Census portal lists ISKCON among 287 ‘other’ religions; removed

The religion question keeps the seven categories used in earlier Censuses.

by · The Siasat Daily

New Delhi: A drop-down list of 287 “other” religions, which named groups such as ISKCON, Sarna, Shia, Sunni and Pentecostal, was pulled from the Census 2027 self-enumeration portal within hours of going live.

The list appeared under the ‘Others’ option of the religion question when the portal (se.census.gov.in) opened on Monday, November 16, for residents of Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, Goa and Uttarakhand, The Hindu reported. All four states are due for Assembly polls early next year.

It was taken down later that day after The Hindu asked the Union Home Ministry to respond on the classification.

The office of the Registrar General and Census Commissioner of India (RG&CCI) said ‘Others’ was still an open field. A representative said the “respondent is free to write any other religion as in previous censuses.” The representative also denied that the listed terms had been shown as separate religions.

Sects, saints and deities

The religion question keeps the seven categories used in earlier Censuses. These are Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain and Others.

This is the first time the ‘Others’ option has been broken up into a menu. In the 2001 and 2011 Censuses, the government treated many of these entries as sects within one of the six major religions or recorded them as write-in answers under “other religions and persuasions.”

These included Sanatan, Shri Ram, Shri Krishna, Balmiki, Bishnoi, Tantric, Yogi and Methodist. Several others have never appeared in Census records, among them ISKCON, Ramakrishna Paramhans, Ramdev, Khalsa, Tirupati Balaji, Gorak Nath, Basaveshwara, Devi Maa and Dev Samaj.

‘Meant to avoid spelling errors’

A government official told The Hindu that the names had been compiled as predictive text entries that auto-complete an enumerator’s entry. For instance, a respondent who says they follow ISKCON would then be recorded without spelling variations.

The official said officials are looking into how the list became a selectable drop-down.

That explanation does not match what enumerators were told in training. Before the list was withdrawn, an official in Uttar Pradesh who trained enumerators said respondents choosing ‘Others’ could pick from more than 280 names. If their faith was missing, they could type it in and it would be recorded as given.

Sarna on the list

Sarna’s presence on the withdrawn list comes amid a long-running campaign by tribal groups in Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, Odisha and West Bengal. They want a separate religion column for Adivasi faiths, which they say are distinct from Hinduism. 

The Jharkhand Assembly passed a resolution in November 2020 seeking a separate Sarna code in the Census.

Schedule in poll-bound states

Self-enumeration in the four states runs till November 30. Under a Home Ministry notification issued on September 5, house-to-house enumeration will follow from December 1 to January 4, 2027. A revisional round will run from January 5 to 9. The reference date for these states is 00:00 hours on January 5, 2027.

The exercise was brought forward in these states because their Assembly terms end by May 2027. For the rest of the country, the portal opens in January and population enumeration is set for February 2027.

The RG&CCI notified 40 questions for the population enumeration phase on August 14. Thirteen of them are new compared with the 29-question schedule of 2011.

The new questions cover spouse’s name, nationality, father’s and mother’s particulars, digital literacy, permanent residential address, place of COVID-19 vaccination, number of bank accounts and passport number. They also ask whether the person holds a driving licence, and for mobile, Aadhaar and voter ID numbers where available.

First digital Census

The Census is the first since 2011 and has been delayed by six years. It is the country’s first digital headcount and the first to offer self-enumeration. It is also the first since Independence to record caste for all communities.

Scheduled Castes (SC) and Scheduled Tribes (ST) respondents select their caste from a drop-down, but everyone else will type it into an open field, despite demands for a full list. The government has said there is no single list of castes apart from the SC and ST lists.