Yorgen Fenech seeks Chief Justice’s recusal in Caruana Galizia appeal
Lawyers argue that the chief justice took a stand and expressed himself on issues central to Fenech's defence in a judgment of the Constitutional Court
by AFP · Times of MaltaYorgen Fenech has asked Chief Justice Mark Chetcuti to abstain from hearing the appeal regarding the acquittal judgment in the murder of journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia.
Fenech was acquitted on September 2 following a 55-day trial by jury. The jury cleared him by an 8–1 vote on two charges relating to the October 16, 2017 car bomb assassination of investigative journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia. He had been accused of complicity in wilful homicide and criminal association.
Appearing before the chief justice and judges Doreen Clarke and Josette Demicoli, Fenech's lawyers argued that Chief Justice Chetcuti had already taken a stand and expressed himself on issues that were central to Fenech's defence in a previous judgment of the Constitutional Court.
The chief justice had already ruled on the credibility of the police investigation and of the prosecution's witnesses, particularly Assistant Commissioner Keith Arnaud.
In the Constitutional judgement, the court presided over by the chief justice alongside judges Giannino Caruana Demajo and Anthony Ellul had concluded that Arnaud was a credible witness and that there was no lack of impartiality in the investigation.
The lawyers also argued that in the judgement, the court had justified the police's decision not to initially consider Keith Schembri as a suspect, whereas Fenech's defence maintains that Schembri was given preferential treatment, and that important evidence was lost from his office at Castille.
The defence also argued that Arnaud had a private WhatsApp chat with Schembri on his personal mobile phone, for which cloning was not requested.
Lawyer Giannella de Marco said that during the search carried out at Keith Schembri’s home, Arnaud ordered scene-of-crime officers to seize only the electronic devices that Schembri himself pointed out during the search.
"In his testimony, Arnaud referred to Schembri as an old family friend," De Marco maintained.
The defence is invoking a European Convention on Human Rights judgment in Micallef vs Malta, which states that a judge must abstain when there are grounds that could give the impression of a lack of objective or subjective impartiality.
Prosecution objects
The prosecution objected to the defence's request and maintained that the basis of Fenech's argument is incorrect because the constitutional court judgment only deals with Keith Arnaud's involvement. Prosecutors also argued that the defence omitted important parts of the judgment.
Lawyer Godwin Cini on behalf of the Attorney General said that the defence forgot to mention in their application, that in the Constitutional Court judgment, the court stated that it shared what the First Hall had said regarding the shortcomings in the investigation.
Regarding the Micallef vs Malta judgment quoted by the defence, the prosecution said that "the fear of partiality must be objectively justified." It explained that in the Micallef vs Malta case, there were direct family ties (the judge was the uncle and brother of the opposing party's lawyer) which were sufficient "to create a legitimate doubt regarding impartiality."
It also stated that the law on the recusal of a member of the judiciary was different at the time of the Micallef vs Malta judgment.
"The fact that a member of the judiciary has made decisions or acquired knowledge of the evidence does not, in itself, mean that they are prejudiced," Cini continued to argue.
The prosecution also emphasised that although “a recusal is a right, it should not be used as a tool to choose the court or to prolong proceedings”, calling this “an abuse of the judicial process under the guise of a fear of alleged partiality”.
Present for the hearing of the application were Caruana Galizia's husband and sisters.
The prosecution is being led by lawyers Godwin Cini, Anthony Vella and Danica Vella on behalf of the Attorney General. Lawyers Giannella De Marco, Charles Mercieca and Gianluca Caruana Carrun represented Yorgen Fenech. Lawyers Therese Comodini Cachia and Jason Azzopardi appeared for the Caruana Galizia family.
Sign up to our free newsletters
Get the latest stories and updates from Times of Malta delivered straight to your inbox.