A Syrian family walks through Schiphol Airport before departing the Netherlands.- Credit: Dienst Terugkeer en Vertrek Ministerie van Asiel en Migratie / Dienst Terugkeer en Vertrek Ministerie van Asiel en Migratie - License: All Rights Reserved

Asylum minister reaffirms Syria is safe despite Council of State ruling

Dutch Asylum Minister Bart van den Brink continues to consider Syria safe for return, despite being instructed by the Council of State to review his assessment. In a letter to Parliament, he said his latest evaluation still supports that position. The court had ordered a reassessment because the government's previous policy lacked sufficient justification.

Following the fall of the former Syrian regime, Van den Brink's predecessor, David van Weel, determined that the threat of indiscriminate violence had declined and that some parts of Syria were safe. The government subsequently tightened its asylum policy. Syrians must now show that they face a personal risk of danger because of their individual circumstances to qualify for a residence permit.

The minister has now set out the reasoning behind the policy. He points to assessments by sources including the European Union Agency for Asylum, which describe Syria's humanitarian situation as worrying but "a relatively limited degree of indiscriminate conflict-related violence".

The Council of State's ruling has already affected asylum procedures. The Immigration and Naturalisation Service (IND) has instructed officials to temporarily suspend decisions rejecting pending Syrian asylum applications while the government reviews its policy. Applications that can be approved may still be processed.

The ruling followed a case brought by a Syrian Palestinian man who applied for asylum in the Netherlands in 2023. He had been imprisoned and tortured by the Assad regime in 2014 over alleged participation in a demonstration.

Although the minister considered his account credible, the Council of State found that the government had not adequately considered the wider consequences of the former regime's actions when assessing the risks of returning to Syria.

Van den Brink acknowledges that Syria continues to face severe humanitarian problems after more than a decade of civil war. A February 2025 report by the United Nations Development Programme found that 50 percent of the country's infrastructure had been destroyed or rendered unusable during the conflict. Large-scale reconstruction has yet to take place.

An estimated 13.3 million people in Syria are experiencing food insecurity. An average of 3.82 million people received direct humanitarian assistance every month in 2025, representing approximately 32 percent of those in need, according to figures cited by the minister.

The minister also points to the number of Syrians who have returned since Assad's fall in December 2024. Approximately 1.91 million internally displaced people have returned to their regions of origin, while another 1.65 million refugees have returned from neighbouring countries, according to figures cited in his letter.

The legal debate is not yet over. The Court of Justice of the European Union is scheduled to hold a hearing on November 26 on a similar question concerning the role of humanitarian circumstances in assessing the safety of countries of origin. Van den Brink has decided to update his policy without waiting for the European Court's guidance.