The Altruists Recap: Accurate Models of Reality
by Ben Rosenstock · VULTUREThe Altruists
Words With Friends
Season 1 Episode 3
Editor’s Rating ★★★
Previous Next
Previous Episode
Next Episode
Up until this point, individual episodes of The Altruists have only made a minor effort to set themselves apart in the larger structure of the series, mostly content to stick with its established structure: two ongoing stories set a few years apart, each proceeding chronologically and covering two different eras in the lives of Sam Bankman-Fried and Caroline Ellison. As in many a bingeable Netflix series, each installment ends with a natural lead-in to the next, and they quickly start to bleed together. Each one features motifs and phrases that get repeated ad nauseam, like “mathematically optimal” in the first, but there’s rarely just one character or dynamic at the center outside Sam and Caroline.
ad-position slots="mobile_article_body"
But “Words With Friends” is the Nishad Singh episode, that’s clear — and while I don’t think it’s a big leap in quality from the previous two, it’s more memorable for that relatively consistent focus. That’s not to say it’s just a Nishad episode; there’s a lot to cover here, and there are significant milestones in both of the major story lines. After all, this is the beginning of FTX. But it filters those two narrative strands through his perspective, filling in details to make a near-background figure into a legitimate supporting character on this show. About time!
ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic desktop_article_body mobile_leaderboard"
In this case, I understand the value of beginning in the 2022 timeline: Nishad finding out about his friend’s betrayal early in the episode gives the flashbacks a certain bittersweetness. Then again, wouldn’t the betrayal have landed harder if it came later in the series, after several episodes of seeing Sam and Nishad work together? But alas. We see Nishad come into the FTX fold in 2018 after learning that his old childhood friend is moving to Hong Kong with his ex-girlfriend and Gary to build a user-friendly crypto exchange that donates its profits to EA charities — and that doesn’t require a license like it would in the U.S.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body mobile_leaderboard"
Well, more accurately, Nishad gets involved once he knows Claire, his co-worker at Facebook, will also move to Hong Kong with him. Yep, Nishad was apparently crushing on Claire even back then, when she was with the same boyfriend, and he actively encouraged her to move across the world to put distance between her and that unseen dick-pic sender. Nishad may be more sympathetic than the other higher-ups at FTX, but he’s got some creepy and/or manipulative tendencies as well. How can he claim that he and Claire are being fully honest with each other and building “accurate models of reality”?
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
We’ll pick back up with Nishad throughout the 2022 segment, but from here the episode pivots more generally to the early ups and downs at FTX. The next step for Sam and Caroline is to get some finance pros onboard, which means hiring Trabucco and, at Caroline’s insistence, some new people who aren’t friends of Sam. That includes Ryan Salame (who knows a lot about the crypto landscape in Asia) and Constance Wang (who’s … very driven?). After a few episodes of setup, the inner circle is firmly established now.
ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
With arbitrage profits starting to dry up and every single non-Nishad coder ditching FTX for competitor Binance in Malta, securing VC investments is a priority. Yet none of Sam’s meetings are going well. That’s not a huge surprise considering what he’s asking for and his general lack of charisma, but there’s a deeper reason, as it turns out: Binance CEO and rumored money launderer Changpeng Zhao (Terry Chen, hammy but entertaining to watch) felt threatened by FTX’s growth, so he hired its coders and offered a lot of money to the VCs whom Sam was pitching. He reveals this after tricking Sam and Caroline into showing up to a fake crypto soirée, where he politely asks them to shut down FTX.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
The story gets a bit sidetracked by a dramatic alleyway kiss between Sam and Caroline following his panic attack. He even apologizes for being a dick, something I’m curious about — did the real SBF ever show regret or treat Caroline with this level of vulnerability, gratitude, and humility? She does him a big favor by suggesting that CZ invest in FTX instead of destroying it; together, the two exchanges can team up against BitMEX instead of fighting each other. And CZ immediately accepts the idea, announcing his $100 million investment. One gets the sense that this is a simplification of what actually went down with CZ, but it works fine enough narratively.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
The 2022 scenes this time are bookended by scenes at the San Francisco Bloomberg office, where Hannah is making a case to report on the hidden relationship between FTX and Alameda. She manages to convince her editor by showing her firsthand how bad Sam is at lying: His whole façade crumbles entirely when Hannah simply asks him whether he lives with his friends in that penthouse in the Bahamas, and he can’t stop stumbling over his words in the scramble to provide an explanation. Credit to Boyle for making his stammering meltdown feel real.
ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
The planned publication of that story is the cliffhanger to end the episode, taking us one step closer to the downfall of FTX. But the rest of the 2022 scenes maintain the Nishad framing. Early on, he hears about Claire’s breakup and finally makes a clumsy move, which gets reciprocated later that night when she reveals she has apparently had a crush on him for a while. It plays out like wish fulfillment, but at least he gets a win. Those will be in short supply soon. After all, less than a day passes in TV time before Rishad is stumbling upon the missing $8 billion (or “the discrepancy,” to use Sam and Caroline’s euphemism), prompted by questions from an off-screen colleague at Voyager named Vanessa.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
Caroline reassures Sam that he was right to hide this from Nishad, but no simple apology can convince Nishad that his friend was doing anything to really protect him. This isn’t a gray area, as Sam insists; it’s pure folly and selfishness, and ordering him to remain quiet about it is a big ask. Bringing a counselor into the workplace to “improve trust” by making everyone sing their favorite song, then, is just an insult at this point. (William Mapother is excellent in the role, though. Lost has trained me to view him as a psychopath, which only adds to his smiley corporate image.)
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
Nishad doesn’t want anything to do with Sam anymore, but he decides to stick around at FTX to work hard and fill the $8 billion hole, which will save the customers and everyone abetting this massive criminal conspiracy. In a way, it all ties back to his love for Claire, because of course it does; The Altruists is all about romantic love. Nishad is determined to keep her out of this mess, and that means coldly shutting down their relationship before it can even really begin, a familiar contrivance in many a romance. I wish Claire pushed back harder, though, because it’s so out of character for him to suddenly have a completely different demeanor and reduce their bond to the one time they “fucked.”
ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
“You’re not complicated. People think you are,” Nishad tells Sam. It’s a cutting line in the moment, reducing Sam to his insatiable need for approval and his inability to ever really gain it. But maybe it’s also a telling statement about the real-life man and the people who seek to justify his actions. After all, according to Kevin T. Dugan’s reporting for New York, prosecutors said that SBF “had six chances from 2021 to 2022 to make things right and give back the money. Each time, he went deeper into the fraud.” This is hardly a complicated man making morally complex decisions, even if there was a point when his EA principles were genuine (itself an open question); he’s a liar and a thief who acted selfishly and irresponsibly and can’t acknowledge he intentionally did anything wrong, even today. The Altruists may have a tendency to extend Sam a little too much empathy, but on this point the show is clear, and that’s a relief.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
Mislabeled Files
• Look, I’m not sure whether Matt Rife is giving a good performance in this or if he’s just better than I expected him to be, but I’m enjoying him. There’s this moment I keep replaying when he’s teasing Nishad about Claire, and he sticks his whole beer bottle in his mouth.
ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic"
• “Nishad wanted me to ask if you wanted him to bring your PS4 out here?”
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
• Staff psychologist George Lerner also shows up in the earlier timeline, serving as a counselor for both Sam (who vents about his panic attacks and fear of failure) and Caroline (who vents about transitioning to a friendship with Sam and her difficulty with sitting in her feelings). Sam even admits he was always jealous of how his parents look at Nishad, the “normal” son they never had.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body mobile_leaderboard"
• Sam and Caroline have a very corny “wow, you look amazing” exchange when she comes down the stairs in her dress for the alleged crypto soirée.
ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
• I know this was 2018, but I never need to hear the word “lituation” again.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"
• SBF did film a MasterClass that never got released, apparently.
ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"