Mamdani’s damning silence after killer Brooklyn building collapse speaks volumes

· New York Post

A day after a Brooklyn building collapse killed eight people, Mayor Zohran Mamdani vowed last week: “If there is anyone, or any entity, operating in this city that bears responsibility for what happened, we will hold them fully accountable.”

If?

Mr. Mayor, you are accountable.

Construction carnage is a systemic problem, because the system rewards corner-cutting.

Fix that.  

The mayor should have said: There are no construction accidents, only preventable negligence and recklessness. 

Last fiscal year, eight people died in construction catastrophes.  

Yes, the city made progress after 2008, a year when 25 people died, including in two crane crashes.

Deaths fell to an annual average of five between 2009 and 2014.

But they spiked into double digits during the first years of Bill de Blasio’s administration, and for the past five years, deaths have averaged seven annually.  

Most victims — not all — are construction workers, including two of last week’s dead.  

Most often, people die due to shoddy work.

A worker falls, because no supervisor checked that he was secured.

Heavy equipment crushes a worker, because no supervisor made sure that thing was strapped down.  

Preventable deaths have been tolerated — and that’s resulted in another mass-casualty disaster.

Though an investigation is pending, circumstantial evidence abounds that recklessness at a building site next door led to this collapse.  

Among the victims were two children, cousins Nicole Daniela Salvada Rodriguez, age 9, and Kevin Santiago Reyes Gonzalez, 10. 

How to stop these tragedies?  

First, the mayor must direct his Department of Buildings to understand who its customers are.  

No, the DOB doesn’t serve developers and contractors.  

The DOB’s customers were little Nicole and Kevin, who died in their home, as well as the six other victims.  

The department should display photos of those children, in their little Success Academy button-down uniforms, in its headquarters.  

That would remind its workforce to tell developers and contractors: Our job is to keep our customers safe from you. 

And the DOB should hold itself accountable by keeping a prominent dashboard of year-to-date deaths and injuries on its website.  

Second, the mayor must ask the City Council to increase fines on hazardous violations — such as the violation a contractor next to the collapsed building incurred in April.  

According to the DOB, the contractor, N Tech design, “unlawfully continued work while on notice of a stop-work order,” a violation considered “immediately hazardous.”

The contractor paid a $10,000 fine.  

Just the cost of doing business, it seems: The contractor apparently kept demolishing the existing building in violation of the stop-work order, speeding the work along.  

According to city data, the DOB found at least 247 violations of a stop-work order last year, carrying a $10,000 fine, and issued another 114 stop-work violations, carrying a $25,000 fine, that were even more serious.  

There is no excuse for continuing work under a stop-work order, and the fact that this happens daily shows that a five-figure fine is not enough.

The fine should be six figures — and should be raised until the scofflaws feel some pain.  

Third, the council should let the DOB experiment with citizen enforcement.

That’s worked well for the Department of Environmental Protection, which allows civilians to record violations of the anti-idling law, backed by time-stamped video evidence.  

This works well for yes-or-no questions: Either a truck or bus is idling, or it’s not.

Same for construction; either a contractor is working illegally before or after authorized hours, or it is not.

Either a contractor has lied on a permit, saying there’s no residence nearby when there is — a complaint easily verified by city data — or it hasn’t.  

Such a mechanism could free up DOB manpower for dangerous cases.

And it could end the cat-and-mouse game: One day a contractor illegally works late, but on the day the DOB comes to visit, the work site is mysteriously quiet.  

And a site that’s incurred a hazardous violation indicates a developer who doesn’t know what he’s doing in choosing contractors, or doesn’t care.

The DOB should conduct its own checks-and-balances scrutiny of all that site’s future permit applications, including applications from different contractors.  

Inattentive or corner-cutting developers should pay extra for this remedial oversight.  

Such a step might have stopped this collapse, had the DOB withheld a permit for construction until it had assured proper safeguards for nearby buildings.  

The issue isn’t overregulation or under-regulation, but enforcing effective regulations.

When the industry routinely commits hazardous violations, something is broken.  

No, these deaths aren’t on Mayor Mamdani.

But unless he sees this mass-scale tragedy as part of a bigger crisis, the next ones will be.  

Nicole Gelinas is a contributing editor to the Manhattan Institute’s City Journal and a 2026 CCNY Moynihan Center fellow.