P

Red alert, Malta’s fertility rate needs a quick fix

As our fertility rate slips below one child per woman, a new Estonian study points to where the first, fastest gains could be found, writes Mark Pullicino

by · Times of Malta

Picture the ambulance. Blue lights flashing, siren wailing, and in the back not a single patient but an entire society. That is where Malta now sits.

The latest figures put our fertility rate at 0.98 children per woman in 2025, the lowest in the European Union, and roughly half what a population needs to replace itself. A decade ago, the figure was 1.38. At the turn of the millennium, it was 1.48.

These are not abstract decimals. They are emptier classrooms in 10 years’ time, a thinner workforce carrying a heavier pension bill, and a country less able to sustain itself from within.

In fairness, that last point needs tempering. On paper, Malta is not shrinking at all. Our population grew by nearly 21,000 in 2023 alone, to around 563,000.

This is the steepest rise in the EU in a decade and that growth is driven overwhelmingly by people coming here to live and work. Foreign workers are already filling the gaps in our hospitals, building sites, restaurants and care homes, and they will continue to do so.

But immigration treats the symptom, not the cause, and it comes with consequences. It adds pressure on housing, roads and public services. It raises real questions about integration and social cohesion. And it leaves the economy ever more dependent on importing its next generation of workers rather than raising it. Immigration can keep the ambulance moving; it cannot cure the patient.

If Malta were a company, the board would have called in a turnaround specialist long ago. So, let’s think like one.

Start where the wins are

Any good turnaround consultant walking into a struggling organisation does the same thing first: they pick the low hanging fruit. Not because the easy wins solve everything, but because an early success proves that change is possible and gives everyone the motivation to keep going.

In the long and complicated business of having children, the low hanging fruit is obvious. It is the couples who already have children and would like more, but keep postponing, because of the mortgage, the childcare bill, the career that cannot wait, or any of the hundred other pressures our “must have it now” culture places on young families. They have already said yes to parenthood. Nobody needs to change their minds; they only need help acting on them.

These families should be our national heroes. We should put them on a pedestal and treat them as gold.

What Estonia found

Last month, a study in the journal Demographic Research put hard numbers on what that could look like. Researchers at Tallinn University, Tanel Paas, Allan Puur and Mark Gortfelder, examined what happened after Estonia introduced a large, universal allowance for families with three or more children in July 2017. No means test, no strings attached. With it, total child benefits for a “three child family” reached around 41 per cent of the average salary.

The results were striking. Families with two children became more likely to have a third: the probability rose by four percentage points, from 37 to 41 per cent, an 11 per cent increase. And those third children arrived nearly a quarter sooner than before.

In other words, generous and predictable support did not merely persuade families to have their children earlier. It helped them have more of them.

‘Can we afford it?’ is the wrong question

The instinctive objection is cost. Forty-one per cent of an average salary sounds like a great deal for the taxpayer to hand out, year after year. But consider the size of the group: somewhere between 4,000 and 5,000 families a year. (The approximate annual births to local residents). Do the maths and the bill is far smaller than the headline percentage suggests – especially if it is funded by redirecting money from other family measures that have done little to bend the curve.

The better question is what it costs us not to act. Every year of delay is another cohort of children who were wanted but never born.

The 2026 Budget recognised the problem, with tax relief for parents and a stated push to get more families to at least two children. That is welcome. But Estonia’s experience suggests that the boldest, most measurable returns may lie one step further along, at the third child.

Brave measures for an emergency

None of this is a silver bullet. Birth rates are shaped by housing, working hours, childcare, gender equality and a dozen other forces, and reversing the trend will take sustained research and a far broader vision. Policymakers are already engaged in that work, and it deserves more urgency, research and more encouragement, not less.

But emergencies call for decisive, ‘out of the box’ action, not another round of consultations. Targeted, generous support for growing families is something we can design, cost and test now. It could give us what we badly need: an early win, and with it, hope.

The siren is sounding. It is time we answered it.

Mark Pullicino is a Maltese author and former international management consultant with a doctorate in social sciences and a keen interest in Malta’s demographic future.

Sign up to our free newsletters

Get the latest stories and updates from Times of Malta delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscribe