Citadel 2 review: Priyanka's show is smarter, slicker, slightly less exhausting

Citadel Season 2 returns with cleaner momentum, sharper self-awareness and a more controlled spy spectacle. It remains excessive and emotionally thin, but the series is finally entertaining on its own terms.

In Short

• Citadel Season 2 shows more restraint than Season 1
• The series embraces fast-paced action and organised chaos
• Priyanka Chopra Jonas delivers a more genuine performance

There is something intriguing about how Citadel functions like an expensive trust exercise. Each season appears as Prime Video stands before viewers and says, "No, no, this time we've fixed it," while pouring money into scenes of people running through glass buildings in tailored jackets. Strangely enough, Season 2 almost convinces you.

Not because the series, directed by Joe Russo, suddenly finds emotional depth or changes the spy genre. It does neither. This is still a world where everyone has parental trauma, everyone is double-crossing each other, and nobody stays dead long enough for grief to matter. But unlike the first season, which often felt like a computer program trying to create a blockbuster, this one finally grasps the value of restraint - relative restraint, anyway. This is still Prime Video's answer to an explosion in a luxury mall.

This time, the story largely revolves around Nadia Sinh and Mason Kane being pulled back into the collapsing machinery of Citadel while Manticore attempts to weaponise a technology capable of controlling minds and turning ordinary people into programmable assassins. Which, honestly, feels exactly like the kind of absurdly ambitious plot this franchise would come up with after spending millions on smoke machines and European skylines.

There are betrayals, family complications, shifting alliances, missing trust, and enough global hopping to make immigration officers nervous. The series wants personal trauma and geopolitical catastrophe to coexist in the same frame at all times, and somehow, it mostly keeps moving before you stop to question it too much.

The biggest improvement is that the show has stopped trying to convince viewers it is smarter than it really is. That arrogance weighed down Season 1, where every reveal felt like a dramatic moment, even when the audience had already anticipated it three episodes earlier. Season 2 is more self-aware. It knows that momentum is the real currency here.

So the series embraces speed. People are chased. Buildings collapse. Someone is emotionally tortured in one corner while someone else hacks into a satellite system in another. The camera moves as if it has consumed three energy drinks. Yet, for the first time, the chaos feels organised instead of stitched together in post-production panic.

What also helps is that the series finally realises that glamour alone can't drive an espionage drama. Beautiful people staring intensely at each other in dimly lit rooms only works for so long before viewers start asking basic questions like, "Why does everyone sound like they are delivering trailer dialogue?"

Priyanka Chopra Jonas (Nadia Sinh) benefits the most from this shift in tone. Season 1 often trapped her in a style that confused intensity with emotional connection. Here, she has moments that feel more genuine. She still carries herself like someone built to survive slow-motion explosions, but her performance breathes more this time. The series also wisely shares the responsibility for making the emotional stakes believable, rather than placing it all on her.

Meanwhile, Richard Madden (Mason Kane) continues to look like a man dealing with global espionage and severe sleep deprivation at once. His greatest contribution to Citadel remains his ability to seem emotionally damaged, even when standing completely still.

But the real standout is Stanley Tucci (Bernard Orlick). He steps into this expensive spy spectacle and acts as if he is in a much better show. Tucci understands something that Citadel sometimes forgets: deadpan seriousness becomes much funnier against a ridiculous backdrop. He delivers lines about catastrophic threats with the fatigue of someone trying to fix the office Wi-Fi, and it works beautifully.

The larger issue is the show's focus on scale over texture. The series wants to feel global, but it sometimes confuses geography with storytelling. Characters jump between countries so often that entire cities become like airport lounges with better cinematography. The ambition of world-building is clear, but emotional continuity often gets sacrificed for international visuals.

Yet here’s the frustrating part: it is entertaining. Not always coherent or emotionally justified. Definitely not subtle. But entertaining in the way glossy spy fiction can be when it fully embraces its excesses. Season 2 finally realises that viewers are not here for realism. They are here to see emotionally flawed, attractive people running through geopolitical chaos while orchestral music blares in the background.

The first season felt like it was made by a committee. This one feels directed. That difference is important.

Citadel still isn't prestige television, no matter how much it tries to dress like it. But Season 2 stops striving to be important and settles for being watchable, and that might be the smartest creative decision this franchise has made so far.

Citadel is currently streaming on Prime Video.

- Ends