Court approves 900-lot Hunter estate after developer's appeal over refused DA

by · Newcastle Herald

A 900-lot Hunter housing estate that was refused by the region's planning panel last year has been approved by the Land and Environment Court.

The court granted consent on October 27 for the master plan and first stage of Third.i's Anambah project at 559 Anambah Road. Images: supplied

The court's decision comes after developer Third.i and Maitland City Council reached a deal during court-led talks.

The court granted consent on October 27 for the master plan and first stage of Third.i's Anambah project at 559 Anambah Road, in the Anambah Urban Release Area north of Rutherford and Windella.

The approval ends a fight that has run for more than two years and had, at points, turned bitter.

Third.i bought the site in 2023 and lodged its development application in 2024.

The land was rezoned from rural to residential in 2020 and had been earmarked for urban development for years, but the developer said at the time that very little had been done to unlock it.

The proposal promised 900 lots, parks and open space, and privately funded roads, utilities and drainage.

Third.i also promised affordable housing for essential workers such as nurses, police officers and teachers, equal to 5 per cent of the development.

Maitland council put the plans on public exhibition twice, in October 2024 and June 2025, and received 60 submissions.

In August 2025, the Hunter and Central Coast Regional Planning Panel refused the application.

The council said the panel gave 20 reasons, including breaches of planning controls, unresolved traffic and flooding problems, biodiversity and safety concerns, not enough infrastructure, and a finding the project was "premature, out of sequence and not in the public interest".

Third.i responded. It asked the panel to review its decision and said the council had opposed the project "every step of the way".

Head of acquisitions Florian Caillon said last November the company had "lost faith in the system" and was weighing court action.

He said holding costs were "through the roof".

Third.i had hoped to start work in 2025 and have the first residents in by 2027.

Third.i took the matter to the Land and Environment Court, which arranged closed-door talks between the two sides, led by Commissioner Shona Porter, on October 16.

The two sides reached an agreement and the court made it official on October 27.

Under court rules, when both sides agree, the court only has to check that it has the legal power to approve the plans.

It does not weigh up the pros and cons of the project.

Ms Porter said she did not make any judgement on the issues that had originally been in dispute.

Third.i's plans were changed during the process, with revised designs and updated reports on flooding, traffic, bushfire risk and biodiversity.

The council signed off on the changes before the deal went to the court.

Third.i must also pay some of the council's legal costs, the "costs thrown away", in an amount to be agreed or set by the court.

"We're pleased that after a long period, we've worked with Council and also the Land and Environment Court to reach this successful outcome," Third.i partner head of acquisitions Florian Caillon said.

"We also thank the Hunter and Central Coast Regional Planning Panel, whose assessment and decision clearly acknowledged the need for new housing for the Region.

"We're excited that we're now able to progress the Project and secure much-needed housing for the people of the Hunter.

"We look forward to commencing works at Anambah within six-months."

Mr Caillon said Anambah was part of Third.i's wider Greenfield development pipeline across NSW, including Charmhaven on the Central Coast and Stream Hill in the Illawarra.

The approved master plan covers up to 900 lots, including up to 90 small lots, three parks, creek corridors and vegetation buffers, stormwater basins, roads, walking and cycling paths, and space for bus routes.

The first stage is about 220 lots, built in five steps.

It includes a new intersection at Anambah Road, upgrades to Anambah Road and River Road, a separate access road along River Road, a local park, earthworks and street trees.

Stages two to five will each need their own approval.

The consent doesn't allow building beyond the first stage, and doesn't lock in the final number of lots or the mix of land uses.