Downstate Is a Harrowing Moral Wrestling Match
by Sara Holdren · VULTURESomething very strange happened at the start of the performance of Downstate that I attended. Bruce Norris’s play — which comes to Broadway by way of a 2018 premiere at Steppenwolf and a 2022 Off Broadway run that may or may not have inadvertently triggered the demise of theater criticism at the Washington Post — gives no early signs that it’s a comedy. Its premise is about as unfunny as you can get: It’s about a group home for men on the sex offenders registry, somewhere in the depressed suburbs south of Chicago. Its opening image is spare and tense: An old man in an electric wheelchair sits in a drab living room, facing a man and a woman who perch uncomfortably on mismatched chairs. The latter man, who’s gripping a piece of paper as if he’s about to recite a speech, tentatively starts to speak. “Take your time,” says the woman.
ad-position slots="mobile_article_body"
At this point, the audience around me burst out laughing. They did it again at another unassuming line soon after. It was too loud, too much, out of all proportion to the event — but it wasn’t necessarily their fault. This production of Downstate — directed by Joe Mantello and produced by Scott Rudin as part of his comeback maneuvering — has been marketed using controversy as bait. “How can you miss the play that will thoroughly piss off half of America?” trumpets the show’s website, quoting the Post’s Johnny Oleksinski, while Megyn Kelly and Sean Hannity make appearances in the Instagram campaign. It’s all geared to amp people up, to court the kind of laughter that’s more about desired outcome than about present, thoughtful reaction. So it goes, I suppose, when everything is a product to be sold, but it’s still a shame, because plays like Downstate deserve better. Yes, the show is sometimes, eventually, terribly (and terribly) funny. It’s also a harrowing examination of where we set the boundaries of our empathy.
ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic desktop_article_body mobile_leaderboard"
“More of a tragicomedy,” says one of its characters, a man called Dee, played by K. Todd Freeman in a masterfully calibrated performance. The production is, as a whole, a showcase for its actors, and as one of two who’ve been with the play in every iteration, Freeman inhabits Dee with the deceptive ease and astonishing fluidity of long acquaintance. He is mesmerizing to watch, especially as he himself watches. Of the four residents in the group home, Dee is the sharpest and subtlest; he’s also, for all his affected remove, the caretaker. He’s the one who gets groceries and who makes sure Fred (Francis Guinan, mild, unsettling, and remarkable, the other original cast member in the show) takes his pills and helps him in and out his wheelchair and the bath. He’s the one who wants things neat, bickering with the hyper, ingratiating Gio (Al’Jaleel McGhee), whose workout bench is clogging up the living room. (“Fred got his little piano sitting right there, don’t see nobody complainin’ ‘bout that,” mumbles Gio, to which Dee sniffs: “His piano is tasteful. Your shit is distasteful.”) Dee’s also the aesthete, a former actor with a carefully curated DVD collection who adores the film work of “Miss Diana Ross.” When he speaks of tragicomedy, he’s describing his favorite, Lady Sings the Blues.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body mobile_leaderboard"
And he is an ex-convict who served fifteen years for, in his own words, having “a sexual relationship with a 14-year-old boy when I was 37.” In light of that, do any of the other facts I just listed matter at all? That’s the wrestling match Norris’s play is engaged in — a straining, bruising one, unlikely ever to produce a clear winner.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
Which is what makes it such fertile ground for theater, a form that gains in potency the more insoluble the questions it takes on. Are Dee, Fred, Gio, and the group home’s fourth resident, the shy and desperate Felix (Adrian Martinez), monsters, or damaged humans, or victims who became victimizers, or citizens who still have rights — or some morally overwhelming, legally confounding combination of all of the above and more? “Evil exists in the world,” says Andy (Thomas Sadoski), the man who at the start of the play has come with his wife, Em (Cassie Beck), to see Fred. Reading from that sheet of paper, his hands shaking, he takes a breath and goes on: “And for me, at this moment, one part of that acceptance is to look you in the eye today, and tell you to your face that you are a fundamentally evil person.”
ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
As a child, Andy was Fred’s piano student and then his victim. In one of Downstate’s gradually tightening, intertwining threads, he has come back to face his abuser and demand that Fred sign a “reconciliation contract.” “I want the truth. I want him to read that aloud, and admit what he did,” says Andy, his whole body vibrating with fury. “He already admitted it in a court of law…” replies Dee. “He’s already been punished.”
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
It would surely be possible to charge Norris with tipping the sympathies of his play too far in favor of the men whom we are accustomed to categorizing, immediately and confidently, as unforgivable. Andy has a fancy car and a fancy phone; he works in finance in the city while Fred lives off his EBT card and will never walk again after having his back broken in prison. Andy speaks the language of righteous progressivism (the look on Dee’s face when he uses the phrase “people of color”), and his wife is promptly insufferable — she doesn’t actually seem to have enough compassion even for him, let alone for, on some theoretical plane, men like the one who hurt him. If Norris goes too far in any particular direction, it’s that he can’t quite resist taking a few extra bites out of these nice, well-off liberals, this therapy-speak-spouting money manager who has, in Dee’s words, come downstate so that he “can tell some poor old white man sitting in a wheelchair living offa food stamps… all the pain I feel cuzza all the little psychological problems in my life.” Downstate has raised some hackles for extending the circle of its humanization to Dee, Fred, Gio, and Felix — but that is its fundamental intention. The image on the cover of its Playbill is an old piece of carpet peeling up from the floor: The play exists to ask us to look at what we sweep under the rug. The more pertinent question, when it comes to its deployment of empathy, is why it seems so inclined to chip away at our store when it comes to Andy.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
It may simply be that Norris wants to undermine what’s automatic in his audience, though I think it goes a little further. It’s Sadoski’s incredible performance — fixated, clenched, and vulnerable — that keeps the character from slipping over the line into flattening, point-making territory, but that line is there, lurking. (It’s also present, far more comically, in the character of Effie, Gio’s fellow Staples employee played by Ivy Wolk, who wields her Labubu-cased phone as recklessly as she does phrases like “safe space” and protestations that she is “legally entitled to possess 2.75 liquid ounces” of weed oil for her “own personal use.”) Andy as written is consumed by rage and has neatly assigned it all to one source in his life. As a playwright, Norris honors the rage but not the sense of neatness or righteousness around it. In one of the show’s most devastating moments, Dee, his defenses finally down, admits to Fred, “I’m filled with so much anger and hatred and it gets the better of me sometimes.” Truly, any character in Downstate, or any of us, might say as much — especially Andy, but Andy is still convinced that he can dig everything hateful and angry out of his soul by punishing one particular person.
ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
“Everybody’s misunderstood, been done wrong, system’s broke, system ain’t fair blah blah…” says the group’s probation officer, Ivy, expertly embodied by Liza Colón-Zayas, a juggler of dynamism and nuance who never drops a ball. “That may or may not be the case,” she goes on, “but I’ll tell ya something. If y’all feel so victimized? Maybe that gives ya a little idea how ya made other people feel, okay?” There’s the hot coal in the center of the ashes. Is there a point at which our human feeling toward our fellow humans should cease? A point when a person has lost the right to any form of care? How can such a thing ever be agreed upon or justly codified? What would real justice look like, beyond the institutionalized shambles that passes for it now? What about forgiveness? Downstate forces us to stand at the shore of our own reservoir of mercy, to consider how deep it really goes.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
Downstate is at the Booth Theatre.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"