from the but-that's-not-fair! dept
Can You Regulate ‘Fairness’? The EU’s Digital Fairness Act Is Going To Try
by Mike Masnick · TechdirtLast week the EU presented its long-awaited “Digital Fairness Act” proposal, an attempt to expand its consumer protection laws to deal with what it believes are shady practices online. Now, you might be thinking that the EU already has a ton of internet laws — the GDPR, the ePrivacy Directive, the DSA, the DMA, the AI Act, and more — with somewhat mixed results. And you’d be right. But that’s not going to slow down the EU.
Dealing with scammy practices online is a laudable goal, but there are a lot of ways that could go wrong, especially if the end result is just giving more control to the biggest companies to “get things right” rather than letting users themselves control their own data and experiences online.
As with many EU proposals, there’s a lot in this proposal that will likely get support, because it targets a bunch of things that people claim to hate. And, some of what the Commission lays out actually looks good:
• A ban on manipulative marketing tactics (so-called “dark patterns”) such as fake claims that a product is almost sold out that pressure consumers into purchasing decisions they might not otherwise make.
• Clear and transparent pricing, particularly prices of purchases made with virtual in-app currencies and when dynamic pricing is used for cultural and sports events. In virtual queues, companies will have to show the current price in real time and the highest possible price.
• Fairness by design, with the option for consumers to turn off addictive design features that encourage excessive or compulsive spending, such as persistent prompts. The proposal will also restrict unfair practices that encourage overspending, for example by banning gambling-like features for minors, such as pay-to-win and pay-to-progress.
• Clear disclosure of influencer marketing, requiring influencers to be transparent about commercial content and preventing the exploitation of the trust of minors in their audience.
• A restriction on unfair personalised ads and prices that target minors or take advantage of sensitive data.
• Digital contracts and subscriptions that are easier to cancel and an end to unwanted automatic renewals and free trials turning into subscription traps. Consumers will have the right to communicate with a human in customer service and will have clear rights when using an AI agent to buy products on their behalf.
The key aspect of the proposal — and this is the subject of a lot of debate on both sides — is that it won’t ban most of the so-called “addictive” features (though it does ban a specific list of so-called “dark patterns”) but would require companies to give consumers the option of turning those features off. To me, that’s better than an outright ban, which would create lots of issues, but others complain that this then puts the burden on the user. Of course, one person’s “burden on the user” is another’s “user empowerment,” so it depends a bit on through which prism you view all this. I’d rather put control in users’ hands than give companies more levers to pull.
Giving people the option to turn off these features actually seems like a mostly reasonable compromise. Many of the practices described above… absolutely suck. And being able to opt out of them seems good, though the devil is very much in the details. And some of the features being targeted can actually be useful in certain circumstances. I’ve talked about how the claims of “addictive design” are often quite overblown — mainly in confusing “addiction” and “habits.”
And that can become problematic, because in addition to bad habits, there can also be good habits — and there are even specialized tools out there designed to help you learn good habits, like getting regular exercise, or practicing mindfulness, or getting a good night’s sleep. Just as an example, Wired notes that a language-learning service like Duolingo or an exercise app like Strava might both be negatively impacted by the law. Both apps rely on features (like Duolingo’s infamous streaks) that nudge you to keep up with your language-learning and exercise habits. And, generally speaking, most people consider that a good thing. If it remains optional to turn these features off, then I guess that’s fine, though it still feels out of place in apps literally designed to try to get you to establish a habit (not an “addiction.”) At the very least, it will require they spend a bunch of engineering time to build a tool to turn off the main reason why people use those apps.
But also, what starts as an “option” to turn off can quickly become required under the law. Indeed, some of the complaints about the proposal that we’re seeing are that many wish there were outright bans, rather than the option to turn off. Of course, in that same article, others are complaining that the existing rules are already too much of a regulatory burden, so you can see there will be efforts to pull the proposal in both directions as the negotiations between the European Parliament and the Council heat up over the final rules.
The group EDRi, who does amazingly good consumer digital rights work in the EU, is largely supportive of the EU’s push to stop anti-consumer tricks online, but warns that the way the law is written might just create a repeat of the “cookie banner” nonsense, which was written to deal with a legitimate concern (people giving up privacy without realizing what they were doing) but when it came to implementation, resulted in just… annoying everyone and doing little to actually protect privacy.
As EDRi’s Itxaso Domínguez de Olazábal points out, the end result of that fiasco was to generally turn the public against efforts to actually protect privacy, and there’s some fear that the same could happen here:
There is also a too familiar political risk: we’ve spent years watching companies turn cookie consent from a perfectly valid legal and protective basis into an obstacle course, only for the resulting frustration to become an argument against EU privacy and data protection regulation.
Now imagine another set of inconvenient controls, confusing settings and repeated choices: people will inevitably become frustrated, industry will complain about Brussels ruining the user experience, and eventually someone will suggest weakening the rules (they will call it ‘simplification,’ though). I’d rather we didn’t repeat that exercise.
There are also bits in the proposal targeting video game “loot boxes” and “pay-to-win” features, which… definitely feel more scammy. The proposal seeks to ban them in games targeted at children and provide much more clear transparency about what’s going on for adult gamers. Of course, the video game industry is already out complaining about these rules, but given how much of the world has been taken over by subtle attempts to make people gamble away everything they have… I’m not as convinced that rules on those kinds of things are as problematic as the industry makes them out to be.
It also looks like the proposal did not take up the request to include the “stop killing games” proposal as a part of the DFA, though that may also be subject to change during the negotiation.
In the end, I have a mixed opinion on much of this. I agree with most people that the scammy tactics some companies use really suck and make everyone’s life worse. But I’m skeptical you can legislate “fairness” broadly in a way that won’t backfire long term (see: cookie banners) or that takes into account all the edge cases. I’d prefer they target specific, proven, malicious behavior rather than writing sweeping rules.
Part of the problem is that politicians can’t seem to think of the internet as anything more than Facebook, Instagram, X, and TikTok. To them, everything is social media, so anything that keeps you engaged must be “bad” and “addictive.” They legislate with that in mind, and when other services (Duolingo, Strava, etc.) push back, the fix is to make the rules “opt-out” rather than an outright ban. But that still puts compliance costs on those services, and it could also lead to some services never being built at all.
A better solution, as always, is for people to have more overall control over their digital experiences, and I worry that laws like this could actually make that harder, because the compliance costs that giants can easily absorb can price out the smaller companies that are often the ones giving users more control in the first place. Small companies are already pointing out that this could really harm them, noting that the compliance costs are large, but they’re generally not the ones doing really scammy tactics in the first place. So to them, this would make them bear the cost, without much benefit to their users.
Yes, giving users the option to turn off certain features would be a step towards more user control, which I appreciate, but the broadness of the law and the mandate makes me worry about how it will be gamed by the largest players, and prove too costly for the smaller ones.
Indeed, we keep seeing big companies (and their lobbyists) shape these rules to benefit themselves long term, while leaving smaller competitors unable to comply.
That is to say that I appreciate the underlying goals of this regulation, and agree that the state of the internet today often sucks. But that doesn’t mean that this regulation will actually make things any better — and there’s a decent enough chance it could make things worse.