May Malimi still bears the scars of a hit-an-run. Photo: Chris Sant Fournier

Lassana Cisse murder: Why prosecutors split the trial of two prime suspects

Sources close to the prosecution and defence shed light on the legal tactics at play in this case

by · Times of Malta

Prosecutors and investigators were shocked by the verdict that acquitted Lorin Scicluna of the murder of Lassana Cisse but, they were convinced trying him and his co-accused separately was the right decision.

Sources close to the investigation and the attorney general’s (AG’s) office told Times of Malta that prosecutors felt the evidence against Scicluna was strong enough to make them confident they could secure a conviction.

That would have paved the way for a second, equally strong trial against his friend, Francesco Fenech, who is also charged with the 2019 murder.

Instead, the verdict left prosecutors stunned. Seven years after Cisse was shot dead on a quiet road in Ħal Far, the man they considered central to the case walked free of the murder charge.

The verdict drew heavy criticism of investigators, the AG’s office and the jury system itself. There were fresh calls to scrap or seriously reform the centuries-old system, amid calls for the AG to resign.

The verdict dealt a major blow because it came two months after the acquittal of Yorgen Fenech, who was cleared of any involvement in the murder of journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia.

Why split the cases?

Among the critics were those who believed that trying the two men separately was a fatal mistake. It meant two different juries could each acquit one man if they felt the evidence against him was not strong enough. These critics argue there is no doubt that one of the two men pulled the trigger on three black men that night. Had they been tried together, they said, a jury panel would have been forced to convict at least one of them.

A tactical decision

Sources close to the prosecution, however, noted the decision was tactical but also legal. Under Maltese law, two co-accused cannot testify against each other in the same trial and anything they said about one another would have been inadmissible. A co-accused may only testify once all proceedings against them have ended. Prosecutors, therefore, wanted Scicluna convicted first, so he could later take the stand against Fenech.

It is common for prosecutors to split proceedings in criminal cases when they feel it gives them a better chance of securing more convictions. And, in Scicluna’s case, they felt like his trial could have been a slam dunk.

“Investigators felt this was the strongest evidence they could possibly get in the circumstances,” one source said. “They proved the car was Scicluna’s, the gun was his and he was driving that night. To them, it was clear he was at the very least complicit in a murder planned by both men and that would have been enough to secure a guilty verdict.”

A shooting that shook the country 

Cisse, an Ivorian migrant, was shot dead on April 6, 2019, while walking home. Scicluna and Fenech, both soldiers at the time, were charged with his murder and with attempting to kill two other migrants: Mohammed Jallow from the Gambia and Ibrahim Bah from Guinea. Both pleaded not guilty.

The case sparked alarm as it quickly became clear the victims were shot simply because they were black. Days later, then prime minister Joseph Muscat had described the killing as racially motivated.

During the two-week trial in late October, Scicluna blamed his friend. He told the jury that Fenech opened fire without warning him.

The jury cleared him of murder by eight votes to one.

Lawyers divided

Times of Malta also spoke to sources close to Scicluna’s defence team and other lawyers with many years of criminal experience. Their views on the verdict were mixed.

Some were baffled that jurors could acquit given the evidence. Others argued the prosecutors failed to prove the most important point of all: who pulled the trigger.

“Prosecutors did not prove that Scicluna shot the migrants,” one criminal lawyer said. “They expected the jurors to take their word for it. Owning the car and the gun does not prove he fired, or even that he meant to hurt anyone.”

Another lawyer said that being with someone who commits a crime does not make a person complicit. Someone can spend time with a friend who seems harmless, only to be taken by surprise when that friend does something violent. That does not mean they planned it, or even knew about it.

“Don’t blame the jurors,” a third lawyer said. “They are told to decide only on the evidence put in front of them. The AG’s lawyers could not prove the one thing that mattered most, which is that Scicluna actually shot Lassana and the other migrants.”

