When Did We Become So Comfortable Playing Armchair Psychologist And Diagnosing Everyone From Strangers On TikTok To People Around Us?

by · BuzzFeed

Over the past few years, we've become much more open about discussing mental health and neurodivergence – and that's undoubtedly a great thing. Social media has played a huge part in making psychological terminology more understandable and helping people recognise experiences they might previously have struggled to put into words.

But as our knowledge has grown, so has our willingness to apply what we've learned to the people around us. A quick scroll through TikTok will show just how comfortable we've become with suggesting that strangers might have a particular mental health condition or be neurodivergent. From analysing celebrities' behaviour to picking apart the actions of people we've never met, the comment sections are often full of armchair diagnoses.

And it's seemingly not just happening online.

Nicoletaionescu / Getty Images

Whether it's telling a friend their newfound passion for a hobby is "giving autism" or suggesting a friend has ADHD because they showed up to Friday night drinks late for two consecutive weeks, we're increasingly becoming way too comfortable putting labels on other people. 

While some might take these comments with a pinch of salt or find them helpful, they might not land quite so well with someone you barely know, or someone who hasn't invited that kind of conversation.

Dr Lucy Viney, clinical psychologist and co-founder of the Fitzrovia Psychology Clinic, believes several things have contributed to this shift. She points to a "genuinely positive cultural movement towards openness around mental health and neurodivergence", which has reduced stigma and encouraged people to talk more freely.

At the same time, she explains that social media has given people access to "psychological language and frameworks that were once largely confined to clinical settings". When something resonates with our own experiences, or those of someone we know, sharing that observation can feel like a natural and even caring thing to do.

"The intention behind these conversations is usually kindness," Dr Viney shares. "The difficulty is that familiarity with a concept is not the same as clinical understanding of it."

So, while being able to talk openly about mental health, triggers, and recognising neurodivergent traits is something worth celebrating, where do we draw the line between showing an interest in someone's wellbeing and making assumptions? Dr Viney has some thoughts.

Dr L Viney/Fitzrovia Psychology Clinic

Can putting a label on someone actually do more harm than good?

Yes, it can, and I think this is the part that often gets missed in these conversations. When someone is told by a friend or sees a comment online suggesting they might have a particular condition, it can set in motion a process of self-understanding that may or may not be accurate. 

For some people, that framing becomes fixed before they have ever spoken to a professional. It can lead to unnecessary anxiety, or conversely, to someone explaining away difficulties using a label rather than exploring what is actually driving them. There is also a real risk that people feel reduced to a category rather than understood as a whole person.

When does pointing out someone's behaviour cross the line into diagnosing them?

Signposting is very different from diagnosing. Saying to a friend, "I notice you seem to really struggle with transitions and I wonder if it might be worth speaking to someone about that" is very different from saying "I think you have ADHD." One opens a door, the other closes one. 

A professional assessment takes time, involves multiple sources of information, considers the full context of a person's life and history, and importantly, rules out other explanations. Condensing that process into a social media comment or a casual conversation does not replicate it, however well-read the person offering that view might be.

Puhimec / Getty Images

Has social media contributed to our growing comfort with diagnosing other people?

Almost certainly, yes. 

This is sometimes called "concept creep," where clinical terms expand to cover a broader and broader range of human experience. 

When someone posts a relatable video about losing their keys or feeling overwhelmed before a social event and tags it with a diagnostic label, it creates the impression that these universal human experiences are symptoms requiring a diagnosis. That is not always helpful. It can pathologise normal variation in human behaviour and, at the same time, risk trivialising the very real difficulties experienced by people with significant clinical need.

How can we talk more openly without labelling people or making assumptions about their experiences?

I think the most important shift is moving from labels to descriptions of experience.

Asking someone how they are feeling, what they find hard, and what they notice about themselves is far more connecting and respectful than arriving with a conclusion. 

Language like "I have noticed you seem to find certain situations really draining; how are you doing with that?" is gentler and more curious than offering a diagnosis. It also leaves space for the other person to define their own experience rather than having it defined for them. We can hold space for someone's struggles without needing to name and categorise them.

Lorenzoantonucci / Getty Images/iStockphoto

If you recognise traits or triggers in yourself, what would you advise as the next step?

I would encourage them to start by keeping a record of what they notice, when it happens, and how it affects their daily life. The more specific and concrete they can be, the more useful that information will be in any assessment. 

I would also say: approach it with curiosity rather than certainty. Going into an assessment with a fixed idea of what you want the outcome to be can sometimes get in the way of genuinely understanding what is happening. 

Shapecharge / Getty Images

A good assessment is not about confirming a label; it is about building a fuller picture of you as an individual. In the UK, a good starting point is often speaking with your GP, who can refer you to appropriate services, or seeking out a qualified clinical psychologist or psychiatrist privately if that is accessible.

Comments