17 women’s shackets we love for layering in every style for fall 2024
· New York PostIt’s true. Sporting one of the best women’s shackets (you know, the lovechild of the shirt and a jacket) is a testament to the fall season — just as much as drinking the Starbucks fall menu.
You’ve probably seen a closet’s worth of shackets clogging up your Instagram feed — and, for a good reason. It’s one of the easiest ways to elevate your look for transitional seasons, and one of the cheapest, especially if you take the Amazon route.
Maybe you gravitate toward a denim style, or something leather, or perhaps, the more traditional flannel shacket. With a good pair of booties, a solid bodysuit, or perhaps some loungewear and classic gold accessories, you’ll be looking like a rockstar en route to pumpkin picking this fall, too.
Oh, and this isn’t our first outerwear rodeo. We’re all about this year’s hottest rain jackets, puffer jackets, and *oh-so-cool* winter coats you’ll want to snatch up before the crowd swarms to them.
Below, find our edit of the 17 best women’s shackets to sport this season, along with versatile options to carry you all the way to spring. After all, it’s not time for the tried-and-true down coat or sherpa jacket just yet.
post wanted picks
- Best Overall Shacket for Women: Madewell Belrose Shirt-Jacket
- Best Flannel Shacket: Thread & Supply Plain Polar Fleece Shacket
- Best Petite Shacket: L.L. Bean Women’s 1912 Overshirt
- Best Leather Shacket: Quince 100% Leather Shirt
- Best Denim Shacket: Free People We The Free Opal Swing Denim Jacket
Best Shackets for Women
Best Overall Shacket for Women: Madewell Belrose Shirt-Jacket
Pros:
- Not too boxy, despite being oversized
- Beautiful, neutral colors
- Side pockets to keep hands warm
Cons:
- Some mention slightly itchy on the skin (best to layer)
Tired of searching for that perfect vintage flannel jacket? Well, skip the antique store and grab this instead. It’s made of Italian boucle, so you know you’ll have it for decades, and its slouchy shoulders and deep pockets will keep you cuddly and warm.
Customers are saying: “This is a great winter jacket. I have been loving the shirt-style jackets this season and this played the part wonderfully for me! I am petite, but I opted for the regular XXS, and while it fits oversized (as it’s meant to fit), it isn’t too oversized. I don’t feel it’s too boxy. The length is perfect on me, as is the sleeve length. The colors are beautiful and neutral.”
Size: XXS-XL | Colors: 3 | Materials: 37% post-consumer recycled wool, 24% viscose, 23% polyamide, 13% conventional wool, 3% other fibers
Best Flannel Shacket: Thread & Supply Plain Polar Fleece Shacket
Pros:
- Warm and cozy fabric, per many reviews
- Good quality considering the price
Cons:
- Some mention sleeves are a bit short
- Runs big
On the hunt for a shirt and a coat? The Thread & Supple Shacket has a slightly oversized fit that makes it a perfect addition to brace for the chilly weather we’re inevitably going to have. Customers suggest pairing it with your favorite pair of booties for a complete fall look.
Customers are saying: “I ordered this in last year’s sale in the camel color, and this year in the brown plaid both in (size) medium. These are soft and comfy. If you strive to be a basic chic at the pumpkin patch this year, this Shacket will not disappoint. Don’t forget the ankle booties to complete the look!”
Size: XS-XL | Colors: 3 | Materials: 100% polyester
Best Petite Shacket: L.L. Bean Women’s 1912 Overshirt
Pros:
- Extended sizing for different body types
- Heavy-duty materials hold up well
Cons:
- More of a casual style
Whether you’re petite, plus size, or somewhere in between, this is one of the best women’s shackets around. Its super soft twill is beyond warm, so you don’t need to bring another jacket “just in case” and there are eight different colors to choose from.
Customers are saying: “I absolutely love it. The colors are fabulous. It’s heavy-duty, true to size and structured. The sleeves and torso are the right length for me (petite, size large). The lining is a classy touch. I even like the buttons. Worth the splurge.”
Size: XS-XL (regular, petite, plus) | Colors: 5 | Materials: 100% polyester
Best Leather Shacket: Quince 100% Leather Shirt
Pros:
- Biodegradable material
- Soft, buttery leather
- Button front closure and adjustable button-closure cuffs
Cons:
- Fewer size options
When things get nippy but you’re not ready for a parka, go for something like this. It’s made of 100% grain leather and will last throughout the seasons. Drop shoulders, as well as adjustable button cuffs soften the shaket’s overall edgy look. Available in black, as well as a lovely tanned color called mushroom, and chocolate brown.