But sources close to the prosecution reject that argument. They say such proof was not needed. “It doesn’t even matter who pulled the trigger because the crime couldn’t be committed without a collaboration between the two,” one source said. “Even if Scicluna did not pull the trigger, he clearly worked with his friend to create the right conditions for him to aim, shoot and hit three men.”

Cats and cartridges 

They pointed to what they described as strong evidence from Scicluna’s own testimony.

When he took the stand in his own trial, Scicluna told jurors the plan was never to shoot people, only cats. He collected his pistol from home and they drove around Ħal Far, down an alley known to be frequented by black people. Scicluna was driving the car and Fenech was in the passenger seat. He said they spotted a black man (Cisse) walking along the road on the driver’s side and that was when Fenech leaned across him and shot Cisse without warning.

Lassana Cisse was walking home when he was shot dead seven years ago. File photo

“Fenech lifted himself off his seat, held onto the door with one hand and extended his other arm outside,” Scicluna told court. “He stretched his arm right out. He leaned right across in front of my face.”

Scicluna said that when he realised his friend had shot a man, he sped off in panic. Moments later, to his shock and dismay, Fenech fired again at two more black pedestrians, Scicluna said.

Jurors may well have believed that Scicluna did not fire and acquitted him on that basis. But, even then, a source close to the prosecution said, he still helped Fenech.

“Scicluna told jurors he was driving and never stopped the car,” the source said. “But Cisse was shot three times and three cartridge cases were found very close to where he died.”

The source said that if the car had been moving, as Scicluna claimed, the cartridge cases would have been scattered along the road at intervals. Instead, they were all found within a “very small radius”.

“That means whoever fired was standing still, or almost still,” the source said. “Even if you believe Fenech fired, you have to believe Scicluna stopped, or, at least, slowed down, enough to make it easier for Fenech to aim and hit. That makes him complicit.”

A 'crime with a common design'

Prosecutors raised this point during the trial but the judge dismissed it as hypothetical. She said the jurors would assess that.

However, sources close to the prosecution insisted the evidence of Scicluna’s complicity and his own admissions during the investigation and in court were so clear that it did not matter who fired the gun.

“This was a crime with a common design,” one source said.

“The two men removed the car plates, left their phones behind and Scicluna loaded the weapon before going on scene. He could have kept the ammunition safely in his pocket but did not.

“Scicluna also let his friend get hold of the loaded gun, despite knowing, by his own account, that, two months earlier, the same friend had swerved the car at another black man on that same road to run him over.”

May Malimi still bears the scars of a hit-and-run. Photo: Chris Sant Fournier

The second shooting

Other sources pointed out one other thing. Scicluna said he sped off after Cisse was shot and was speeding more than before when they drove past the other two men.

“Any firearm expert knows it’s extremely hard to aim, fire four bullets and hit two people with two of the bullets, in the dark, from inside a vehicle that’s moving at high speed,” one source said.

“Now keep in mind, this was a semi-automatic weapon, which means whoever shot needed to pull the trigger with each shot, which makes it harder to aim each time.”

And not just that, a second source added. The cartridges at the second shooting were also not found at intervals, as they would have been found if the car was moving at high speed. They were also found within a relatively small radius.

“And both victims who were also shot that night and survived testified that they saw the car slow down before the shots were fired. One of them even said he saw the car stopping and reversing slightly.”

One prosecution source noted that Scicluna was also in full control of the situation. As the driver, he could have turned the car around when they found no cats to shoot. Instead, he kept driving down a road that both men knew was frequented by black people.

“On top of that, the car was in the perfect position for Fenech to aim, shoot and hit,” the source said. “The car was in such a good position that the shooter hit all three targets.”

The jury did not acquit Scicluna on every charge, however. It found him guilty of grievously injuring another person, May Malimi, whom he ran over two months before the shooting.

He was sentenced to eight years in prison for grievously injuring him.

Fenech is still awaiting trial.

Sign up to our free newsletters

Get the latest stories and updates from Times of Malta delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscribe