Geo News issues clarification and apology over 10th Muharram documentary 'Safar-e-Ishq'

Geo News has acknowledged an editorial error regarding content aired during its 10th Muharram transmission, "Safar-e-Ishq", saying the footage neither reflected its editorial stance nor its policy of respecting the widely accepted beliefs and religious sensitivities of the Muslim Ummah.

The purpose of this clarification is not to justify the incident, but to acknowledge it honestly, explain the actions taken, and reaffirm our commitment to ensuring that such an incident never happens again.

1. We fully acknowledge the mistake.

What happened was wrong. We do not seek to defend, minimise, or rationalise it. We sincerely regret that this material was broadcast.

2. The incident was completely unintentional.

This was a grave editorial error. It was neither deliberate nor reflective of Geo News' editorial values or institutional beliefs. We are personally hurt—both religiously and emotionally—because the matter concerns values and beliefs that we ourselves deeply respect.

3. We identified and corrected the mistake ourselves.

The content was removed immediately after we ourselves realised the error, before any authority or individual formally approached us. This reflects our own internal sense of responsibility rather than a reaction to external pressure.

4. Immediate accountability was ensured.

Show-cause notices were issued to the reporter and the members of the editorial committee responsible for the lapse. A formal inquiry was initiated, and strict disciplinary action is being taken in accordance with our internal policies.

5. Stronger safeguards have been introduced.

We have strengthened our editorial approval procedures by introducing additional review mechanisms, enhanced supervision, and stricter compliance checks to minimise the possibility of any similar incident occurring in the future.

6. Our institutional record demonstrates our commitment.

For decades, Geo News has consistently worked to promote Islamic knowledge and values. We pioneered dedicated religious pages in our publications, launched Aalim Online, introduced Ramazan transmissions, and have consistently produced special programming for Hajj, Rabi-ul-Awwal, Muharram, and other important Islamic occasions. Our long record reflects our genuine commitment to serving the religious interests of our audience with sincerity and respect.

7. Our overall contribution should be viewed fairly.

One regrettable mistake should not overshadow years of responsible work and sincere efforts made in promoting religious understanding and serving millions of viewers.

8. Human error is never an excuse—but it is a reality.

A 24-hour news organisation makes thousands of editorial decisions every day under continuous deadlines. While human error can unfortunately occur in any institution, it can never be an excuse. The true measure of an organisation is how it responds when a mistake occurs. Our responsibility is to acknowledge it immediately, correct it, hold those responsible accountable, and strengthen our systems to prevent any recurrence.

9. Our institutional culture is based on accountability.

Whenever we identify a mistake, we do not deny it or attempt to shift responsibility. We acknowledge it openly, investigate it thoroughly, hold individuals accountable where appropriate, and continuously improve our editorial processes.

10. Transparency strengthens public trust.

We believe responsible institutions should encourage a culture in which mistakes are admitted honestly, accountability is enforced fairly, and systems are continuously improved rather than mistakes being concealed or ignored.

11. Greater reach brings greater scrutiny.

As the most widely watched Urdu news channel in the world, every aspect of our programming is examined closely. Even minor errors receive widespread attention. We accept this responsibility because public trust must always be earned through transparency and accountability.

12. Continuous improvement remains our commitment.

This incident has reinforced our determination to further strengthen editorial oversight, staff training, internal compliance, and quality control so that our standards continue to improve.

13. We have no agenda contrary to Islamic values.

Geo News has always respected the religious beliefs and sensitivities of the Muslim Ummah.

Geo News’ unconditional apology

In an earlier statement, the broadcaster said the programme had depicted certain rituals practised by a limited number of people in Iraq and some other Middle Eastern countries. It clarified that the footage merely portrayed local customs and was never intended to represent, endorse, or promote any broader religious viewpoint.

Geo News said the material was neither produced by the channel nor aired with any deliberate intent or objective.

The broadcaster reiterated that it remains firmly committed to its policy of respecting the widely accepted beliefs and sensitivities of the Muslim Ummah, adding that the inclusion of the footage did not reflect its editorial position or institutional ideology.

It said the relevant content was removed immediately after the issue came to light, while prompt action was taken against those involved in its inclusion.

Geo News further stated that clarifications and an apology had been aired before the public reaction emerged. The channel expressed regret over any distress caused and reaffirmed its commitment to upholding the highest standards of religious respect.

PEMRA issues notice

The Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (PEMRA) has issued a notice to Geo News, ordering the suspension of its transmission for 15 days.

According to the regulator's order, Geo News' broadcasts will remain suspended on satellite and all other transmission networks. PEMRA further directed that its Complaints Council will hear the matter for further proceedings and formulate recommendations for additional regulatory action.