New York Post Tester: “I’ll be the first to admit, it’s a bit difficult to define a shacket,” admitted Commerce Reporter, Miska Salemann. “But if I had to try, I would simply point at this leather shirt jacket from Quince. I’ve worn it both as a shirt and layered it over a slim-fitting top as a jacket. The material is buttery-soft and drapes in all the right spots. I was afraid it would look boxy, but it had no such effect. It’s a more feminine style than you might imagine.”
Size: XS-XL | Colors: 3 | Materials: 100% leather, partial lining: 100% poly satin
Best Shacket on Amazon: AUTOMET Casual Flannel Plaid Shacket
Pros:
- Fuzz, cozy material
- Lots of colorways
- Nice look for the holidays
- Looks great paired with spandex or leggings
Cons:
- Less durable
Shakcets come in all forms, but when we find one on Amazon under $30, we do not wait. With the best-selling AUTOMET Casual Flannel Plaid Shacket, you’ll be ready to take on any fall festivity in style. Even better, there are a multitude of color options to choose from — fuzzy knit fabric aside.
Customers are saying: “I am SO glad I grabbed this!! The colors are true to the picture. I washed it in cold water and then put it in a dryer on the lightest setting before wearing and it is SO soft and cozy!! I don’t find it itchy at all.”
Sizes: XS to XXL | Colors: 27 | Material: 100% polyester
Best Zip Shacket: Gap Utility Jacket
Pros:
- Large, functional pockets
- Fits true to size, per customer reviews
- The lightweight material is comfy
Cons:
- Material is a bit on the thinner side (not ideal for freezing temps)
Straight-fitting and cute, this no-frills, relaxed-fitting utility shacket dresses up and down this season. Plus, the exaggerated hem detailing is everything! We love the forest green shade and only wish this best-selling shirt jacket came in a few more colors. At under $50, it’s a superb deal!
Customers are saying: “This Jacket is everything I expected. Fits true to size. I’m 5’8 and the large fits perfectly. I liked it so much that I bought another one for my daughter. She loves it. Wish there were more colors though.”
Size: XS-XXL | Colors: 1 | Materials: 100% cotton
Best Denim Shacket: Free People We The Free Opal Swing Denim Jacket
Pros:
- Variety of colorways
- Lightweight and not restrictive
- Double bust patch pockets
Cons:
- Running low on some sizes/colors
Add this to your bag ahead of your next weekend excursion to the woods. Its defined back pleating gives the denim shacket a swingy movement, while the double bust pockets offer extra storage. Our favorite feature? It’s available in lots of different colors!
New York Post Tester: “I’m not much of a denim jacket person, but I’ve been converted,” shared Salemann. “Free People’s Swing Jacket is far less bulky than other denim jackets that I’ve tried. The material seriously does swing with your body — it’s not restrictive at all. I could jog in this. Not to mention, the pockets offer ample storage. Even with my keys and phone piled in, the jacket is still light enough to easily layer over a t-shirt or even a fall sweater. I love the fact that it comes in a sea of flashy bright colors, but my dark-wash shade is so easy to pair that I can’t stop wearing it.”
Size: S-XXL | Colors: 7 | Materials: 100% cotton
Best Wool Shacket: BlankNYC Flannel Shacket
Pros:
- Made with wool, which has a temperature-regulating property
- Very bright, unique color combinations
Cons:
- Limited size options
- A bit itchy against the skin (best for layering)
Blair Waldorf inspired this shacket, no doubt about it. With a dainty blush, grey, and ivory plaid, it’s one to live in this season for a girly touch to any outfit. The incorporation of wool is sure to keep your body at just the right temperature — the material has natural regulating properties that make it ideal for transitional pieces.
Customers are saying: “The material is nice on the outside but isn’t lined. Feels kinda itchy if you don’t wear a long sleeve under. Otherwise, it fits pretty good and the price is great.”
