Gov't list of locations with dangerous PFAS contamination riddled with errors
The government's list of PFAS-contaminated sites that need urgent remediation is riddled with errors, according to research by NOS and the regional broadcasters. Nearly half of the listed sites should be removed because it is unclear whether they pose a risk to the surrounding environment. And multiple well-known locations, like Schiphol Airport, are missing from the list.
Experts consulted by NOS called this list a clear example of the Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management’s chaotic and sluggish approach to the PFAS issue. "There is a real danger that, on one hand, high-risk sites might be overlooked, while on the other, resources could be wasted on the unnecessary remediation of other locations," Chiel Jonker, a PFAS expert at Utrecht University, told the broadcaster.
The Netherlands has many thousands of sites potentially contaminated with PFAS - a group of thousands of chemical substances that do not, or hardly, break down. More is being learned about the risks they entail, including affecting people’s immune system, liver, and cholesterol levels. PFAS have also been linked to kidney and testicular cancer.
The Cabinet asked 12 provinces and 29 major municipalities to identify which sites require urgent remediation. The criterion for such a “PFAS priority site” is that the location must pose “unacceptable risks” to humans. In May, the government reported that 57 sites have been identified. Last month, it published the list of locations following an appeal to the Open Government Act. They include airports, former ariports, military sites, and fire brigade training grounds, among others.
NOS and the regional broadcasters examined the lists and found numerous errors. For six of the 57 sites, there is no “unacceptable risk.” 20 sites are listed with the risk “not yet known.” And for another five, this field is left blank.
The Ministry referred NOS to the provinces and municipalities involved when asked about the errors. The broadcasters did so and received varied responses. The province of Zuid-Holland said that, when it compiled the list, “the definition [for a PFAS priority site] was not yet known.” Noord-Holland blamed an “administrative error” on its part. Nijmegen said the Ministry had asked for a list of “potentially high-risk sites.” The province of Groningen said that it has no sites listed because the submissions it provided were not in the format required by the Ministry.
Chiel Jonker, a PFAS expert at Utrecht University, is primarily concerned by the obvious and well-known sites missing from the list. He mentioned Schiphol Airport, in particular. “It is one of the largest PFAS-contaminated sites in the Netherlands, from which polluted water is actively being pumped out,” Jonker told NOS.
A spokesperson for Noord-Holland told the broadcaster that Schiphol poses no “acute risks to humans or threats to drinking water extraction.” But Jonker doubts that. "The water is used to irrigate farmland and vegetable gardens; people swim and fish in it, and it flows directly into the Amsterdamse Bos. And why are other airports included on the list, but not Schiphol?"
“This responsibility should not be placed on local authorities - that simply doesn’t work,” Jonker said. An issue this complex requires specialized expertise, which provincial and municipal authorities often don’t have access to.
Hans Slenders of the PFAS Expertise Centre agrees. "The PFAS issue is far too complex to be solved at a local level," he told the broadcaster. "The ministry needs to take the lead." Centralized management could also accelerate the process, he added. “It would provide local authorities with better tools and a necessary push. Right now, the decentralization is causing things to stall.”
The Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management told NOS that municipalities and provinces are well-informed about the definition of a “PFAS priority site” and are fully capable of assessing the associated risks.