I love Google's 7-year Pixel update promise, but there's one big problem

If anyone in my family asks me for an Android phone recommendation, I usually lean toward a Google Pixel or Samsung Galaxy smartphone.

Not only do phones from both brands offer polished experiences, but I also like that they're updated frequently, unlike phones from other Android brands, where you have to wait months for the latest software.

Starting with the Google Pixel 8 series in 2023, Google took that even further by promising seven years of OS updates for its Pixel phones. In theory, that sounds great.

But three years into that promise, I've started noticing one small problem with Google's seven-year update policy that we don't really talk about.

Related

4 reasons I won't upgrade my Google Pixel 8 to Pixel 10

The case for keeping your Pixel 8

Posts 28
By  Parth Shah

Google's 7-year Pixel promise sounds great on paper

Long-term Android and security updates are a huge win

Google is probably the only major Android phone maker right now that releases major OS updates for all of its supported devices at once.

Whenever Google releases a new version of Android, most recently Android 17, the update arrives across supported Pixel phones on the same day, which is something not even Samsung does.

On release day, you can open Settings and download the latest Android update. You don't have to wait for a staggered rollout based on your Pixel model, even if you're using a two- or three-year-old phone, as long as it's still supported.

In theory, that's pretty great. Barring Apple, Google is probably the only major smartphone maker that handles software updates this smoothly.

The problem, however, is that getting the latest version of Android doesn't necessarily mean getting all of its new features. Older Pixels may be technically up to date while still missing some of the biggest features Google is introducing with its newer phones.

Google keeps its best features exclusive to newer Pixels

Google regularly reserves its newest tricks for the latest hardware

Google isn't doing anything unusual here. Most smartphone manufacturers keep at least some new features exclusive to their latest devices. But it makes me question what seven years of OS updates actually means for a Pixel owner.

Sure, your three-year-old Pixel 8 can run Android 17. But does that mean it gets features like Rambler or Magic Capture that Google is advertising with the Pixel 11? Unfortunately, no. A lot of those headline features remain exclusive to newer Pixels.

We've seen Google do this before. When Google introduced Magic Editor with the Pixel 8 series, it was exclusive to those phones before becoming widely available. That's my problem with Google's update promise.

Technically, Google is doing exactly what it promised. Your Pixel gets the latest Android version and plenty of smaller improvements. But increasingly, the features that make a new Android or Pixel release exciting aren't necessarily part of that promise.

I know hardware limitations play a role here. And to Google's credit, the fine print around its update promise has always made it clear that feature availability depends on hardware capabilities.

Some features require newer processors, cameras, or on-device AI models that don't work properly on older hardware. But I don't think that explains everything.

Take Rambler on the Pixel 11 series. The feature uses cloud processing for its AI-powered voice typing, yet it's currently limited to the Pixel 11 lineup.

If a feature relies on Google's servers to handle a significant part of the work, it's harder to argue that a Pixel from a couple of years ago doesn't have the hardware to support it.

Google may bring Rambler to older Pixels. Based on what the company has done with previous Pixel-exclusive features, I wouldn't be surprised if it does. But that's the problem. We don't know.

Related

This phone is the only one I'd trust to last beyond 2030

Settle for the right phone, not the most expensive one

Posts 34
By  Jon Gilbert

7 years of updates doesn't mean 7 years of features

I'm not saying Google's seven-year update promise is bad. I'd much rather have a Pixel receiving the latest Android version and security patches six years from now than a phone that's abandoned after three or four.

I don't expect every Pixel 11 feature to work on a Pixel 8 either. Some features require newer hardware, and that's understandable.

But Google could be more transparent about which features are hardware-dependent, temporarily exclusive, or eventually coming to older Pixels.

Instead, a feature launches as an exclusive, you consider upgrading for it, and then months later, it suddenly appears on your older Pixel anyway. A little clarity from the start would go a long way.