Size: XS-L | Colors: 6 | Materials: 80% polyester, 20% wool
Best Quilted Shacket: Levi’s Women’s Diamond Quilted Lightweight Shirt Jacket
Pros:
- Unique Western styles
- High-quality material keeps in heat
- Room to move easily
Cons:
- The quilting is better for colder temperatures
If you’ve been waiting to nail the Western wear look, leave it to Levi’s. The denim masterminds also have a shacket for you. This cozy style is available with charming bandanna prints and unique diamond quilting for a laidback look with an edge-of-country style. Best of all, it’s adorned with lofty chest pockets that could even fit an iPhone.
Customers are saying: “Exact on sizing, plenty of room for movements, well made, a bit warm — made for those chilly days and it seems waterproof but (I) have not tested it. It looks prettier than the pictures.”
Size: XS-XXL | Colors: 12 | Materials: 55% polyester, 45% nylon
Best Splurge Shacket: Mother The Midi Chopper
Pros:
- Zip pockets for safe storage
- Versatile; can be worn through most seasons
- High-quality feel and look
Cons:
- More expensive than typical shackets
This glamorous piece may fall more into the jacket sphere, than the shacket category (though I argue you could rock it without a shirt beneath). However, it deserves a spot on this roundup because it serves up everything you’re looking for in a transitional piece for fall and spring — faux leather, a notched collar, zip pockets, and a gorgeous floral interior that might make you wish it was reversible.
Editor’s Note: “I strongly believe the purpose of a shacket should be that you don’t need to take it off,” said Salemann. “The Midi Chopper doesn’t need the help of a top. It shines alone. The mid-rise cut and cinched belt are ultra-flattering and ideal for layering. The deep burgundy brings a decadent contrast to a variety of denim shades. You can wear it inside, wear it outside, wear it through fall, winter, and spring. If you’re going to splurge, splurge on this.”
Size: XS-L | Colors: 1 | Materials: 50% polyester, 50% coated polyurethane, lining: 100% Polyester
Best Classic Shacket: Organic Cotton Denim Classic Shirt
Pros:
- Good length for tucking into pants
- Extended sizing for a variety of body types
- Lightweight material
Cons:
- Only available in one wash
- Not very warm
Out Updates Editor, Holly J Coley, has recently fallen back in love with Gap clothing, and this classic denim cut is among her favorite Fall pieces. It’s versatile, lightweight, and made with super-soft fabric (trust us, you won’t even believe it’s denim).
New York Post Tester: “I’ve recently re-fallen in love with Gap clothing and the Organic Cotton Denim Classic Shirt or ‘shacket’ is my latest find. It’s long enough for me to tuck into jeans or a skirt when I need to look more formal, but looks really cool worn as is when layered over a tee or tank. It’s soft and I love the spread collar, especially when left unbuttoned. It’s perfect for fall when the weather is unpredictable and you don’t know if it’s going to stay chilly or become warm,” said Coley.
Size: S-XXL (regular, tall, petite) | Colors: 1 | Materials: 100% cotton
Best Unisex Shacket: Faherty Comfort Twill Chore Jacket
Pros:
- Rare unisex style (nice for sharing!)
- Great sale feal going on now
- Bit of stretch
- Fits true to size, but our reviewer recommends that women size down
Cons:
- The style may be too “masculine” for shoppers
Let’s shine some light on a shacket that seemingly does it all. This one is technically made for men, but it’s loved by women, too. It’s got a touch of stretch, boasts interior and exterior patch pockets, and even is machine-washable, which seems to be a somewhat rare feature in the shacket department.
New York Post Tedster: “So, I originally bought this for my husband after visiting Paris, where everyone had a blue shacket that hit above the waist with a straight-cut edge at the bottom,” shared Commerce Reporter, Emma Sutton-Williams. “But it’s so cute that I wear it out on occasion. I’m 5’9 and purchased the men’s small. It’s a great unisex jacket that looks great on everyone, and since it’s a shacket, the oversized look on me looks just right.”
Size: S- XXL | Colors: 2 | Materials: 98% organic cotton, 2% spandex
Best Long Shacket: Aritzia Wilfred Free the Ganna Long Shirt Jacket
Pros:
- Extending sizing available
- Variety of colors
- Not too heavy, but still very warm
Cons:
- Some may not like the longer length, which is more of a style preference
- Runs large
This Wilfred Free classic delivers the warmth of a traditional jacket but does not falter when it comes to style and trendiness. The longer construction almost mimics the shape of a trench coat, with a slightly more relaxed fit. Best of all, it comes in a sea of colors and patterns that vary from soft pastels to richer Winter shades.
New York Post Tester: “As far as colorways go, Artizia has knocked it out of the park,” shared Salemann. “I’m yet to find a shacket that cleverly combines such rich, bold tones. It’s a clear low-effort statement price, and the materials are up to snuff too. The dense wool keeps you cool and cozy, and the longer hemline seals in that warmth on brisker mornings.”
Size: 2XS-2XL | Colors: 11 | Materials: 100% merino wool, lining: 100% cotton
Best Fleece Shacket: Columbia Women’s Benton Springs Fleece Shirt Jacket
Pros:
- Extended sizing
- Casual style
- Customers say it’s great for camping
Cons:
- Harder to wear with dressier outfits
Available in standard and plus size, this women’s fleece shacket has a menswear silhouette that we consider rugged-chic. We’d wear it with leggings, boots, and a cute beanie-style cap. If you don’t like it in red and black, it’s also available in three other colors.
Customers are saying: “This is the perfect shirt jacket for fall. It has a loose fit and is a little long in length and long sleeves for me (I’m short), but comfortable. I like it and have already worn it comfortably.”
Size: XS-XXL | Colors: 4 | Materials: 100% polyester, MTR filament fleece 250g, shell: 100% nylon
Best Plaid Shacket: L.L. Bean Women’s Brushed Plaid Shacket
Pros:
- Great for cooler temperatures
- Not too heavy but still keeps you warm
- Can be dressed up or down
Cons:
- More of a casual style
- Customers report some pilling
L.L. Bean calls this piece a “jacket replacement,” and we agree. According to reviews and our testing, it’s much warmer than it looks. For the ultimate casual style, throw this over a pair of leggings and call it a day.
New York Post Tester: “It’s really not surprising that L.L.Bean makes top-quality shackets. The brand is known for its grand variety of outerwear, and this plaid style does not disappoint. I would say that this one lands on the warmer side of the shacket category. The textured fabric offers great insulation, but doesn’t seem to stick to my skin like some other flannel-like materials.”
Size: XS-XL | Colors: 4 | Materials: 95% polyester, 5% wool
Best Corduroy Shackett: BWDIDACI Women’s Corduroy Button-down Shacket
Pros:
- Unique color options
- Can easily be worn tucked or untucked
- Soft and lightweight
Cons:
- Colors may appear a bit different than the photos (check reviews)
- Comes in only one size
This roundup would be incomplete without a beautiful forest green corduroy shacket (it comes in other colors too!). With two front pockets and impeccable button detailing, it’s a textured, chic statement piece to rock whenever you’re on the go.
Customers are saying: “Getting compliments from your fashionable 20-year-old kids is not something that happens every day! But when I put on this shirt over a solid color tee-shirt and dressed it up with a pair of dark jeans to head out to dinner, I got a nice compliment from my kids.”
Size: S | Colors: 4 | Materials: 100% corduroy
Shacket FAQs
What is a shacket?
There are some disputes on the definition of shacket. Most people agree that a shacket is simply the cross between a shirt and a jacket — something that draws features from both so that it could be worn alone or layered on top of other clothing. Shackets can be styled in many ways and are constructed with. variety of materials; cotton, denim, leather, and more.
What is the difference between a flannel and a shacket?
Flannel shirts and shackets may be easily confused, but they’re are a few key differences. Flannels are typically lighter weight, making them ideal for spring and summer wear occasions. Shackets, on the other hand, are heavier-weight and made to withstand cooler temperatures. While flannels are typically made just with cotton and wool, shackets also come in a wider variety of materials.
Check out the New York Post Shopping section for more content.
Why Trust Post Wanted by the New York Post
For over 200 years, the New York Post has been America’s go-to source for bold news, engaging stories, in-depth reporting, and now, insightful shopping guidance. We’re not just thorough reporters – we sift through mountains of information, test and compare products, and consult experts on any topics we aren’t already schooled specialists in to deliver useful, realistic product recommendations based on our extensive and hands-on analysis. Here at The Post, we’re known for being brutally honest – we clearly label partnership content, and whether we receive anything from affiliate links, so you always know where we stand. We routinely update content to reflect current research and expert advice, provide context (and wit) and ensure our links work. Please note that deals can expire, and all prices are subject to change.