Supreme Court says accused cannot choose where victims file complaintsParvez Sagar

SC allows separate probes into virtual cloud space investment fraud

The Supreme Court observed that an accused cannot dictate where victims lodge complaints and said overlapping investigations could not be used to give the accused an advantage.

by · India Today

In Short

  • Supreme Court says accused cannot choose where victims file complaints
  • Court allows accused to approach state high courts for relief
  • Justice Joymalya Bagchi stresses strict action against organised cybercrime

The Supreme Court on Friday refused to consolidate FIRs filed across states against an accused in an alleged investment fraud involving the sale of virtual cloud space, Press Trust of India reported.

The court observed that an accused cannot dictate where victims lodge complaints and said overlapping investigations could not be used to give the accused an advantage.

A bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana was hearing a petition filed by Bhumi Uptalbhai Patel, who sought relief in criminal cases registered in Gujarat and Haryana.

While declining to consolidate the FIRs registered in the two states, the bench said Patel could approach the respective high courts for relief over the consolidation of cases within each state.

During the hearing, Justice Bagchi said an accused could neither choose where victims register their complaints nor prevent police forces in different states from investigating alleged offences within their jurisdictions, PTI reported.

“We are not going to give advantage to an accused in respect of overlapping investigations. It is for the agencies to consider,” he said.

The bench said the law must be applied in the “harshest” manner while dealing with organised cybercrime. Rejecting the request for a lenient approach, Justice Bagchi said, “No leeway. The law has to be taken at its harshest level.”

Criminal proceedings against Patel are pending before trial courts in Gandhinagar, Gujarat, and Faridabad, Haryana. According to court records, Patel had surrendered and the relevant custody certificate had been submitted.

Patel had spent five months and five days in judicial custody as an undertrial prisoner and was lodged in Central Jail, Ahmedabad, Gujarat.

The Supreme Court, therefore, left Patel free to seek relief from the respective high courts but refused to combine the FIRs filed in Gujarat and Haryana.

- Ends