Chinese spy suspect walks free after Prague court acquittal, while Czech spy suspect in China remains behind bars

by · EUobserver

Police escorted Yang Yiming into Prague’s municipal court on Monday. (Source: Lukáš Prchal / Deník N)

Europe today

Unlock article and share
By Ondřej Kundra,
Prague
,

First published in Respekt.

Yang Yiming, a suspected Chinese spy, has walked free after his arrest earlier this year in the Czech Republic.

Prague Municipal Court judge Tome Frankič found that Yiming posed as a foreign correspondent for a Chinese media outlet while working for the country’s intelligence services. He accepted assignments to covertly pass on information he obtained about politicians and other public figures.

And yet, the man was released this week on Monday (2 November). In the view of judge Frankič, the evidence against Yiming did not show he broke the law.

Suspected Chinese spy walks free

In court, the prosecution failed to prove Yiming had “intentionally endangered or damaged the constitutional order, territorial integrity, defence or security of the Czech Republic, or undermined its sovereignty.”

The trial of the Chinese man was the first of its kind in modern-day Czech Republic.

Previously, espionage could be prosecuted only if police or intelligence services could prove that a person had obtained classified information such as government documents or intelligence-service materials.

But the Czech security community argued for years that defining the offence of spying was defined too narrowly, and could not adequately tackle espionage.

Indeed, collecting information on people's private lives - whether it be their alcoholism or intimate relationships - could be enough to blackmail some to advance the interests of foreign powers.

So the previous Czech government passed a new, broader criminal offence - unauthorised activity for a foreign power.

Now, bringing someone before a Czech court requires proof of activities for a foreign power with intent to endanger the Czech Republic's constitutional order, sovereignty, territorial integrity, defence or security.

To read this story, log in or subscribe

Enjoy access to all articles and 25 years of archives, comment and gift articles. Become a subscriber for as low as €1,75 per week.

Read without limits
Already a subscriber? Login
Unlock article and share

Latest from China

Czech MEP Markéta Gregorová stopped at Chinese border in ‘pseudo-scare tactics’

Listen: Why is the EU introducing a new €2 charge on parcels?

Latest from Czech Republic

Czech public broadcasters hold historic strike following government vote to abolish licence fees

Czech government approves first step to scrapping TV and radio licence fees in 4.36am vote, sparking protests

Latest from Espionage

Ex-EU commissioner Reynders faces new Belgian and Polish scrutiny after EUobserver revelations

[EXCLUSIVE] Leaked WhatsApps between ex-EU commissioner Reynders and senior Belgian spy reveal attempts to bury allegations of his possible Russia ties

Latest from Europe today

Details emerge of Russian atrocity: dropping three-tonne bombs on civilians at food bank and shelter (Ukraine Battlefield update, Day 1,715)

‘Emotional part’ of Polish court crisis is ‘closer to over’ says Tusk, amid talks of EU mediation

Police escorted Yang Yiming into Prague's municipal court on Monday. (Source: Lukáš Prchal / Deník N)

Topics

Author Bio

Ondřej Kundra is the deputy editor-in-chief of Respekt, where he has been a permanent editorial member since 2002 focusing on Czech politics, justice, and the influence of foreign powers like Russia and China. He is award-winning investigative journalist, he has authored several books covering topics ranging from Russian intelligence services and European jihadists to Czech military aid for Ukraine.

+ Follow author by email