A first round URC clean sweep for SA… Bittered by Boks

South Africa’s URC clean sweep highlighted impressive depth, but the Springboks’ Perth defeat showed the huge gap between franchise and Test rugby says Chris Nkomo of the @DummySwitchPod.

_________________________________________________________________________________

I know we're only one round in, but our franchises certainly gave us a glimpse of what could be and perhaps bolstered the argument behind the question I asked last week: is it really too much to expect all four South African franchises to make the URC top eight?

Yes, it's still early doors. But four from four isn't a bad way to start.

READ | Boks deserved to lose

Perhaps the Lions will be the only ones wondering what might have been, after narrowly missing out on a full house of points against a young but very well-coached Leinster side. The Stormers were definitely made to work for their win and did well to take control of the game in the second half against a tough Connacht side who will always back themselves at home. Connacht were well in it going into half-time, but ultimately couldn't outmuscle a Stormers pack that simply went to work, dominating possession and territory when it mattered.

The Lions, meanwhile, found a way to outlast a young but fiery Leinster side who actually had the better possession and territory statistics and will feel they simply ran out of time as they finished within a point. However, this Lions team looks like a completely different prospect this season, especially after that All Black game during RGR. And with so-called "underrated" guys like Erich Cronje making plays, they possess a potential threat that could finally rock this competition.

READ | Siya already making his mark at the Stormers

The Bulls and Sharks perhaps had the "easier" assignments of the four, but easier on paper doesn't mean automatic on the scoreboard. These are games that still need to be played and won and once again, there were youngsters making themselves known to the URC, notably Luan Gilliomee, who seems to have everybody sitting up every time he touches the ball.

All together, it was a very good start for our franchises and another reminder of the depth available in South African rugby.

And then came Perth.

Boks Make It A Bitter Weekend

That reminder of our depth quickly turned bitter as the Boks went on to lose the very next day. Whilst we basked in our URC clean sweep, salivating at the prospect of the depth coming through and our various teams' potential to "show us something" this season, the Boks went and poured water into our Sunday beers and suddenly, that good feeling left a rather bitter taste. It had arguably started earlier in the week with the controversy around the captain of the day and then culminated in a poor Bok showing that has already been well documented and dissected.

There is no point pretending otherwise, the Boks weren't good enough, but perhaps the bigger question coming out of the weekend isn't simply about the defeat itself; it's about the depth. The depth should absolutely be celebrated. It should be nurtured, tested and given opportunities. And yes, part of that process is pain, as they say.

Paul de Villiers in action against Australia. (Photo: Gallo Images)

But surely there has been enough pain and enough lessons along the way to know that Test rugby doesn't offer many free passes, because that is where the distinction needs to be made: a player can look outstanding in the URC and still find Test rugby a completely different proposition. Young players can dominate a franchise match, make a few big plays and suddenly have everyone asking whether Dr Rassie should be taking notice, and yes, he should.

READ | Rassie sizes up 'improved' Wallabies as a real 2027 World Cup threat

That's the whole point of the pathway, but the jump from franchise rugby to Test rugby is enormous and perhaps that is what Perth reminded us of. The depth is there. The talent is there. The conveyor belt is clearly still moving. But is the depth ready? That’s the question. Because the weekend gave us two very different messages. The URC told us that South African rugby has plenty of players capable of stepping up, making an impact and helping our franchises compete.

Perth and the Wallabies reminded us that Test rugby is a different beast altogether. One thing is for sure, this coaching group will know better than most that depth and Test-level quality are not necessarily the same thing, and perhaps that's the real lesson from a weekend that started with a clean sweep...and ended with a bitter taste.

Courtney Jameson and Chris Nkomo run the @dummyswitchpod. and are part of KickOff's Bomb Squad and Tap 'n Go team. Be sure to follow them on X.

Related tags

Bomb Squad Bulls Lions Sharks Springboks Stormers URC Wallabies