A Jupiter-Sized Planet Has Disappeared, and an Invisible Neighbor May Be to Blame
An unseen giant planet may explain an extraordinary cosmic disappearance. But it raises another mystery.
by Tudor Tarita · ZME ScienceHow does one lose a Jupiter-sized planet?
In 2019, astronomers spotted a giant planet passing in front of a distant star. Every eight days or so, it blotted out a sliver of starlight. But then something strange began happening. The crossings grew shorter. The shadow weakened. And by March 2026, it had vanished.
A planet roughly the size of Jupiter had disappeared from astronomers’ view in just seven years.
Of course, the planet itself hasn’t disappeared. But something tilted its orbit just enough to make its crossings invisible from Earth.
And the prime suspect is another planet nobody has ever seen.
Tilting Out of Sight
TOI-2535 b lies roughly 1,100 light-years away and circles a star slightly smaller than our Sun. It takes just 8.24 days to complete an orbit, making it a “hot Jupiter,” a gas giant roasting close to its star.
NASA’s Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite, or TESS, first spotted evidence of it in 2019. The telescope searches for tiny dips in stars’ brightness as planets pass in front of them, much as a moth briefly dims a lamp.
But the timing of those crossings offered the first clue that something was amiss—either 6 hours late or 6 hour early. Another massive body appeared to be interfering with its motion.
×
Get smarter every day...
Stay ahead with ZME Science and subscribe.
Daily Newsletter
The science you need to know, every weekday.
Weekly Newsletter
A week in science, all in one place. Sends every Sunday.
No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime. Review our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! One more thing...
Please check your inbox and confirm your subscription.
Meanwhile, each transit became shorter and shallower, suggesting that the planet was crossing progressively closer to the edge of its star. By 2026, even careful searches found no detectable crossing.
“The planet’s orbit is tilting so quickly that its transit disappeared while we were watching,” Samuel Yee, the study’s lead author and an astrophysicist at UCLA, said in a statement.
The explanation involves a subtle change of perspective. An orbit need only move slightly out of alignment with Earth for its planet to stop passing in front of its star from our viewpoint. The world continues circling; we simply lose its shadow.
It’s a bit like watching a race car circle a track from the grandstands. Shift your viewing angle slightly, and the car might disappear behind a wall on every lap. The car is still racing. You just can’t see it anymore.
The Invisible Culprit
The researchers tested 300,000 possible planetary arrangements against the observations. They then tracked 100 promising configurations for a million years (in the simulation). About two-thirds eventually became unstable, with planets approaching one another dangerously close.
The more durable arrangements point to a companion at least as massive as Saturn, orbiting near TOI-2535 b. The models also suggest that the planets’ orbital planes are tilted by at least 5° relative to each other. Their mutual gravity makes those planes slowly wobble like spinning tops.
For comparison, most planets in our solar system orbit in nearly the same plane, with Mercury a notable exception having a 7° tilt relative to the ecliptic.
And here’s where things get even more interesting. The stable arrangements all shared another feature: orbital resonance.
In these configurations, the planets’ orbital periods follow simple numerical relationships, such as 2:1 or 3:2. That means one planet might complete two orbits for every three made by its neighbor. The resulting gravitational rhythm can help prevent dangerously close encounters, keeping the system stable despite the planets’ unusually tilted orbits.
But even with these clues, astronomers can’t reconstruct the system with certainty It’s too far to observe it directly and the data cannot determine exactly where it orbits. Even the possibility of a third planet remains open.
More precise measurements of how the star moves under its planets’ gravitational pull could help settle the question.
How Did This System Get So Twisted?
The bigger mystery is how two giant planets ended up in such an unusual arrangement. The answer might have something to do with the planet itself.
RelatedPosts
Astronomers Discover 128 New Moons Around Saturn Securing Its Title as the Moon King and Leaving Jupiter in the Dust
Neptune’s Great Dark Spot is also shrinking
Exoplanets could have better conditions for life than Earth, study finds
This Stinky Molten World Is Rewriting the Planetary Rulebook
Hot Jupiters probably form farther from their stars before moving inward. Having another giant planet nearby suggests TOI-2535 b migrated inward through a gas disk rather than arriving after a violent gravitational encounter. Such a journey could also explain why the planets ended up in resonance: when two planets migrate inward through a disk of gas, they can become trapped in orbital resonance if one moves inward faster than the other.
“They likely migrated in through the protoplanetary disk,” Yee told ScienceAlert. “However, how their inclinations got excited remains an open question.”
There’s just one problem. Gas disks tend to keep planetary orbits neatly aligned, not tilted at unusual angles. Something must have disturbed this system, either during its formation or afterward.
One possibility is that the planets passed through an orbital resonance that amplified their inclinations. Another involves changes in the young star or the disk of gas surrounding it. For now, the researchers can’t say which, if any, of these scenarios occurred.
Astronomers have witnessed the reverse trick before: a planet in the TOI-4504 system began transiting after its changing orbit brought it into view. TOI-2535 b is the first confirmed case caught going the other way around as its changing orbital orientation carried its transits out of view.
It may not stay hidden forever. Researchers expect its transits to return in roughly 30 to 50 years. Its invisible companion might reveal itself even sooner.
For now, astronomers have a vanished planet, a suspected invisible culprit, and a cosmic mystery that may take decades to fully unravel.
The study was published in The Astrophysical Journal Letters.