticised Farrugia for rejecting the honour but choosing to remain on government-appointed boards and receiving payment for those appointments.

The Labour MP claimed Farrugia held or had held five remunerated board positions worth approximately €20,000 per year, citing parliamentary replies.

However, the Malta Employers’ said the figures were inflated, while distancing itself from Farrugia’s personal decision to return the honour.

In parliament this week, Vella tabled screenshots of Farrugia’s social media insults towards him and requested the parliamentary ruling, citing a breach of parliamentary privilege.

Parliamentary privilege normally governs statements made in the House by Members of Parliament, allowing them immunity from civil or criminal proceedings.

Sign up to our free newsletters

Get the latest stories and updates from Times of Malta delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscribe