Netanyahu’s takedown of Barkat: Chronicle of a political elimination foretold

The economy minister plotted to oust Netanyahu after October 7. Now he’s facing the wrath of a prime minister who neither forgets nor forgives

The script for the clash between Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Economy Minister Nir Barkat was written well in advance, and none of it should come as a surprise.

In their highly dysfunctional relationship, everything has unfolded with predictable precision. The trajectory has been clear and meticulously documented over the years — especially in the aftermath of the October 7 Hamas massacre — and the dramatic climax heading into the August 17 Likud party primary shouldn’t shock anyone.

It is abundantly clear that Netanyahu is finally seizing the opportunity he has been waiting for: to throw Barkat under the bus, just like the premier has done with all his other enemies, or at the very least relegate him to the margins of the party slate after years of systematically eroding his standing.

The schemes Barkat previously devised to remove Netanyahu from the premiership only fueled the prime minister’s boundless appetite for revenge. In Monday’s internal elections, both men will face their moment of truth. For now, the target is locked and the political hit job is well underway. We’ve watched it play out across television channels and social media all week.

The October 7 disaster found Barkat — a self-made tech billionaire who amassed a fortune as an early investor in Check Point Software before serving as mayor of Jerusalem — in a distinct state of mind. Like many Israelis, he simply could not fathom why Prime Minister Netanyahu didn’t immediately convene a special press conference and announce his resignation.

Barkat was already convinced back then that Netanyahu was a walking disaster and that every additional day he remained in power endangered the country. Barkat argued that Netanyahu’s conciliatory policy toward Hamas had led directly to the horrific catastrophe in the Gaza border communities and on every other front. The colossal failure, he told associates in private, would inevitably bring ruin upon Likud, as Netanyahu stood zero chance of reelection.

At the end of May 2024, Zman Israel — The Times of Israel’s sister site in Hebrew — reported on Barkat’s thinking and the practical steps he was initiating. Those who met him during those days encountered a man seething with rage at Netanyahu over the failure and tragedy — no less angry than the speakers addressing the mass protests against the judicial overhaul on Tel Aviv’s Kaplan Street a year earlier, the epicenter of the movement against the coalition.

Barkat believed the crisis offered a natural opening for him to oust the man responsible for everything that had gone wrong. He wagered that public fury at Netanyahu would only intensify, seeping into the right-wing electorate and Likud voters, ultimately paving Barkat’s own path to the leadership of both the party and the government.

Barkat had a clear strategy: push for early Likud primaries, where he would easily defeat Netanyahu, aided in no small part by his virtually unlimited financial resources.

Barkat firmly believed Likud members would embrace the alternative he offered rather than allow themselves to be dragged toward political oblivion. According to internal polls he presented to Likud Knesset members and prominent party activists —  of whom he commands a loyal following — Barkat was the only figure capable of securing 30 seats and preserving right-wing rule for the long haul.

Simultaneously, Barkat was quietly engineering a constructive vote of no-confidence that would allow the Knesset to topple a sitting prime minister, but only if a majority simultaneously votes to install a specific alternative leader, thereby replacing the government without triggering a snap general election.

Barkat planned to bring down the government in cooperation with the opposition and rally behind the candidacy of senior Likud MK Yuli Edelstein, then the chairman of the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee and a former Knesset speaker. Edelstein had long been a formidable internal opponent of Netanyahu.

Following this maneuver, Barkat planned to hold Likud primaries a year later, where he expected to sweep the board.

That plan never materialized. Edelstein told me at the time: “It has no chance whatsoever. Everyone in our party is afraid to go against Netanyahu.”

Barkat’s alternate plans also fizzled. Netanyahu began to politically recover and mount a counter-offensive. He successfully cultivated a narrative among his base that he was the victim of a trap laid by the senior defense establishment, and the Likud grassroots increasingly rallied back to his side.

Barkat, whom Netanyahu had deliberately excluded from any influence over diplomatic or security affairs, refusing even to appoint him as a guest observer in the security cabinet, still tried to stake out independent positions and attack Netanyahu from the right, per his advisers’ instructions. But every such statement boomeranged.

In an interview with the fiercely pro-Netanyahu, right-wing Channel 14 on Wednesday, Barkat claimed his past opposition toward Netanyahu had been purely substantive, reiterating his own refusal to allow tens of thousands of Palestinian laborers back into Israel. He argued that Netanyahu was failing to remove bureaucratic hurdles to recruiting foreign workers from countries at peace with Israel.

Netanyahu responded through the Likud spokesperson’s office: “While the prime minister is leading the war effort in the face of enormous international pressure, Barkat is joining those who malign Prime Minister Netanyahu in order to win an embrace from the media.”

There was more. Barkat met with Druze Likud activists early in the war and declared, “Netanyahu and Defense Minister [Yoav] Gallant are leftists disguised as right-wingers. They are cowards. [Hezbollah leader Hassan] Nasrallah can smell their weakness.” Netanyahu shot back harshly. “Barkat knows nothing and is only encouraging our enemies to get a headline,” the Prime Minister’s Office stated at the time.

Following that clash, Barkat gradually lowered his profile. He eventually realized this battle could cost him dearly, given Netanyahu’s resurgent popularity within the Likud base. He capitulated, pivoting to lavish the prime minister with effusive, sometimes embarrassing, praise — including this week — commending Netanyahu for his “wise and courageous diplomatic and security leadership.”

Barkat went further, making a high-profile appearance at the Tel Aviv District Court where Netanyahu was testifying in his ongoing corruption trial. Barkat claimed on camera that the cases were fabricated and the trial was unnecessary. In a subsequent interview on Channel 12, Barkat even referred to Netanyahu as the “supreme leader.”

But the prime minister’s inner circle remembers everything and forgets nothing.

Last November, as the long primary campaign began with internal elections for party convention delegates, Barkat allied with his longtime rival, Regional Cooperation Minister Dudi Amsalem. Amsalem is a highly influential Likud power broker, particularly within the party’s powerful Jerusalem branch, and Barkat sought his help in a bid to take control of the local apparatus.

Throughout that local contest, the prime minister’s son, Yair Netanyahu, sent messages from his home in Miami to prominent Jerusalem activists, demanding they not support “someone who wants to bring down my father.”

Netanyahu and his loyalists now want to add Barkat to the long list of senior figures who have been thrown under the bus and left to grope their way through the political wilderness — a list that includes Gallant, Edelstein, former ambassador to the UN Gilad Erdan, and many others over the years. As far as the Netanyahu camp is concerned, Barkat remains a clear and present danger.

In conversations Yair Netanyahu held with Likud activists in November, he reportedly claimed that if the coming general election produces no decisive result, Barkat will once again move to oust Netanyahu simply to prevent Likud from ending up in the opposition.

On Monday, we will find out how the campaign against Barkat concludes. For now, unfortunately for him, another front has opened up: Nearly all of the senior journalists at Channel 12, Israel’s most-watched mainstream commercial network, are hounding Barkat relentlessly.

This may be related to a bitter legal dispute currently being waged between Barkat and the network. Blow after blow is landing on Barkat from two opposing directions, and not all of the fight is being conducted strictly within the boundaries of journalistic or political ethics.

Barkat is now one of 33 ministers and MKs desperately fighting over just 15 or 16 remaining realistic spots on the Likud slate in the upcoming primary. In the previous primary, in 2022, he finished a respectable seventh, and he has worked the grassroots relentlessly ever since, signing up members and hosting lavish conferences.

Netanyahu, for his part, has just delivered another calculated jab at Barkat. The only external candidate Netanyahu has so far awarded a guaranteed spot on the Likud slate is Oren Dobronsky, a Silicon Valley tech entrepreneur and a star investor on Israel’s television show version of Shark Tank. Dobronsky occupies the exact high-tech innovator niche Barkat claims for himself.

Netanyahu also publicly announced that Dobronsky will serve as a minister in the next government. Anyone who thinks this is a random announcement with no connection to Barkat, just days before the primary, should think again.