Alfred Sant was speaking alongside former prime minister and political rival Lawrence Gonzi in a Times of Malta event for subscribers. Photo: Matthew Mirabelli

Alfred Sant: 'Taxing TCNs is crazy. Make them join unions instead'

Clyde Caruana is doing the right thing the 'wrong way around', the former prime minister believes

by · Times of Malta

Alfred Sant believes Budget 2027 measures targeting third-country nationals are 'crazy' and will not address overpopulation.

Clyde Caruana is right to increase labour costs because that is the only good strategy, but he is doing it clumsily and "the wrong way around", the former prime minister said during a Times of Malta event on Monday.

The conversation between Sant and fellow former prime minister Lawrence Gonzi was exclusive to Times of Malta subscribers.

"Caruana is trying to raise the costs of imported labour, and that's right. That's what you should do. There's no other way. But how do you do it? By putting fees on the poorer class, as is happening now, which is crazy?" Sant said.

Alfred Sant dubbed the measures "cack-handed". Video: Matthew Mirabelli, Xandru Azzopardi

"[Caruana is] trying to do it in a cack-handed way. It's the wrong way around," You don't do it by attacking the guys in the lowest bracket, but by putting pressure on the employers bringing these guys over."

Sant said the measures would simply drive away third-country national (TCN) workers who could not afford the new expenses, with employers replacing them with others from countries where workers are more desperate and ready to accept meagre salaries.

"There you are. It doesn't work," he said. "And apart from that, it also fuels racism and xenophobia."

'Make them join a union'

The real solution, according to Sant, is mandatory trade union membership, which Labour proposed a few years back but shelved "after pushback from employers".

TCNs are poorer because they lack social protection, he said, and unions would give "the underclass the power to negotiate back" and raise salaries. That raises labour costs for employers without hitting those who do not have a vote and can afford it the least.

"Making them join a trade union will give them the social protection they need," he said.

"That way wages will increase, Maltese workers will be less induced to move to the public sector, and there will be a bigger push on producers to invest in devices that save labour and increase productivity."

But the idea will be resisted, he added.

"Critics will say obligatory union membership goes against the principle of freedom of association, which is rubbish," he said.

"If you don't have anything to defend you in society, what use is freedom of association to you?"

A shelved promise

Labour’s 2022 manifesto (proposal 193) said it agreed in principle with mandatory trade union membership and would open talks with social partners on implementing it.

In July 2025, after nearly three years of discussions, the government said, citing legal advice, that pursuing it was not legally advisable.

Last month, Clyde Caruana announced a raft of measures targeting non-EU workers as part of the government's budget plan for 2027. 

TCNs will have to start paying for childcare, which until now was provided for free. They will also be charged significantly higher fees to renew their work permits, an €83 monthly fee to drive a car and €33 monthly to take the bus. 

The church, along with various activists, employers, TCNs and childcare operators have since criticised the measures.

They said they were worried they might impact their operations and send out the wrong message - that not all workers deserve equal treatment.

But in an interview with Times of Malta last week, the finance minister defended the measures, saying his aim is not to be cruel with workers, but to nudge employers to realign the economy towards investment in capital, instead of more foreign labour.

Employers of TCN workers will likely have to cover the new costs themselves or lose their much-needed staff to a rival who will, he said.

Each TCN worker will, therefore, cost more, and employers will have less appetite to bring in new ones. If cheap labour becomes more expensive, employers will want fewer workers and invest in technology, automation and AI instead.

Subscribe to Times of Malta to get full, exclusive access to the 90-minute conversation between Alfred Sant and Lawrence Gonzi. 

Sign up to our free newsletters

Get the latest stories and updates from Times of Malta delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscribe