Telangana State Committee of Human Rights Forum

HRF writes to TOMCOM board, seeks full refund for Germany batch

The forum said TOMCOM has failed to meet the level of transparency expected of a government agency.

by · The Siasat Daily

Hyderabad: The Human Rights Forum (HRF) has asked the Telangana Overseas Manpower Company Limited (TOMCOM) to refund all payments collected from candidates who approached it for jobs in Germany, saying the government-run agency must regain public trust.

In a letter to TOMCOM’s Board of Directors dated Monday, November 16, the HRF’s Hyderabad committee listed seven demands. The letter was signed by general secretary Sanjeev and secretary Talla Rohith.

The HRF said it wrote after meeting students from the Germany batch. It said they described severe difficulties, particularly over the role of Fairstreet India Pvt Ltd, the Lucknow firm that ran the training programmes. The forum said TOMCOM has failed to meet the level of transparency expected of a government agency. It added that TOMCOM was set up to be a trustworthy agency that does not dupe those seeking overseas jobs.

Paying TOMCOM, signing with Fairstreet

The first concern the HRF raised was about who candidates sign agreements with. Communication is handled by TOMCOM, and candidates pay TOMCOM, yet the candidate agreement form is signed with Fairstreet, the letter said. The forum said any legal agreement should be between the candidate and TOMCOM exclusively.

The HRF also wants TOMCOM to:

  • Tell candidates in writing which services are provided by third parties and which by TOMCOM itself.
  • Offer a day scholar option, since residential programmes are a heavy financial burden on candidates from poor families.
  • Publish the names of its third-party partners and the Memoranda of Understanding (MoUs) signed with them on its official website.
  • Maintain a public dashboard of every batch of trainees and placement figures, instead of confining its reported successes to a few individual stories on social media.
  • Correct the “Vacancies” tab on its platform, which the forum said wrongly gives the impression that TOMCOM itself is hiring.
  • Refund all payments collected from candidates who approached it for jobs in Germany.

The letter ended by saying the HRF hopes TOMCOM will succeed in placing candidates in overseas jobs according to their qualifications.

The background

Siasat.com has reported since October 16 on TOMCOM’s Germany programmes. Candidates stated that the no-refund agreement form was given to them only after they had paid the second instalment of Rs 1,16,700. TOMCOM counts 12 of the 79 candidates in its Germany apprenticeship, or Ausbildung, programme as deployed, a figure candidates dispute. When Siasat.com sought the MoU with Fairstreet under the Right to Information (RTI) Act, TOMCOM withheld it.

On Thursday, November 12, TOMCOM filed a complaint against Fairstreet, and the Hyderabad Central Crime Station (CCS) registered a First Information Report (FIR) the same day. The complaint alleges cheating, criminal breach of trust and misappropriation of funds. It says TOMCOM paid Fairstreet Rs 1.28 crore out of the money collected from 67 candidates, and that Fairstreet secured an overseas placement for only one of them.

The complaint came more than 15 months after the last batches finished training, and TOMCOM has not publicly explained its own role in overseeing the programmes. TOMCOM has emailed candidates about a refund process, but they told Siasat.com it is unclear how much will be refunded and on what basis.

An HRF team had earlier sought a probe into the Germany programme, and Bharat Rashtra Samithi (BRS) leaders have demanded a full refund and an independent inquiry.